Aldi's $2M Slip-and-Fall Verdict Puts Georgia's New Collateral Source Rule to Its First Test
Aldi used SB 68's collateral-source provision to put a Georgia slip-and-fall plaintiff's health insurance before the jury even though she had dropped her medical expense claim. A roughly $2 million verdict followed, and the trial bar now has its first look at how O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1.1 works in a courtroom.
Torts Desk··17 min read

Aldi used the collateral-source provision of Georgia's 2025 tort reform law, Senate Bill 68, to put a slip-and-fall plaintiff's health insurance in front of the jury even though she had already withdrawn her claim for medical expenses, and the jury still returned a verdict of roughly $2 million, the Daily Report reported on November 10, 2026. It is the first reported trial test of the new Georgia collateral source rule codified at O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1.1, and it raises a question none of the statute's early commentary answered: what the provision is for when a plaintiff stops asking for medical bills at all.
A lawyer quoted in the Daily Report called the trial the law's first "stress test." The label fits. Section 51-12-1.1 was written to end what its supporters called "phantom damages," the gap between what hospitals bill and what insurers actually pay. The Aldi plaintiff appears to have tried to take that fight off the table entirely by giving up her medical special damages, and the grocery chain nonetheless used the statute to tell the jury she was insured. How Georgia's appellate courts treat that move will shape premises liability, trucking and auto trials across the state for years.
What happened in the Aldi slip-and-fall case in Georgia?
According to the Daily Report's account, a customer who fell at an Aldi store sued the grocer in a Georgia court under a premises liability theory, and a jury returned a verdict of about $2 million. Before trial, the plaintiff withdrew her claim for medical expenses. Aldi then invoked the collateral-source provision added by SB 68 to put her health insurance before the jury anyway.
The publicly available portion of the report does not identify the court, the county, the presiding judge or the plaintiff, does not give the exact verdict figure or its breakdown between categories of damages, and does not say whether Aldi has filed a motion for new trial or notice of appeal. Those details are omitted here rather than guessed. What is established is the sequence that makes the case significant:
- The plaintiff's fall was recent enough for the 2025 statute to apply, since the medical-expense provisions reach only causes of action arising on or after April 21, 2025.
- She dropped medical special damages, the category § 51-12-1.1 regulates.
- Aldi persuaded the trial court to let the jury learn of her health insurance regardless.
- The jury still awarded about $2 million, which, with no medical expenses in the case, must consist mostly or entirely of noneconomic damages such as pain and suffering, plus any lost earnings claimed.
That last point is the immediate practical lesson. Whatever the insurance evidence was meant to accomplish, it did not produce a small verdict. Whether it should have been admitted at all is the legal question the case now poses.
What is the Georgia collateral source rule?
The Georgia collateral source rule is a common law doctrine that bars a defendant from reducing its liability, or from telling the jury, that the plaintiff's losses were covered by an independent source such as health insurance, disability benefits, or gratuitous payments. The rationale is that a wrongdoer should not get the benefit of insurance the victim paid for or of generosity extended to the victim.
Georgia courts applied the rule broadly to medical expenses. Before SB 68, a plaintiff could prove the full amount billed by providers, and the defense generally could not introduce the lower amount the plaintiff's health insurer actually paid under its negotiated contract. Defense-side commentators, including Shook, Hardy & Bacon, describe the old regime as one in which jurors saw the provider's list price and never learned what had actually been paid. The difference between those two numbers, often large for hospital care, is what reform advocates called phantom damages.
The rule had exceptions. Collateral-source evidence could come in for a valid purpose unrelated to reducing damages, for example to impeach a plaintiff who testified that unpaid bills caused financial hardship. But as a default, insurance was out of the courtroom.
The 1987 statute and Denton v. Con-Way
The General Assembly tried once before to change this. In 1987 it enacted O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1(b), which allowed the jury to consider evidence of benefits or payments available to the plaintiff for any claimed special damages. In Denton v. Con-Way Southern Express, Inc., 261 Ga. 41, 402 S.E.2d 269 (1991), the Supreme Court of Georgia declared that subsection void. The plurality rested on the Georgia Constitution's equal protection guarantee, while a concurrence found the statute unconstitutionally vague. Later Georgia decisions held that Denton's effect was to restore the common law collateral source rule to where it stood before 1987, and the court subsequently disapproved Denton to the extent it suggested a new equal protection analysis.
That history explains the careful drafting of the 2025 statute, which is far narrower than the 1987 version: it reaches only medical and health care expenses, it frames its evidence as bearing on the reasonable value of care rather than as an offset, and it says it abrogates the common law rule only "to the extent necessary."
Did SB 68 abolish Georgia's collateral source rule?
No. SB 68 narrowed the Georgia collateral source rule for medical and health care expenses but did not abolish it. New O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1.1 abrogates the common law rule only to the extent necessary to admit the billed-versus-paid evidence the section describes, and the common law rule still governs other collateral benefits and all injuries that predate April 21, 2025.
Gov. Brian Kemp signed SB 68 on April 21, 2025, as one half of a two-bill package. Its companion, SB 69, regulates Third-Party Litigation Funding through registration and disclosure. SB 68 itself contained the medical-expense provision alongside limits on anchoring noneconomic damages in closing argument, a right to bifurcated trials, changes to negligent security liability, admissibility of seatbelt non-use, and new limits on voluntary dismissal.
Section 51-12-1.1, subsection by subsection
| Subsection | What it does | Practical effect |
|---|---|---|
| (b) | Limits special damages for medical and health care expenses to the reasonable value of medically necessary care, treatment or services, with the amount set by the trier of fact | Billed charges are no longer the presumptive measure; the jury decides reasonable value |
| (c) | Where the plaintiff has health insurance, relevant evidence of reasonable value includes both the amounts charged and the amounts actually necessary to satisfy those charges under the insurance contract | Juries see the negotiated, paid figure, reportedly even if the plaintiff chose not to use the coverage |
| (d) | Where treatment was provided under a letter of protection or similar arrangement, makes relevant and discoverable a copy of the letter, itemized coded charges, any sale of the receivable to a third party (buyer and price), and whether a referral was made and by whom | Opens the lawyer-provider-factoring chain to discovery |
| (e) | Abrogates the common law collateral source rule to the extent necessary to introduce the evidence described; the court may instruct the jury on its proper use | Narrow abrogation, designed with Denton in mind |
| (f) | Preserves each side's right to challenge the reasonableness or medical necessity of past or projected expenses | Billing and coding experts remain central |
Three features matter for the Aldi problem. The statute is framed around special damages for medical expenses. Its stated purpose for the insurance evidence is proving reasonable value. And its abrogation of the common law rule is expressly limited. Each of those features is a reason to ask what work the statute does once medical expenses are out of the case.
Can a jury hear about health insurance in a Georgia personal injury case?
Yes, for injuries on or after April 21, 2025 where medical expenses are claimed: under § 51-12-1.1(c), the jury may hear both what providers billed and what was actually necessary to satisfy those charges under the plaintiff's health insurance contract. Outside that setting, the common law collateral source rule still generally keeps insurance out unless the evidence serves another legitimate purpose.
Several Georgia plaintiff-side firms, including Hasner Law and the authors of the legalaid-ga.org explainer, read subsection (c) to admit the insurance-contract rate even when the plaintiff did not submit the bills to the insurer, for instance because a provider treated under a letter of protection. One commentator has argued that the drafting of that clause covers health insurance but may not reach workers' compensation coverage the plaintiff did not use; that reading has not been tested in a reported decision.
Two limits are worth noting. First, the statute speaks of evidence of amounts, not of the mere existence of a policy; how much a defendant may say about coverage beyond the paid figures is a matter for the trial court's instructions under subsection (e). Second, subsection (f) keeps the door open for the plaintiff to argue that the paid figure understates reasonable value, and for the defense to argue that even the paid figure covered unnecessary care.
What happens if a plaintiff drops the claim for medical expenses?
If a plaintiff drops the claim for medical expenses, the plaintiff gives up recovery of those special damages, and on the statute's text the trigger for § 51-12-1.1's insurance evidence, a claim for special damages for medical and health care expenses, arguably disappears with it. The Aldi trial is the first reported instance of a court allowing a defendant to use the provision anyway, which is why it is being called a stress test.
The plaintiff-side logic of withdrawal is straightforward. If a jury will see that a $90,000 hospital bill was satisfied for $22,000, the marginal value of the medical-expense claim falls sharply, while the risk that jurors anchor on the smaller number, or conclude that someone else already made the plaintiff whole, rises. Dropping the claim sacrifices a discounted item of damages to keep insurance out of the jury's thinking about pain and suffering.
The defense-side logic for using the statute anyway, as reported, is less obvious from the text, and the publicly available account does not set out Aldi's precise argument. Possible theories a defendant might advance in this posture include:
- Relevance to noneconomic damages. Treatment history and its cost can bear on the severity of an injury; a defendant may argue that the jury cannot assess pain and suffering fairly while being told nothing about what treatment cost.
- Completeness and impeachment. If the plaintiff testifies about the course of treatment, financial strain or decisions to forgo care, the defense may argue that insurance evidence becomes relevant to credibility, an exception that predates SB 68.
- Legislative purpose. A defendant may argue that the General Assembly's abrogation of the common law rule reflects a policy that juries should not be shielded from the fact of insurance in injury cases generally.
Each faces a textual counterargument. Subsection (e) abrogates the common law rule only "to the extent necessary" to introduce the evidence the section describes, and that evidence is defined by reference to proving the reasonable value of medical expenses that are being claimed. With no medical-expense claim, a plaintiff will argue, there is nothing for the insurance evidence to prove, and the common law collateral source rule returns in full. Georgia's general relevance and prejudice rules under the 2013 Evidence Code would also apply, and a plaintiff can argue that telling jurors about insurance invites the very offset reasoning the surviving common law rule forbids.
How an appellate court resolves that debate will decide whether withdrawal remains a viable plaintiff tactic. If the Court of Appeals holds that § 51-12-1.1 applies only when medical expenses are claimed, plaintiffs gain a clean choice between seeking medical specials and keeping insurance out. If it holds that the statute, or ordinary relevance, lets insurance in regardless, the withdrawal tactic loses most of its value and plaintiffs will usually prefer to claim the paid amounts.
Does SB 68 apply to injuries before April 21, 2025?
No. The medical-expense provisions of SB 68, including § 51-12-1.1, apply only to causes of action arising on or after April 21, 2025, according to Jones Day and other summaries of the enrolled bill; earlier injuries remain under Georgia's common law collateral source rule even if the case is tried today. The same prospective-only rule applies to SB 68's negligent security, seatbelt evidence and litigation-financing discovery provisions.
The other procedural pieces of SB 68 are different. Practitioner summaries report that the anchoring limits, the bifurcation right and several other procedural provisions took effect immediately and apply to pending cases, though the Court of Appeals has refused to apply the anchoring amendments to trials held before the statute's effective date. The result is a split regime that will last for several more years: a 2024 fall tried in 2027 is governed by the old collateral source rule but by the new anchoring limits, while a 2025 fall like the Aldi plaintiff's is governed by both.
| Issue | Injury before April 21, 2025 | Injury on or after April 21, 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Medical expenses measure | Billed amounts, common law collateral source rule | Reasonable value; billed and paid amounts both admissible (§ 51-12-1.1) |
| Health insurance evidence | Generally excluded | Paid amounts admissible where medical expenses claimed; scope after withdrawal now being tested |
| Letter of protection discovery | Ordinary discovery rules | Letter, coded charges, receivable sales and referrals discoverable (§ 51-12-1.1(d)) |
| Anchoring in closing (§ 9-10-184) | New limits apply to trials after the effective date | New limits apply |
| Bifurcation on request | Available on request in pending cases, per practitioner summaries | Available; may be denied only below $150,000 in controversy or in certain cases involving sexual offenses against minors |
Are letters of protection discoverable in Georgia after SB 68?
Yes. For causes of action arising on or after April 21, 2025, § 51-12-1.1(d) makes a letter of protection relevant and discoverable, along with itemized coded charges, the identity of any third party that bought the provider's receivable and the price it paid, and whether the plaintiff was referred for treatment and by whom.
Letters of protection matter to the Aldi problem because they are the main way uninsured or underinsured plaintiffs obtain care, and because they produce the largest gaps between billed and paid amounts when a provider sells the receivable to a factoring company at a discount. Subsection (d) means that a plaintiff treated under a letter of protection who keeps the medical-expense claim will face discovery into the referral chain and the receivable sale; a plaintiff who drops the claim may hope to avoid that discovery entirely. That is another reason the Aldi ruling on the scope of the statute will matter, especially for practices that rely on referral relationships with treating providers and for funders that buy medical receivables. Any Medical Lien asserted against the recovery is a separate question, but its amount will increasingly be compared with what the jury was told.
Is Georgia's new collateral source law constitutional?
It has not been tested. As of Best Lawyers' October 19, 2026 review of the reforms' first eighteen months, no constitutional challenge to SB 68 had been filed, although the law was drafted with such challenges in mind. The obvious grounds are the Georgia Constitution's equal protection and due process guarantees relied on in Denton v. Con-Way in 1991, and the right to jury trial that the Supreme Court of Georgia used in Atlanta Oculoplastic Surgery, P.C. v. Nestlehutt (2010) to strike down the 2005 cap on noneconomic damages in medical malpractice cases.
The 2025 drafters made choices that distinguish § 51-12-1.1 from both precedents. It caps nothing; the jury still decides reasonable value. It admits evidence rather than mandating an offset. And it limits its abrogation of the common law rule to what is "necessary." A court applying the statute to a plaintiff who has dropped medical expenses would be stretching it beyond those limits, which is one reason a plaintiff in the Aldi posture may prefer to argue statutory scope rather than constitutionality: the narrower argument avoids asking the Supreme Court of Georgia to strike a signature statute.
How Georgia compares with Florida's 2023 reform
Georgia's provision follows the path Florida took in its 2023 tort reform law, HB 837, which created Fla. Stat. § 768.0427. Both states now admit what health coverage actually pays and require disclosure of letter-of-protection arrangements, but they differ in detail.
| Feature | Georgia § 51-12-1.1 (2025) | Florida § 768.0427 (2023) |
|---|---|---|
| Damages measure | Reasonable value of medically necessary care, set by the trier of fact | Evidence limited by statute; damages may not exceed amounts actually paid, owed or necessary to satisfy charges |
| Insured plaintiff | Billed and insurance-contract amounts both admissible | Amount health coverage is obligated to pay admissible |
| Letters of protection | Letter, coded charges, receivable sales and referrals discoverable | Detailed disclosure of letter of protection and related arrangements required |
| Common law rule | Abrogated only "to the extent necessary" | Displaced for medical-expense evidence |
| Constitutional history | 1987 predecessor struck in Denton (1991) | No comparable precedent |
The comparison matters because Florida's statute has been in force two years longer, and its text is more prescriptive: subsection (4) caps recoverable past medical damages at amounts actually paid, amounts necessary to satisfy charges still owed, and amounts needed for reasonable future care. Georgia instead left the reasonable-value question to the jury. Georgia courts are not bound by Florida decisions, but defense and plaintiff counsel are likely to cite them as persuasive authority while the Aldi question works its way up.
What the Georgia collateral source rule test means for litigants
For defendants and their insurers
The Aldi trial shows that a defendant can ask a trial court to apply § 51-12-1.1 aggressively, and that at least one court agreed. It also shows the limits: introducing insurance did not keep the verdict small. Defense counsel planning to use the provision after a plaintiff withdraws medical expenses should expect the admission to be the lead issue on any appeal and should build a record tying the evidence to a purpose other than offset. Retailers and trucking carriers will also want to coordinate collateral-source strategy with SB 68's anchoring limits and bifurcation right, since a bifurcated damages phase changes when and how insurance evidence lands.
For plaintiffs' counsel
Withdrawing medical special damages is no longer a guaranteed way to keep insurance out of the courtroom, at least until an appellate court rules. The choice now carries two risks: the plaintiff gives up recoverable damages, and the jury may hear about insurance anyway. Firms evaluating 2025-and-later injuries should model both outcomes, preserve objections under subsection (e) and the Evidence Code, request limiting instructions, and be prepared to argue that the statute's text confines it to cases claiming medical expenses. Contingency Fee economics also shift, since a case without medical specials depends more heavily on noneconomic damages that SB 68's anchoring rules make harder to argue.
For medical providers, factoring companies and funders
Subsection (d) already exposes receivable sales and referral relationships when medical expenses are claimed. If Aldi's approach is endorsed on appeal, plaintiffs will have less incentive to drop medical claims to avoid that discovery, and more letter-of-protection arrangements will be examined in front of juries. Funders operating under SB 69's registration regime face a parallel transparency push.
For other states watching
Georgia's reforms are being watched as a model. The Best Lawyers review predicted that other states would copy the bifurcation and disclosure rules if they survive legal challenge. A clear appellate answer on the collateral-source provision's scope will be part of that record.
What to watch next
- Post-trial motions in the Aldi case. Any motion for new trial or appeal by either side will frame the first appellate test of § 51-12-1.1.
- Court of Appeals decisions on SB 68. The Court of Appeals' October 29, 2026 Walmart anchoring decision showed it will enforce SB 68's procedural provisions strictly; a collateral-source ruling would complete the picture.
- A constitutional challenge. No challenge had been filed as of October 2026; a trial-level ruling stretching the statute beyond medical-expense claims may prompt one.
- Jury instructions. Subsection (e) lets courts instruct juries on collateral-source evidence; pattern instructions have not yet settled.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Georgia collateral source rule after SB 68?
It is the common law doctrine barring defendants from using a plaintiff's insurance or other independent benefits to reduce damages, now narrowed by O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1.1 for medical expenses on injuries arising on or after April 21, 2025, so that juries may see both billed and insurance-paid amounts.
What did Aldi do in the Georgia slip-and-fall trial?
According to the Daily Report's November 10, 2026 report, Aldi used SB 68's collateral-source provision to put the plaintiff's health insurance before the jury even though she had withdrawn her medical expense claim, and the jury still returned a verdict of about $2 million.
Can a Georgia jury reduce my award because I have health insurance?
The jury may hear the amounts your insurer actually paid when you claim medical expenses for an injury on or after April 21, 2025, and it decides the reasonable value of the care; the statute does not order an automatic deduction, and the common law rule still bars using insurance as an offset in other respects.
Does withdrawing the medical expense claim keep insurance out of a Georgia trial?
Not reliably. The Aldi trial is the first reported case in which a court let a defendant use § 51-12-1.1 after the plaintiff dropped medical expenses, and the question of whether the statute reaches that situation has not yet been decided on appeal.
When did Georgia's new collateral source rule take effect?
Gov. Brian Kemp signed SB 68 on April 21, 2025, and its medical-expense provisions apply only to causes of action arising on or after that date.
Has anyone challenged SB 68 as unconstitutional?
Not as of October 2026. The 1987 predecessor statute was struck down in Denton v. Con-Way Southern Express (1991), so a challenge to § 51-12-1.1 is widely expected, but none had been filed by the time of Best Lawyers' October 19, 2026 review.
This article is analysis of reported developments and statutory text and is not legal advice.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Georgia Anchoring Law: Walmart Wins New Trial as Appeals Court Voids $975,000 Slip-and-Fall Verdict
On October 29, 2026 the Georgia Court of Appeals backed Walmart's bid for a new trial after a $975,000 slip-and-fall verdict, holding that the plaintiff's closing-argument dollar comparisons for pain and suffering broke the 2025 SB 68 amendment to OCGA § 9-10-184.
Torts Desk · 15 min

Texas Tort Reform in 2027: Democratic Sweep Leaves SB 30's Revival Facing a Veto and a New Senate Gatekeeper
Bill filing for the 2027 Texas Legislature opened November 9 after Democrats won the governor's office, the lieutenant governor's post and the House. Texas tort reform in 2027 now needs a Democratic governor's signature, which makes a rerun of the failed SB 30 damages bill far less likely.
Policy Desk · 15 min

Largest Personal Injury Verdicts of 2026: 12 of the Top 17 Are on Appeal, Reduced or Uncollectable
A November 11 review of the largest personal injury verdicts of 2026 finds 12 of the 17 biggest jury awards are on appeal, cut after trial or entered against a bankrupt or imprisoned defendant. Those 12 make up $4.61 billion of $5.24 billion, and none of the 17 is confirmed paid in full.
Torts Desk · 17 min