Ace Hardware Arbitration Ruling: Judge Davila Sends Cookie Banner Tracking Class Action to Arbitration
A federal judge in San Jose has ordered the Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware cookie-tracking class action into arbitration, finding the retailer's cookie banner gave 'reasonably conspicuous' notice of its terms of use. The claims now face Ace's staged, JAMS-administered mass arbitration protocol.
Courts Desk··14 min read

The Ace Hardware arbitration ruling sends a nationwide cookie-tracking class action out of federal court: on Nov. 9, 2026, Judge Edward J. Davila of the Northern District of California granted Ace Hardware Corp.'s motion to compel arbitration in Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corp., finding the retailer's cookie banner gave visitors "reasonably conspicuous" notice of its terms of use. The three named plaintiffs must now pursue their wiretap claims individually under Ace's arbitration terms, which channel coordinated filings into a staged mass arbitration administered by JAMS.
The decision matters beyond one hardware chain. It is the third reported order from the same federal district this year in which a cookie banner, the pop-up built to collect tracking consent, also did the work of binding a visitor to an arbitration agreement and a class action waiver. For plaintiffs' firms that have filed waves of "broken banner" suits under the federal Wiretap Act and the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), the Ace Hardware arbitration ruling narrows the courtroom path. For companies, it confirms that the banner's wording and layout now carry contract-formation consequences.
What did the court decide in the Ace Hardware arbitration ruling?
Judge Davila granted Ace's motion to compel arbitration, stayed the lawsuit rather than dismissing it, and terminated Ace's separate motion to dismiss as moot. According to the docket, the two motions had been taken under submission on Sept. 3, 2026, and the order issued two months later. The court directed the parties to file a report within 10 days after a final resolution in arbitration.
Two findings did the work, according to Bloomberg Law and MediaPost coverage of the order:
- Notice. Ace's cookie banner linked to the terms of use and offered visitors three choices: accept all cookies, accept only necessary cookies, or manage preferences. The court found that this presentation gave "reasonably conspicuous" notice that the terms existed and applied.
- A valid agreement and delegation. The court treated the arbitration contract in Ace's terms of use as valid and enforceable, and reports say it left the question of arbitrability, meaning whether these particular claims fall within the clause, to the arbitrator.
The second point is significant. Where an arbitration agreement contains a clear Delegation Clause, a court's job under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) shrinks to deciding whether an agreement was formed at all. Scope disputes and many enforceability challenges, including some Unconscionability arguments aimed at the clause as a whole, become Gateway Questions for the arbitrator. Formation, however, always stays with the court, which is why the notice-and-assent analysis was the main event.
Because the order compels arbitration and stays the case, the plaintiffs generally cannot appeal immediately. Section 16 of the FAA allows interlocutory appeals from orders denying arbitration, not from orders granting it with a stay, so appellate review of Judge Davila's notice finding would ordinarily wait until after arbitration ends.
What is the Ace Hardware privacy lawsuit about?
The case was filed on March 12, 2026, in the Northern District of California and assigned to Judge Davila in San Jose as No. 5:26-cv-02151. The named plaintiffs are Scott Pflaumer of California, Hans Cummings of Indiana and Mark Rosenthal of Colorado. They sued on behalf of a proposed nationwide class and a California subclass, represented by Janove PLLC and Levi & Korsinsky LLP.
The complaint attacks the gap between what a consent banner promises and what a browser actually does. It alleges that:
- Tracking technologies loaded the moment a visitor arrived, before the visitor could interact with the banner.
- Tools from Google Analytics, Bazaarvoice and other third parties collected browsing information such as search terms, product views and device identifiers.
- Those tools kept firing after visitors chose to opt out of non-essential cookies, so data was transmitted to advertising partners against the visitors' stated choice.
On that theory, the banner is both the promise of privacy and the evidence of its breach. The plaintiffs pleaded claims under the federal Wiretap Act and CIPA, the 1967 California statute that plaintiffs' firms have used against website tracking because it authorizes statutory damages per violation. Ace had urged the court to dismiss the case outright or send it to arbitration, arguing among other things that the alleged harm was not "concrete" enough to support standing in federal court. The arbitration order means the court never reached those merits and standing arguments.
Why did the judge send the Ace Hardware lawsuit to arbitration?
Online contract formation in California federal courts turns on the two-part test the Ninth Circuit applied in Berman v. Freedom Financial Network (2022) and refined in Chabolla v. ClassPass (2025). A website's terms bind a user who did not read them only if (1) the site gave reasonably conspicuous notice of the terms, and (2) the user took some action, such as clicking a button or checking a box, that unambiguously manifested assent to them.
Courts often sort online agreements into categories:
| Format | How assent is shown | Typical result |
|---|---|---|
| Clickwrap | User checks a box or clicks "I agree" to the terms themselves | Usually enforced |
| Sign-in wrap | User clicks a button (sign up, continue) next to text saying that doing so accepts linked terms | Enforced only if notice is conspicuous and the text ties the click to assent |
| Browsewrap | Terms are linked somewhere on the page; use of the site is said to be acceptance | Rarely enforced without actual knowledge |
| Cookie-banner wrap | A consent banner says clicking a cookie choice, or continuing to browse, accepts linked terms | Enforced in three 2026 N.D. Cal. orders; still developing |
Ace's banner, as described in coverage of the ruling, stated that continuing to browse meant accepting the terms of use, and the "terms of use" link was set off in capitalized, bold, blue, underlined text. That styling answers the conspicuousness concern that sank the defendant in Nader v. LendingTree, decided by the Ninth Circuit on Nov. 4, 2026, where the court found terms displayed in type considerably smaller than the surrounding text. The banner also forced an interaction: a visitor had to choose among accept-all, necessary-only, or manage-choices before the banner went away.
The more contestable question is assent. A banner that equates "continuing to browse" with acceptance sounds like a classic browsewrap, which the Ninth Circuit rejected in Perkins v. Rugs.com on Oct. 28, 2026. The difference courts have drawn in the cookie cases is that the visitor must click something in the banner itself, so there is an affirmative act located next to the disclosure. The published coverage does not quote the order's reasoning on assent in full, and the plaintiffs' best argument on any later appeal is likely to be that clicking a privacy control is not an unambiguous manifestation of assent to an unrelated dispute-resolution contract.
How does this compare with the NVIDIA and Harbor Freight cookie banner rulings?
The Ace Hardware arbitration ruling extends a line of 2026 decisions from the same courthouse, each involving a privacy suit alleging that a site ignored opt-out choices.
| Case | Court and judge | Date | Banner design | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Penning v. NVIDIA Corp., No. 5:25-cv-09160 | N.D. Cal., Magistrate Judge Susan van Keulen | May 21, 2026 | Persistent banner; clicking any button accepted the Terms of Service; terms link sat directly above the buttons | Individual arbitration compelled; CIPA and common-law claims stayed |
| Alba v. Harbor Freight Tools USA, Inc., No. 5:26-cv-01069 | N.D. Cal., Judge Beth Labson Freeman | July 27, 2026 | Banner updated around Oct. 31, 2024 to say clicking any button, including a rejection, accepted Terms and Conditions; banner redisplayed until the user interacted | Arbitration compelled; case stayed |
| Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corp., No. 5:26-cv-02151 | N.D. Cal., Judge Edward J. Davila | Nov. 9, 2026 | Banner linked terms of use in capitalized, bold, blue, underlined text; continuing to browse meant acceptance; accept-all, necessary-only and manage-choices options | Arbitration compelled; arbitrability left to arbitrator; case stayed |
Three patterns run through the trio. First, each banner tied an action the visitor had to take to acceptance of the broader terms, not just to cookie settings. Second, each defendant came forward with evidence of what the banner looked like when the plaintiff visited; in Alba, the plaintiff's failure to submit a declaration rebutting Harbor Freight's evidence was decisive. Third, in Penning, the plaintiff's own complaint described reading and relying on the banner, which made it hard to deny notice of what the banner said.
Commentators have not all welcomed the trend. Eric Goldman criticized Alba for treating a click on "Reject All Cookies" as agreement to arbitrate, calling that reading extremely expansive. Other practitioners note a tension that runs the other way: a banner can satisfy a privacy regulator's consent expectations and still be too ambiguous to form an arbitration agreement.
How does the Ninth Circuit's recent run of arbitration denials fit?
The district-court wins for cookie-banner defendants arrive in the same fortnight as three Ninth Circuit affirmances that went against companies seeking arbitration:
- Perkins v. Rugs.com (Oct. 28, 2026): an email sign-up with a "Join Now" button and a terms link was not assent under Washington law, and site use alone was a browsewrap that bound no one.
- Nader v. LendingTree (Nov. 4, 2026), arising from the Snowflake data breach MDL in the District of Montana: the LendingTree and QuoteWizard sites did not provide reasonably conspicuous notice because the terms appeared in small type.
- The Yippee Entertainment video-privacy appeal (early November 2026): after an earlier panel found the terms conspicuous, the district court on remand held that users never manifested assent, because the advisal said users agreed by "clicking below" without making clear which of several clickable items counted. The Ninth Circuit affirmed.
These outcomes are consistent with the Ace order. All apply the same two-part test, and the losing designs failed on a specific, fixable point: small font, a non-committal button, or an ambiguous instruction. The cookie-banner cases succeeded where the banner was prominent, persistent until engaged, and explicit that the click accepted the terms. The doctrine is not shifting; companies are learning to build the record it demands. Several of the Ninth Circuit rulings were unpublished memorandum dispositions, so their precedential weight is limited, but district judges read them closely.
What happens next in Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware?
The federal case sits on a stay. Each named plaintiff must now file an individual Demand for Arbitration under Ace's terms, and the class claims are off the table if the Class Action Waiver in those terms holds. The court has asked for a status report within 10 days of a final arbitral result.
What makes the next stage unusual is the procedure the plaintiffs' bar would face if it tried to convert the class into a Mass Arbitration. Ace's posted Dispute Resolution Terms contain a dedicated mass arbitration protocol:
| Feature of Ace's terms | What the posted terms provide |
|---|---|
| Trigger | 25 or more claimants submitting similar claims against Ace or related parties, where JAMS mass arbitration criteria are met |
| Administrator | JAMS administers mass arbitration claims instead of the American Arbitration Association, which handles individual consumer cases under some Ace program terms |
| Stage one | Claimants' counsel and Ace's counsel each select 15 claims, 30 in total, to proceed in individual arbitrations |
| After each stage | Global mediation of all remaining claims before a retired federal or state judge, with Ace paying the mediator's fee |
| Later stages | Larger sets of selected claims (as indexed, 20 per side in stage two and 25 per side in stage three); the mediation after stage three is at claimants' counsel's election |
| Remaining claims | Not filed or deemed filed in arbitration, and no arbitration fees assessed, until selected |
| Court enforcement | A court may enforce the mass arbitration provisions, including by enjoining mass filings or fee assessments |
| Opt-out | Claimants may opt out of arbitration by a personally signed notice sent by certified mail within 30 days after stage three or its elective mediation ends; Ace has a 14-day window after that to opt claims out |
| Court forum for opted-out claims | State or federal courts in Illinois |
Clauses like this are designed to blunt the leverage that comes from filing thousands of demands at once and triggering per-case fees. Under default JAMS mass arbitration procedures, the mass designation applies at 75 similar demands unless the agreement sets a different number; Ace's terms set 25. JAMS charges a single non-refundable $7,500 filing fee for a mass arbitration regardless of the number of cases, caps the consumer share of the initial filing fee at $2,500, and allows a Process Administrator to decide preliminary and administrative matters. Combined with Staggered Processing and mandatory mediation between rounds, the structure functions as a Bellwether Provision (Arbitration): the parties learn how arbitrators value claims from a small sample before the bulk of claims advances.
The late opt-out is the provision most likely to draw scrutiny. It gives claimants who are still unresolved after three rounds a route back to court, in Illinois, which supporters describe as a safety valve against indefinite delay. Critics of batching provisions argue that multi-round structures can leave most claimants waiting years, and the terms themselves warn that electing to join a mass arbitration may delay resolution. Courts have split on whether such provisions are substantively unconscionable; that question, if raised, may now belong to the arbitrator under the delegation finding.
Does the Ace Hardware arbitration ruling end cookie banner lawsuits?
No. The order binds only the parties before Judge Davila and turns on Ace's specific banner and terms. It does not decide whether Ace's trackers actually fired after opt-out, whether that conduct violates the Wiretap Act or CIPA, or whether the plaintiffs suffered a concrete injury. Those merits questions move to the arbitrator, claimant by claimant.
The ruling also does not help websites whose banners say nothing about terms of use. A banner that only manages cookie preferences forms no arbitration agreement, and the conspicuousness and assent failures in Rugs.com, LendingTree and the Yippee case show how readily courts deny motions to compel when design details slip. Separately, California's SB 690, signed Sept. 30, 2026, ends private pen-register suits under CIPA over website and app tracking from Jan. 1, 2027, but leaves the statute's wiretapping and eavesdropping provisions in place, so the theory pleaded against Ace remains available to future plaintiffs.
What it means for practitioners
For companies and clause drafters. The three 2026 orders sketch a workable design: a banner that persists until the visitor clicks, states plainly that clicking any option accepts the terms of use, places a prominent hyperlink to those terms beside the buttons, and is backed by preserved records of what each version displayed and when it went live. The Arbitration Agreement behind the link should contain a clear delegation clause and, if mass filings are a concern, a reviewed mass arbitration protocol. The losses in the Ninth Circuit show the cost of small type and vague instructions.
For claimants' counsel. Pre-filing diligence now has to include the defendant's cookie banner history, not just its checkout flow. Archived captures of the banner on the dates clients visited, client declarations about what they saw, and early evidence on whether the banner redisplayed are the materials that decided Alba. Firms considering a pivot from class litigation to coordinated individual demands against a defendant with Ace-style terms should budget for 30-claim first rounds, mandatory mediation, and the 25-claimant JAMS trigger, and should track the opt-out window that reopens the courthouse after stage three.
For the mass arbitration market. Cookie-tracking claims with statutory damages are attractive mass arbitration inventory, and banner-based formation rulings increase the number of consumers who are arguably bound. Staged protocols like Ace's are the defense response; how arbitrators and courts treat them will determine whether these claims settle as portfolios or grind through rounds.
FAQ
What did the court decide in the Ace Hardware cookie banner case?
On Nov. 9, 2026, Judge Edward J. Davila of the Northern District of California granted Ace Hardware's motion to compel arbitration in Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corp., stayed the case, and terminated Ace's motion to dismiss as moot, finding that the cookie banner gave reasonably conspicuous notice of Ace's terms of use.
Can a cookie banner create a binding arbitration agreement?
Three 2026 Northern District of California orders, in the NVIDIA, Harbor Freight and Ace Hardware cases, say it can when the banner clearly links the terms and tells visitors that clicking an option, or continuing to browse, accepts them. No published Ninth Circuit opinion on a cookie-banner arbitration agreement surfaced in this desk's research, so the question remains open at the appellate level.
Who are the plaintiffs and lawyers in Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware?
The named plaintiffs are Scott Pflaumer of California, Hans Cummings of Indiana and Mark Rosenthal of Colorado, represented by Janove PLLC and Levi & Korsinsky LLP. They sued on March 12, 2026, for a proposed nationwide class and a California subclass.
Can the plaintiffs appeal the Ace Hardware arbitration ruling?
Not right away in the ordinary course. Because the court compelled arbitration and stayed the case, the FAA does not provide an immediate appeal; review of the notice finding would generally wait until after arbitration concludes.
How does mass arbitration work under Ace Hardware's terms?
If 25 or more claimants bring similar claims, JAMS administers them in stages: each side first picks 15 claims for individual arbitration, followed by a global mediation that Ace pays for, with later, larger rounds. Claims not yet selected are not deemed filed and incur no fees.
Does the ruling mean Ace did not track users after they opted out?
No. The court did not decide whether the tracking allegations are true or whether they violate the Wiretap Act or CIPA. It decided only where those claims must be heard.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Rugs.com Arbitration Ruling: Ninth Circuit Says a 'Join Now' Email Sign-Up Did Not Bind Shoppers
In Perkins v. Rugs.com, the Ninth Circuit on Oct. 28, 2026 affirmed the denial of Rugs.com's motion to compel arbitration, holding that entering an email address and clicking 'Join Now' beside a Terms of Use link was not assent under Washington law.
Courts Desk · 13 min

SB 690 CIPA Law Signed: Private Pen Register Suits Over Websites End, Retroactive to 2025 Filings
Governor Newsom signed SB 690 on September 30, 2026, leaving CIPA pen register and trap-and-trace claims over websites and apps to the Attorney General from January 1, 2027, and reaching back to pending claims filed since January 1, 2025. Section 631 wiretap claims survive.
Policy Desk · 15 min

LendingTree Arbitration Ruling: Ninth Circuit Keeps Snowflake Breach Claims in the Montana MDL
On Nov. 4, 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel in Nader v. LendingTree affirmed that LendingTree and QuoteWizard cannot compel arbitration of Snowflake data breach claims, finding their websites never produced mutual assent, so the claims stay in MDL 3126.
Courts Desk · 13 min