Motley Rice Attorney Sentenced to 87 Months for Shell-Company Billing and Fake Injury Claims
Former Motley Rice attorney William Christopher Swett was sentenced on Nov. 16, 2026 to 87 months in federal prison and more than $2.5 million in restitution for a six-year scheme built on sham vendors, invented clients and fabricated injury claims.
Torts Desk··11 min read

A former Motley Rice attorney was sentenced on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, to 87 months in federal prison: U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel in Charleston imposed the term on William Christopher Swett, 42, along with three years of supervised release and more than $2.5 million in restitution, for defrauding the Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, firm and its clients between 2018 and March 2024. For the plaintiffs' bar, the case matters less as a story about one lawyer's gambling losses than as a map of how sham vendors, invented clients and fabricated injury claims passed through the expense and settlement machinery of one of the country's best-known mass tort firms for six years.
Swett pleaded guilty to four counts of wire fraud and four counts of money laundering. He was charged by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of South Carolina on Feb. 24, 2026, under a plea agreement, and entered his plea at a hearing on March 19, 2026. The FBI's Columbia Field Office investigated, and Assistant U.S. Attorney Emily Limehouse prosecuted.
What was the former Motley Rice attorney sentenced for?
The Motley Rice attorney was sentenced for running what prosecutors described as several overlapping fraud schemes against his employer and its clients, then moving the proceeds through accounts he controlled. The wire fraud counts cover the false billing and false claims; the money laundering counts cover what he did with the money afterward.
According to the government's charging and sentencing announcements and local reporting from the hearing, the conduct fell into four categories:
- Sham vendors. Swett set up two businesses, reported as MedBill and LegalAssets, that looked like ordinary legal-support vendors. They invoiced Motley Rice, and in some instances clients' case costs, for services that were never performed or were inflated.
- Expenses for clients who did not exist. He submitted reimbursement requests for travel, meals and meetings connected to more than a dozen fictitious clients.
- Sham injury claims for relatives. He filed personal injury claims in the names of family members and routed the recoveries to accounts he controlled.
- Fabricated mesothelioma settlements. Using fake clients and falsified medical records, he resolved two mesothelioma claims with Johnson & Johnson in 2021. Those settlements totaled $975,000, and part of the money went to accounts under his control.
The last category is the one defense lawyers in asbestos and talc litigation will notice. It means that, at least twice, invented claimants backed by fabricated medical records cleared a major defendant's settlement review and were paid. Public reporting does not say whether those claims were filed in court or resolved in an inventory deal before suit.
How long is Chris Swett's prison sentence?
Chris Swett's prison sentence is 87 months, or seven years and three months, to be followed by three years of supervised release. Reporting from the courtroom says the term sits at the bottom of the federal sentencing guidelines range. Neither the range itself nor the government's specific request has been made public in coverage of the hearing.
Judge Gergel told the courtroom he had come in prepared to go higher, according to the Post and Courier, but that Swett's statement of remorse persuaded him to stay within the guidelines. Swett addressed the court and the former colleagues in the gallery, apologized, and accepted responsibility.
The defense, led by Nathan Williams, framed the case around a severe gambling addiction, substance abuse and childhood trauma. A sentencing filing said Swett wagered more than $11 million and lost more than $1 million. The judge acknowledged those circumstances but said they did not excuse the conduct.
The emotional center of the hearing was a letter from Joe Rice, the Motley Rice co-founder who died on Sept. 3, 2026. Rice wrote it before his death, and his daughter, firm partner Ann Rice Ervin, read it aloud while more than a dozen Motley Rice partners and associates watched. Prosecutors had singled Rice out as a particular victim of the betrayal.
How much money did Swett take from Motley Rice and its clients?
The short answer is more than $2 million, but four different numbers appear in coverage, and they measure different things. The table below reconciles them.
| Figure | Where it comes from | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| At least $1.5 million | Feb. 24, 2026 charging release; plea | The loss Swett admitted when he agreed to plead guilty |
| More than $2 million | Nov. 2026 sentencing release | The government's headline loss figure at sentencing |
| Nearly $2.25 million | Post and Courier; South Carolina Lawyers Weekly | Reported total taken from the firm and clients |
| More than $2.5 million ($2,565,821.01) | Restitution order as reported | Amount the court ordered repaid, which can include interest and investigative costs borne by victims |
The gap between the plea figure and the sentencing figure is not unusual. When Swett was charged, prosecutors signaled that they expected to prove a substantially larger loss at sentencing, and the firm's own forensic review kept turning up additional transactions. Restitution under federal law covers a victim's actual losses and can include costs such as the expense of investigating the fraud, which helps explain why the order exceeds the loss totals.
How was the Motley Rice fraud discovered?
The Motley Rice fraud was discovered when Swett's bank flagged a fraudulent check and contacted the firm. Motley Rice opened an internal investigation, and as the scope widened it referred the matter to the FBI and the Justice Department.
Ann Rice Ervin said the review took roughly 10,000 hours of work. South Carolina Lawyers Weekly reported that the firm went back through about 11 years of Swett's files, effectively his entire tenure; the ABA Journal, citing Reuters, put his time at the firm at 12 years.
That detection path matters to firm managers. The scheme was not caught by the firm's expense review, by co-counsel, or by the defendant whose settlement desk paid the two mesothelioma claims. It was caught by a bank's fraud screen, an external control the firm did not own.
Were Motley Rice clients repaid?
Yes. Motley Rice says every individual affected by Swett's schemes has been repaid with interest by the firm, according to officials quoted in coverage of the sentencing. The restitution order runs to the victims as the court defined them, and in practice much of it will reimburse the firm, which absorbed client losses up front.
For clients, the practical point is that the firm made them whole without waiting for a criminal judgment that may never be fully collected. Restitution judgments against individual defendants who have gambled away proceeds frequently go largely unpaid.
Is Chris Swett disbarred?
The South Carolina Supreme Court suspended Swett's law license in May 2024, two months after the conduct ended, according to prosecutors. Some sentencing coverage now describes him as disbarred, while earlier reporting at the time of his March 2026 plea said his license was listed as not in good standing without a disbarment order. A felony conviction for fraud involving client funds typically leads to disbarment in South Carolina, but no disbarment order had been publicly reported as of Nov. 22, 2026.
Timeline: from first fake invoice to federal prison
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 2018 | Fraud begins, per prosecutors; sham vendors start billing the firm |
| 2021 | Two mesothelioma claims built on fake clients and falsified records settle with Johnson & Johnson for $975,000 |
| March 2024 | Conduct ends, per prosecutors |
| May 2024 | South Carolina Supreme Court suspends Swett's law license |
| Date not public | Bank flags a fraudulent check; Motley Rice investigates and refers the case to the FBI and DOJ |
| Feb. 24, 2026 | U.S. Attorney's Office charges Swett with wire fraud and money laundering under a plea agreement, alleging at least $1.5 million |
| March 19, 2026 | Swett pleads guilty to four wire fraud and four money laundering counts |
| Sept. 3, 2026 | Motley Rice co-founder Joe Rice dies |
| Nov. 16, 2026 | Judge Gergel imposes 87 months, three years of supervised release, and more than $2.5 million in restitution |
How the sentence compares with other plaintiffs' lawyer fraud cases
The 87-month term is identical to the one imposed on Tom Girardi, the former Los Angeles plaintiffs' lawyer sentenced in the Central District of California on June 3, 2025, after a jury convicted him of four counts of wire fraud. The comparison is instructive mostly for its differences. Girardi's case involved tens of millions of dollars in client settlement money, a trial rather than a plea, and a government request for 14 years that the court cut in light of his age and dementia. His restitution order was $2,310,247.
Swett's case involved a far smaller dollar loss but an aggravating feature that Girardi's did not: the creation of fictitious claimants and fabricated medical records to extract settlements from a defendant. That conduct reaches beyond theft from a firm or client into fraud on the claims process itself. Against that, Swett pleaded guilty, his employer repaid the victims, and the judge credited his allocution.
South Carolina practitioners will also read the case against the backdrop of the Alex Murdaugh prosecutions, which made the state's bar the subject of national scrutiny over misappropriated settlement funds. The Swett matter is different in scale and in mechanism, but it lands in the same courthouse culture and will be cited in the same conversations about firm-level financial controls.
Judge Gergel is also the transferee judge in the aqueous film-forming foam MDL in the same district. Nothing in the record connects Swett's conduct to that docket, and the overlap is a function of the Charleston bench rather than the case.
What the Motley Rice attorney sentencing means for mass tort firms, defendants and clients
For plaintiffs' firms running large inventories. The scheme exploited three ordinary workflows: vendor onboarding, case-cost reimbursement and settlement distribution. Firms handling a Mass Tort docket at volume tend to rely on many small vendors for record retrieval, medical summaries and logistics, and on individual lawyers to certify that a client and a cost are real. The Swett facts argue for independent vendor verification (registration, ownership and bank-account checks against employee records), periodic reconciliation of client-level case costs against signed retainer documents, and a rule that no lawyer can both originate a claimant and approve the disbursement on that claimant's settlement.
For defendants and settlement administrators. Two fabricated mesothelioma claims were paid. Defense counsel and any Claims Administrator running a Global Settlement will cite the case as support for tighter Claimant Vetting: identity verification, provider-level confirmation of key medical records, and audit rights in inventory agreements. Expect it to appear in briefs arguing for more rigorous record certification in Multidistrict Litigation (MDL) settlement programs and in census or registry orders.
For the broader fight over plaintiff-side fraud. Corporate defendants and insurers have filed a wave of civil RICO suits against personal injury lawyers in recent years, and their advocates collect examples of fabricated claims. The Swett case is a criminal conviction, not a civil RICO finding, and the firm itself was the principal victim and the party that reported the conduct. That distinction cuts against using it as evidence of firm-wide misconduct, but it will still be quoted as proof that fabricated claims can clear settlement review.
For clients. Clients of a firm whose lawyer is charged with fraud should look for written confirmation of what was taken from their matter and how it was repaid. Here, the firm says repayment with interest is complete. Where a firm cannot or will not do that, state client protection funds may provide partial relief, subject to caps.
For individual lawyers. The gambling and addiction mitigation did not keep Swett out of prison; it may have kept him at the bottom of the range. Lawyer assistance programs in South Carolina and elsewhere offer confidential help, and disciplinary systems generally treat self-reporting and early intervention far more favorably than discovery by a bank.
What remains open
Several details have not surfaced in public coverage: the precise guidelines range, the government's requested sentence, whether the plea agreement included an appeal waiver, and Swett's surrender date. The South Carolina disciplinary proceeding, if a formal disbarment order has not yet issued, will follow the federal judgment. And Johnson & Johnson, which paid $975,000 on the two fabricated mesothelioma claims, has not been reported to have sought or received repayment from the restitution stream or from the firm.
FAQ
Who is William Christopher Swett?
William Christopher Swett, 42, of Johns Island, South Carolina, is a former personal injury attorney who spent about a dozen years at Motley Rice in Mount Pleasant before his license was suspended in May 2024. He was sentenced on Nov. 16, 2026, to 87 months in federal prison for wire fraud and money laundering.
What did the Motley Rice attorney do?
He billed the firm and clients through two sham vendors, expensed costs for more than a dozen nonexistent clients, filed sham injury claims for relatives, and used fake clients and falsified medical records to settle two mesothelioma claims with Johnson & Johnson for $975,000 in 2021.
How much restitution must Swett pay?
The court ordered more than $2.5 million in restitution, reported as $2,565,821.01. That exceeds the $1.5 million he admitted at the plea stage and the roughly $2 million to $2.25 million loss figures reported at sentencing.
Did the Swett case involve fake mesothelioma claims against Johnson & Johnson?
Yes. Prosecutors said Swett used fictitious clients and falsified medical records to settle two mesothelioma claims with Johnson & Johnson in 2021 for a combined $975,000, diverting part of the money to accounts he controlled.
Were Motley Rice clients harmed?
Clients were among the victims, through inflated or fictitious case costs, but Motley Rice says all affected individuals have been repaid with interest.
Who was the judge in the Swett sentencing?
U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel of the District of South Carolina imposed the sentence in Charleston, at the bottom of the guidelines range, after saying Swett's statement of remorse influenced his decision.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Gregory Rohl Disbarred: $659,821 Restitution Over Lilliana Kerr Wrongful-Death Settlement
Michigan's Attorney Discipline Board disbarred Gregory J. Rohl by consent, effective October 1, 2026, and ordered $659,821.44 in restitution after he pleaded no contest to misappropriating children's court-ordered shares of a $2.5 million wrongful-death settlement.
Courts Desk · 15 min

Opioid MDL Co-Lead Counsel: Polster Names Donald Migliori to Succeed the Late Joe Rice
On 23 September 2026 Judge Dan Aaron Polster appointed Motley Rice managing partner Donald Migliori as plaintiffs' co-lead counsel in MDL No. 2804, filling the seat Joe Rice held for eight years before his death on 3 September, just as the PBM phase of the opioid litigation reaches the Sixth Circuit.
Torts Desk · 10 min

RICO Lawsuits Against Personal Injury Lawyers: Report Counts Nearly 300 as 3M Case Clears Dismissal
A tort reform group's October 6 report says businesses and insurers have filed nearly 300 civil RICO suits since 2024, two dozen naming lawyers or funders. Courts are split: Uber and 3M have survived dismissal, while Ford and Uber's New York case lost.
Policy Desk · 17 min