$24 Million Radiologist Verdict: Gross Negligence Finding Tests South Carolina's Malpractice Cap
A Columbia, South Carolina jury awarded $24 million, including $14,645,390 in wrongful death noneconomic damages, over a missed esophageal perforation and found the radiologist grossly negligent, the finding that can lift the state's malpractice cap.
Torts Desk··12 min read

The $24 million radiologist verdict: what the Columbia jury decided
A jury in Columbia, South Carolina has returned a $24 million radiologist verdict for the estate of a 36-year-old former pilot who died after his CT angiogram was read without flagging an esophageal perforation, and it found the radiologist grossly negligent. That gross negligence finding matters as much as the dollar figure, because South Carolina's statutory cap on medical malpractice noneconomic damages does not apply when a jury makes it, which means the $14,645,390 wrongful death noneconomic award is not automatically cut to a few hundred thousand dollars.
The verdict was reported on November 11, 2026 by Radiology Business and by The State, the Columbia daily, after a trial of roughly two weeks that began on October 26. According to those reports, the patient had undergone an ablation procedure for atrial fibrillation, continued to have symptoms for about a month afterward, and then had a CT angiogram. The interpreting radiologist did not identify an esophageal perforation on that study. The patient died 12 days after the scan from complications related to the perforation.
Before trial, the estate settled with the cardiologist who performed the ablation for $1.2 million. The radiologist was the defendant who went to verdict. Published reports have not named the radiologist, the facility, or the case caption, and they did not break down the balance of the award beyond the noneconomic wrongful death figure, so this analysis sticks to what has been reported and to the South Carolina statutes that now govern what the estate can actually collect.
For the plaintiffs' bar, the case is a clean illustration of how a single interrogatory on the verdict form can move eight figures. For defendants, hospitals, and medical liability carriers, it lands while a bill backed by the South Carolina Hospital Association, H.4544, that would remove the very exception this jury triggered sits unfinished in the state Senate.
What did the radiologist miss in the $24 million case?
The radiologist missed an esophageal perforation, a tear through the wall of the esophagus, on a CT angiogram taken after the patient's cardiac ablation. Reports describe the jury as finding the radiologist at fault for failing to identify the injury on the imaging study.
The clinical sequence explains why the read mattered. Catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation works near the back wall of the heart's left atrium, which sits close to the esophagus, and esophageal injury is a recognized complication of the procedure. A patient who keeps reporting symptoms in the weeks after ablation and is sent for cross-sectional imaging is precisely the patient for whom an esophageal finding has to be ruled out. In this case, according to the reporting, the perforation was on the scan and was not called; death followed 12 days later.
The State reported that, according to the lawsuit, the patient was a decorated former F-16 fighter pilot who also flew commercially. The plaintiffs' trial team described the case as one in which a critical finding was missed on the angiogram. Radiology Business, which covers malpractice outcomes for the imaging specialty, framed the result as a negligence verdict against the interpreting physician rather than the ordering cardiologist.
How much was the South Carolina radiologist malpractice verdict?
The total verdict was $24 million. Of that, $14,645,390 was awarded as noneconomic damages for wrongful death, according to Radiology Business. The reports reviewed did not itemize the remaining roughly $9.35 million, so whether it consists of economic loss, survival damages, Punitive Damages, or some combination is not public on the current record.
| Component | Amount | Source / status |
|---|---|---|
| Total verdict | $24,000,000 | Reported by Radiology Business and The State |
| Wrongful death noneconomic damages | $14,645,390 | Reported by Radiology Business |
| Balance of award (economic, survival, or other) | about $9,354,610 | Arithmetic from reported figures; not itemized in reports |
| Pre-trial settlement with ablating cardiologist | $1,200,000 | Reported; release subject to S.C. Code § 15-38-50 |
| Gross negligence finding | Yes | Reported by Radiology Business |
| § 15-32-220 per-provider noneconomic base cap (pre-indexing) | $350,000 | Statute; adjusted annually for inflation |
| Indexed per-provider cap cited by practitioner guides | about $596,001 | Two secondary guides; other guides report different figures |
| Noneconomic award that would exceed an indexed cap of about $596,001, if the cap applied | about $14,049,389 | Illustration only; the gross negligence finding removes the cap under § 15-32-220(E) |
The last row is the reason the gross negligence question dominates post-trial strategy. Measured against a per-provider cap in the neighborhood of $600,000, the wrongful death noneconomic award would shrink by roughly $14 million if the cap governed. With the finding in place, it does not.
Does South Carolina cap medical malpractice damages?
Yes. South Carolina caps noneconomic damages in medical malpractice actions under S.C. Code § 15-32-220, enacted in the 2005 tort reform package. The statute sets a base limit of $350,000 per claimant against a single health care provider or institution and an aggregate base of $1,050,000 per claimant across all defendants, and both numbers are adjusted every year for inflation. Economic damages, including lost earnings and medical expenses, are not capped by this section.
The current indexed figure is harder to pin down than it should be. Two practitioner guides put the 2026 per-provider number at $596,001 and the aggregate at $1,788,002. Other secondary sources publish figures ranging from about $530,000 to $580,461 for a single provider, apparently reflecting different years. Counsel computing a remittitur or a settlement range should take the number from the state's official annual adjustment rather than from a blog post. For this verdict, however, the precise dollar figure is secondary to the threshold question of whether the cap applies at all.
South Carolina's approach mirrors the California model discussed in coverage of the Demi Dominguez verdict under MICRA, where the legislative cap, not the jury's valuation, ultimately sets the recovery. The key difference is the escape hatch.
Does the South Carolina damages cap apply when a doctor is grossly negligent?
No. Subsection (E) of § 15-32-220 provides that the noneconomic damages limits against a health care provider or institution do not apply if the jury or court determines the defendant was grossly negligent, wilful, wanton, or reckless and that conduct proximately caused the claimant's noneconomic damages. The same subsection lifts the cap where the defendant engaged in fraud or misrepresentation related to the health care rendered or altered or destroyed medical records to avoid a claim, according to the code text and practitioner summaries of it.
That is why the verdict form in Columbia carried a separate gross negligence question, and why the jury's yes answer is the most consequential line in the result. In South Carolina, gross negligence is generally understood as the intentional, conscious failure to do something a person is bound to do, or the doing of something a reasonable person would not do, a meaningful step above ordinary negligence. A missed read on a single image is not obviously that kind of conduct, and the defense can be expected to say so after trial.
The finding also matters beyond the cap. Under S.C. Code § 15-38-15, a defendant found less than 50 percent at fault ordinarily pays only its proportionate share of indivisible damages, but that protection does not apply to a defendant whose conduct is found wilful, wanton, reckless, grossly negligent, or intentional. With only the radiologist at trial, apportionment between co-defendants was not the central issue here, but the gross negligence exception to modified joint and several liability is part of why plaintiffs' lawyers in South Carolina request the finding routinely.
What is South Carolina bill H.4544 and would it change the gross negligence exception?
H.4544 is a 2025-2026 medical malpractice bill that, in the version described in the Legislature's own bill summary, would amend § 15-32-220(E) to eliminate the gross negligence exception to the malpractice damages cap. The South Carolina Hospital Association made the bill a legislative priority, describing the goal as removing vague gross negligence language from the cap exceptions and limiting future cap increases.
| Date | H.4544 action |
|---|---|
| May 8, 2025 | Introduced in the House |
| March 25, 2026 | Passed the House 116-0 |
| March 26, 2026 | Introduced in the Senate; referred to Judiciary |
| April 22, 2026 | Recalled from Senate Judiciary to the calendar |
| May 12, 2026 | Read a second time in the Senate |
| As of November 2026 | Bill page shows the bill residing in the Senate; no act number or governor's action appears |
The bill's content shifted as it moved. A House Judiciary panel adopted sponsor amendments that would raise noneconomic caps for physicians and dentists, which the sponsor described as $600,000 for a single occurrence and $1.2 million in total, would define an "occurrence" as an unfolding sequence of events proximately flowing from a single act of negligence, and would restore a fraud or misrepresentation exception. One committee amendment version retained gross negligence language but would have capped such cases at eight times the ordinary limit, while the summary of the later version says the exception is eliminated. The versions do not fully reconcile, which is itself a signal that the gross negligence question was the bill's pressure point.
Had H.4544 been enacted in its later form before this case was tried, the Columbia jury's gross negligence finding would likely not have lifted the cap at all, subject to whatever retroactivity provision the enacted text contained. Under South Carolina's two-year legislative cycle, a bill not enacted by the end of the 126th General Assembly must start over when the 127th convenes in January 2027, and verdicts like this one are likely to feature in that debate on both sides.
Will the $1.2 million cardiologist settlement reduce the $24 million verdict?
Probably, in some form. S.C. Code § 15-38-50 provides that a good-faith release given to one tortfeasor does not discharge the others unless its terms say so, but it reduces the claim against the others by the amount stipulated in the release or the consideration paid, whichever is greater. Applied here, the radiologist can ask the court to credit the $1.2 million paid by the cardiologist against the judgment.
How that credit is applied, and whether any allocation in the settlement agreement between wrongful death and survival claims affects it, will be litigated in post-trial motions. Against a $24 million verdict, the setoff is modest; the cap question is where the real money is.
Can the radiologist appeal the $24 million verdict?
Yes. The defense can file post-trial motions in the trial court for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, a new trial, or a new trial nisi remittitur, and can then appeal to the South Carolina Court of Appeals. No reporting reviewed so far indicates that post-trial motions have been filed, which is unsurprising given that the verdict was reported on November 11.
The likely grounds are predictable from the verdict's structure. First, the defense can argue that the evidence did not support a gross negligence finding as a matter of law, and that the cap therefore applies. Second, it can argue that a noneconomic wrongful death award of more than $14.6 million is excessive. Third, it can seek the § 15-38-50 credit for the cardiologist's settlement. Each argument attacks a different slice of the award, and by the arithmetic in the table above the first is the one that could move the most money, roughly $14 million of the noneconomic award against a $1.2 million setoff.
The radiologist was represented at trial by Mark S. Barrow and Marshall C. Crane of Sweeny Wingate & Barrow. The estate was represented by John Kassel, Theile McVey and Jamie Raie Rutskoski of Kassel McVey, together with Thad Myers.
How the $24 million radiologist verdict fits the 2026 run of radiology awards
Missed or delayed imaging findings are a steady source of large malpractice verdicts. Radiology Business has separately reported a $23 million Maine verdict that a hospital must pay after a radiologist missed a spinal cord injury on CT, a $15.5 million verdict tied to criticism of a teleradiologist's quick CT read, and an appellate decision upholding a $75 million verdict against a radiologist and an emergency physician.
The Columbia case adds a variable those cases did not share in the same way: a cap statute with a conduct-based exception, and a jury willing to find the conduct met it. As the review of the largest personal injury verdicts of 2026 showed, headline jury numbers often differ sharply from what is collected; here the collectible amount depends on whether one finding survives post-trial review, and on the limits of the radiologist's professional liability coverage, which have not been reported.
What it means for plaintiffs' firms, defendants, and insurers
For plaintiffs' firms handling South Carolina malpractice cases. The verdict confirms the value of building a gross negligence record from the start: pleading it, developing it through expert testimony about how obvious the missed finding was and what protocols required, and securing a separate verdict-form question. Without the finding, a noneconomic award of this size would be reduced to the indexed cap. Firms should also track H.4544's successor in the 2027 session, because an enacted bill removing the exception would change case valuation and intake economics for every catastrophic malpractice claim in the state.
For defense counsel and radiology groups. The post-trial fight will center on whether a misread can amount to gross negligence as a matter of law. Groups that rely on high-volume reading should expect plaintiffs to frame volume, time per study, and failure to escalate symptoms in an atypical post-procedure patient as conscious disregard rather than error.
For medical liability insurers and hospitals. Reserves for South Carolina exposure cannot assume the cap holds when gross negligence is pleaded. The verdict also gives the Hospital Association a concrete example for the 2027 debate over § 15-32-220(E), and gives the trial bar an equally concrete counterexample.
For patients and families. The result illustrates that, in South Carolina, a jury's finding about the seriousness of a provider's conduct, not only the size of the loss, can determine whether noneconomic damages are limited. It is not a prediction of the outcome of any other case.
FAQ
How much was the South Carolina radiologist malpractice verdict?
A Columbia jury awarded $24 million to the estate of a 36-year-old former pilot, including $14,645,390 in noneconomic damages for wrongful death, in a verdict reported on November 11, 2026.
What did the radiologist miss?
The radiologist failed to identify an esophageal perforation on a CT angiogram taken after the patient's atrial fibrillation ablation; the patient died 12 days after the scan.
Does South Carolina cap medical malpractice damages?
Yes. S.C. Code § 15-32-220 caps noneconomic damages from a base of $350,000 per provider and $1,050,000 in total, adjusted annually for inflation; economic damages are not capped.
Does the cap apply if the doctor was grossly negligent?
No. Under § 15-32-220(E), the noneconomic damages limits do not apply if the jury or court finds the defendant grossly negligent, wilful, wanton, or reckless, and the Columbia jury made that finding.
Would H.4544 change that rule?
The later version of H.4544 would eliminate the gross negligence exception; it passed the House 116-0 and reached second reading in the Senate on May 12, 2026, but no enactment appears on the Legislature's bill page.
Will the $1.2 million cardiologist settlement reduce the verdict?
Likely yes: under S.C. Code § 15-38-50, a release of one tortfeasor reduces the claim against the others by the amount paid, so the radiologist can seek a $1.2 million credit.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Demi Dominguez Verdict: $9.25 Million Against Arthur Park Meets California's Old $250,000 MICRA Cap
A Kern County jury on October 21 awarded $9.25 million against former OB-GYN Arthur Park for the 2019 deaths of Demi Dominguez and her newborn son. Because the suit predates AB 35, the pre-2023 $250,000 MICRA cap governs, and Park says he cannot pay.
Torts Desk · 12 min

Largest Personal Injury Verdicts of 2026: 12 of the Top 17 Are on Appeal, Reduced or Uncollectable
A November 11 review of the largest personal injury verdicts of 2026 finds 12 of the 17 biggest jury awards are on appeal, cut after trial or entered against a bankrupt or imprisoned defendant. Those 12 make up $4.61 billion of $5.24 billion, and none of the 17 is confirmed paid in full.
Torts Desk · 17 min

Vasectomy Malpractice Verdict: Pa. Superior Court Affirms $9.5M Brennen Award and $62K Discovery Sanctions
On October 26, 2026 the Superior Court of Pennsylvania upheld a $9.5 million Fayette County vasectomy malpractice verdict for a man who lost a testicle, and let stand roughly $62,000 in sanctions on the urology defendants and their trial counsel for producing the full medical record days before trial.
Torts Desk · 12 min