Roblox Forced Arbitration Bill: Two Senate Proposals Would Let Families of Harmed Children Choose Court
On November 16, 2026, two bipartisan Senate groups introduced bills that would let families void arbitration clauses in children's online-harm cases. A day later, Roblox's CEO declined to testify at the first Senate hearing on the platform. The Roblox forced arbitration bill could reach pending MDL cases.
Policy Desk··14 min read

The Roblox forced arbitration bill is really two bills: on November 16, 2026, Sens. Josh Hawley and Dick Durbin introduced the No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act, and Sens. Katie Britt, Richard Blumenthal and Cory Booker introduced the Ending Forced Arbitration of Children Online Act, each letting families of children harmed online sue in court even if the child clicked through terms requiring private arbitration. The next day, a Senate Judiciary subcommittee held the first congressional hearing on Roblox, Chief Executive David Baszucki declined to appear, and Hawley promised to push the arbitration ban through committee.
The timing is not incidental. Roblox and Discord are asking Chief Judge Richard Seeborg of the Northern District of California to send bellwether cases in In re: Roblox Corporation Child Sexual Exploitation and Assault Litigation, MDL No. 3166, to individual arbitration, with a hearing set for January 13, 2027. Reporting on the Hawley-Durbin text says it would reach cases already pending on the day it is enacted. If that language survives, Congress, not the court, could decide whether the roughly 200 Roblox lawsuits stay in public court.
This article explains what each bill does, what was said at the November 17 hearing, how the proposals interact with the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and the 2022 sexual-assault arbitration statute, and what the developments mean for platform defendants, contract drafters, claimants' counsel and the Mass Arbitration bar.
What is the Roblox forced arbitration bill?
The Roblox forced arbitration bill is the shorthand being used for the No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act, sponsored by Hawley (R-Mo.) and Durbin (D-Ill.), which would allow families of minors harmed by tech products or online sexual exploitation to litigate in court notwithstanding a platform's terms of service. Roblox is not named in the short title, but the bill was introduced on the eve of the Roblox hearing and grew out of the two senators' earlier investigation of the platform, according to Durbin's office.
According to the sponsors' releases and press coverage, the Hawley-Durbin bill would:
- Open the courthouse to covered claims. Families of children harmed by tech products, or by sexual exploitation including grooming, could file suit even if the child agreed to terms of service requiring private arbitration.
- Preserve claimant choice. Survivors and families could elect public court or confidential arbitration. The bill is framed as an option for the injured party, not a ban on arbitration as such.
- Close the click-through loophole. The sponsors say the bill ensures that a click-through agreement cannot limit a child's rights.
- Permit class actions. Coverage reports that the bill would allow class-action lawsuits, which means a Class Action Waiver in a platform's terms would not bar aggregate litigation of covered claims.
- Give the gatekeeping question to a judge. Durbin's office says a judge, not an arbitrator, would decide whether the law applies to a child's claim. That provision neutralizes a Delegation Clause, which otherwise routes Gateway Questions such as scope and enforceability to the arbitrator.
- Reach pending cases. Reporting that quotes the bill's applicability language says it would cover any case or proceeding pending on, or commenced on or after, the date of enactment, regardless of when the conduct, injury or agreement at issue occurred.
The bill text had not been posted on Congress.gov at the time of writing, and no bill number had been published. Definitions, including what counts as a "cyber injury" and which platforms are covered, therefore remain unverified.
What is the Ending Forced Arbitration of Children Online Act?
The second proposal, from Britt (R-Ala.), Blumenthal (D-Conn.) and Booker (D-N.J.), takes a broader platform-by-platform approach rather than a harm-by-harm one. As summarized by Yellowhammer News and law-firm analyses, the operative provision would make a pre-dispute Arbitration Agreement or a pre-dispute joint-action waiver invalid and unenforceable, at the election of the person bringing the claim, where the alleged harm relates to a minor's use of a covered platform.
Reported coverage is wide. Covered platforms are said to include online platforms, video games, messaging apps, video streaming services and AI systems that children use or are reasonably likely to use. Covered harms reportedly include physical injury, mental or psychological harm, privacy violations and misuse of personal data. Britt framed the bill around consent, saying there is no way an 8-year-old could read the terms and sign away a day in court. The National Center on Sexual Exploitation has endorsed it.
The structure echoes the 2022 statute that Congress passed for workplace sexual misconduct: a claimant's election, a court deciding applicability, and invalidity of both arbitration agreements and joint-action waivers. The difference is the trigger. The 2022 law turns on the nature of the dispute; the Britt bill would turn on who was harmed (a minor) and where (a covered platform).
Hawley-Durbin vs. Britt-Blumenthal-Booker: how the two bills compare
| Feature | No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act | Ending Forced Arbitration of Children Online Act |
|---|---|---|
| Sponsors | Hawley (R-Mo.), Durbin (D-Ill.) | Britt (R-Ala.), Blumenthal (D-Conn.), Booker (D-N.J.) |
| Introduced | November 16, 2026 | November 16, 2026 |
| Trigger | Child sexual exploitation, including grooming, and injuries caused by tech products or platform design | Harm relating to a minor's use of a covered platform |
| Covered harms | Sexual exploitation; "cyber injuries" (definition not yet public) | Physical injury, mental or psychological harm, privacy violations, misuse of personal data (as reported) |
| Covered services | Tech products and online platforms | Online platforms, video games, messaging apps, streaming services, AI systems (as reported) |
| Claimant choice of court or arbitration | Yes | Yes, at the claimant's election |
| Class actions / joint-action waivers | Class actions allowed | Pre-dispute joint-action waivers unenforceable |
| Who decides applicability | A judge, not an arbitrator | A court (as reported) |
| Pending cases | Applies to cases pending on or filed after enactment (as reported) | Not addressed in released summaries; text not yet public |
| Endorsements reported | Survivor advocates at hearing | National Center on Sexual Exploitation |
Two practical differences stand out. First, the Hawley-Durbin bill is anchored in sexual exploitation, which makes it a direct legislative answer to the narrow reading of the existing statute that Roblox and Discord are pressing in the MDL. Second, the Britt bill's coverage of privacy and data-misuse harms would reach a much larger docket, including children's privacy claims that today are frequently pushed into individual arbitration or Mass Arbitration campaigns.
What happened at the Roblox Senate hearing on November 17, 2026?
The Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism, chaired by Hawley, held a hearing titled "Roblox and Online Gaming: Digital Playgrounds Endangering America's Children" on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. The panel heard from two survivors of alleged grooming on the platform, Michael Schlep and a witness identified as Woody Doe; Khari James of the National Center on Sexual Exploitation; and law professor Myriam Gilles.
Schlep told senators that an older user befriended him on Roblox when he was 12, moved their conversations to private channels, and exposed him to violent and extremist material; he said Roblox must be held accountable publicly. Gilles focused on the arbitration terms. According to hearing reports, she testified that forced arbitration strips consumers and workers of their rights, questioned whether children can meaningfully consent to such terms when creating a gaming account, and said Roblox has sought to enforce provisions that include confidentiality requirements and a one-year deadline for bringing claims. In an exchange with Durbin, she confirmed that Roblox asks all users, regardless of age, to agree to arbitration.
Durbin, the Judiciary Committee's ranking member, used his opening statement to press for final passage of the STOP CSAM Act, which would let victims sue companies that host child sexual abuse material, and suggested it could ride on the National Defense Authorization Act before the end of December. Hawley closed by saying he would not rest until the committee marks up and passes a bill ending forced arbitration for victims of online exploitation.
Why did Roblox CEO David Baszucki not testify?
Baszucki was invited to testify and declined, according to Hawley, who said the chief executive sent a letter on the morning of the hearing raising concerns about how much time he had been given to decide whether to participate. Hawley said Baszucki had "stiff-armed" the subcommittee, and Roblox sent no representative to the witness table.
Roblox responded in statements reported by Wired and other outlets. The company said it requires age checks to use chat, places users under 16 in age-based accounts with protective defaults, and blocks images and video in chat. It called the allegations aired at the hearing fundamentally misleading, and said that a legal position about arbitration is not a measure of a company's safety record. That last line is the company's core message to Congress: that the arbitration fight is about forum, not about whether the platform is safe.
Can Roblox force families into arbitration today?
Under current law, Roblox can try. Its terms of use, as published with a November 1 effective date, contain a binding individual-arbitration agreement and a class-action waiver for users in the United States and Canada (other than Quebec). Under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), such clauses are generally enforceable, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly held that state rules disfavoring arbitration are preempted. Families resisting arbitration currently rely on three arguments, each of which the MDL plaintiffs have raised.
The EFAA. The Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act, 9 U.S.C. §§ 401-402, lets a person alleging conduct constituting a sexual assault dispute or sexual harassment dispute elect to void a predispute arbitration agreement. Roblox and Discord argue the statute does not reach these suits because the claims concern failures to protect users from third-party predators rather than assaults by company employees or agents, and because, in several bellwether cases, there was no physical contact. Roblox has said three of the six plaintiffs in its motion allege exchanges of explicit images rather than physical contact.
Minority and disaffirmance. Plaintiffs argue that minors may disaffirm contracts, including arbitration agreements, under state law. Platforms respond that continued use after reaching majority, or a parent's assent, ratifies the terms.
Formation and unconscionability. Plaintiffs also contend that some agreements were never validly formed, and that terms imposed on children through a Contract of Adhesion are unenforceable under the Unconscionability doctrine. Those arguments vary state by state and claimant by claimant, which is precisely why defendants prefer them to a categorical federal rule.
Both new bills would replace that case-by-case fight with a statutory election, at least for the claims they cover.
How does the bill relate to the Roblox MDL arbitration motions?
The connection is direct. MDL No. 3166 was centralized before Chief Judge Seeborg in San Francisco. On September 22, 2026, Roblox and Discord each moved to compel arbitration of six bellwether cases. Plaintiffs filed a consolidated opposition on October 27, relying principally on the EFAA. Replies are due November 20, 2026, and the Motion to Compel Arbitration hearing is set for January 13, 2027. Parallel rulings from San Mateo County Superior Court applying the EFAA against Roblox and Discord are on appeal in California's First Appellate District.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| March 3, 2022 | EFAA takes effect for claims accruing on or after that date |
| September 22, 2026 | Roblox and Discord move to compel arbitration in six MDL bellwether cases |
| October 27, 2026 | MDL plaintiffs file consolidated opposition citing the EFAA, minority and formation defenses |
| November 1, 2026 | Current Roblox terms of use take effect (as published) |
| November 16, 2026 | Hawley-Durbin and Britt-Blumenthal-Booker bills introduced |
| November 17, 2026 | Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing on Roblox; Baszucki declines to appear |
| November 20, 2026 | Roblox and Discord replies due in MDL No. 3166 |
| January 13, 2027 | Hearing on motions to compel arbitration before Chief Judge Seeborg |
Three scenarios follow. If Judge Seeborg denies arbitration under the EFAA, the bills become less urgent for MDL plaintiffs but remain important for non-sexual harms such as addiction, privacy and design-defect claims. If he grants arbitration, even in part, pressure on Congress grows, and the Hawley-Durbin pending-case clause becomes the plaintiffs' most valuable provision. If either bill is enacted before a ruling, the motions could be mooted for covered claims, subject to any constitutional challenge to retroactive application.
Would the bill apply to pending Roblox lawsuits?
Yes, if the Hawley-Durbin text is enacted as reported. The applicability language described in coverage reaches any case pending on, or commenced on or after, the date of enactment, regardless of when the conduct, injury or agreement occurred. That is broader than the EFAA, which Congress limited to claims that arose or accrued on or after its March 3, 2022 effective date. A pending-case clause would let the roughly 200 families already suing Roblox, along with state attorneys general whose suits sit alongside the private cases, invoke the new election without refiling.
Defendants can be expected to argue that applying the statute to agreements formed and claims filed before enactment raises retroactivity concerns. Courts generally permit Congress to change the forum for pending claims, since forum rules are usually treated as procedural rather than as altering substantive rights, but the question would be litigated. For the Britt bill, the effect on pending cases cannot be assessed until its text is released.
Will the Roblox arbitration bill pass?
Passage is uncertain, and neither bill has a committee vote scheduled. Several signals point in different directions. On the positive side, both bills are bipartisan, Hawley chairs the subcommittee that held the hearing, Durbin is the full committee's ranking member, and the EFAA itself passed with bipartisan support in 2022 after a similar survivor-driven campaign. On the negative side, the 119th Congress is in its final weeks, broader Arbitration Reform Proposals such as the FAIR Act have repeatedly stalled, and business groups have historically resisted subject-matter carve-outs from the FAA that could spread to other consumer contracts. Durbin's push to attach the STOP CSAM Act to the NDAA suggests the realistic short-term vehicle for online child-safety measures is must-pass legislation, not standalone floor votes. Bills that do not pass by the end of the Congress must be reintroduced in January.
What it means for each audience
For platform defendants and their counsel. The hearing put the arbitration clause, not just content moderation, at the center of the child-safety debate. Platforms whose terms bind minors to individual arbitration should expect the clause itself to be cited as evidence in legislative and public-relations fights. A pending-case clause also means defense strategy in MDL No. 3166 cannot assume the forum question will be settled by Judge Seeborg alone.
For contract drafters. The bills target pre-dispute agreements and joint-action waivers, and they assign applicability to courts. Drafters relying on a Delegation Clause for minor users should recognize that both proposals would override it for covered claims. Teams may also revisit provisions singled out at the hearing, including confidentiality terms and shortened limitations periods, which already draw Unconscionability scrutiny when applied to children.
For claimants' counsel and the PI bar. Firms handling Roblox, Discord and gaming-addiction cases gain a legislative argument and a timetable to watch. The class-action provision matters for privacy and data claims, where individual damages are small and aggregate litigation is the only economical path. Counsel weighing whether to pursue Mass Arbitration as an alternative should note that both bills preserve arbitration as the claimant's option, so a mass filing strategy remains available if a family prefers a confidential forum.
For litigation funders. Funders backing child-safety dockets face a binary near-term risk tied to the January 13 hearing, and a longer-term upside if a pending-case provision becomes law. Third-Party Litigation Funding disclosure bills moving in the same Congress add a second layer of legislative risk.
For the broader arbitration debate. The EFAA showed that Congress can carve a subject-matter exception out of the FAA without repealing it. These bills test whether that model extends from workplace misconduct to an entire user population, minors online. If it does, the template could be reused for other categories of vulnerable consumers.
What remains unknown
Several points cannot yet be verified. Neither bill's full text had been posted on Congress.gov at the time of writing, and no bill numbers had been published. The definitions of "cyber injuries" and "covered platform," the treatment of parents' own claims as distinct from children's, and whether the Britt bill reaches pending cases all depend on the text. Witness affiliations and quotations here are drawn from senators' releases and press accounts of the hearing rather than an official transcript.
FAQ
What is the Roblox forced arbitration bill?
It is the No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act, introduced by Sens. Hawley and Durbin on November 16, 2026, which would let families of children harmed by online exploitation or tech products sue in court despite arbitration clauses in terms of service. A companion bill from Sens. Britt, Blumenthal and Booker, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Children Online Act, pursues the same goal for harms tied to a minor's use of covered platforms.
Does the bill ban arbitration on Roblox?
No. Both bills give the family a choice. A family could still elect confidential arbitration, but the platform could not force it, and a pre-dispute class-action or joint-action waiver could not block aggregate litigation of covered claims.
Would the bill apply to the Roblox lawsuits already filed?
The Hawley-Durbin bill, as reported, would apply to any case pending on or filed after enactment, regardless of when the conduct, injury or agreement occurred. That would reach the roughly 200 lawsuits now pending against Roblox if the bill becomes law in that form.
Why didn't Roblox's CEO testify at the Senate hearing?
David Baszucki declined the subcommittee's invitation and, according to Hawley, sent a letter the morning of the November 17 hearing citing concerns about the time he was given to decide. Roblox did not send any other witness.
What did Roblox say about the arbitration bills?
Roblox said that a legal position about arbitration is not a measure of a company's safety record, and pointed to age checks for chat, protective defaults for users under 16 and blocks on images and video in chat. It called the allegations presented at the hearing misleading.
When will the court rule on Roblox's motion to compel arbitration?
Chief Judge Richard Seeborg is scheduled to hear Roblox's and Discord's motions to compel arbitration in MDL No. 3166 on January 13, 2027, after the companies file replies on November 20, 2026. A ruling would follow the hearing; no date has been set.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Roblox Arbitration Lawsuit: Abuse Survivors Tell MDL Judge the EFAA Bars Roblox and Discord's Clauses
On October 27, 2026, plaintiffs in the roughly 180-case Roblox arbitration lawsuit fight told Chief Judge Richard Seeborg that a 2022 federal statute voids the platforms' clauses. The companies say no physical contact means no sexual assault dispute. A January 13 hearing will decide which reading wins.
Courts Desk · 18 min

The Roblox Motion to Compel Arbitration Lands 22 September — and the EFAA Decides Half of MDL 3166
Roblox and Discord are due to move to compel arbitration on 22 September 2026 across more than 160 child exploitation actions in MDL No. 3166. A 2022 statute, and the date a child was harmed, will decide most of it.
Courts Desk · 15 min

SpaceX Arbitration Ruling: Ninth Circuit Rejects a Plausibility Test for the EFAA
In a 2-1 SpaceX arbitration ruling on November 10, 2026, the Ninth Circuit held that eight fired engineers can litigate in court because the EFAA asks only whether a complaint asserts sexual harassment, not whether it would survive a motion to dismiss.
Courts Desk · 12 min