Hazelnut Allergy Lawsuit Verdict: Colorado Jury Hits Wafer Distributor Solen USA With $1.55 Million
A federal jury in Colorado found Solen USA liable for an undeclared hazelnut in a Biscolata wafer that sent a 10-year-old into a severe reaction, awarding $350,000 in compensatory and $1.2 million in punitive damages. Colorado's punitive cap and the state consumer act's trebling rule now decide the final number.
Torts Desk··16 min read

A federal jury in Colorado returned a $1.55 million hazelnut allergy lawsuit verdict on November 5, 2026, finding wafer distributor Solen USA, LLC liable to a boy who suffered a severe allergic reaction after eating a chocolate wafer whose label and Amazon listing never disclosed hazelnut. The award, $350,000 in compensatory damages and $1.2 million in punitive damages, is a rare jury win in a packaged-food allergen case, and it was reached against a company that did not manufacture the product, which is the point plaintiffs' lawyers and food importers will study most closely.
The case is A.C., by and through his mother and next friend, Maria Vitale v. Solen USA, LLC, No. 1:22-cv-02804, before U.S. District Judge Gordon P. Gallagher in the District of Colorado. Two features make it more than a one-off. First, liability on negligence was decided by the judge before the jury was seated, on a negligence per se theory built on Colorado's food misbranding rule. Second, the jury's punitive figure runs straight into Colorado's statutory cap on exemplary damages, while the plaintiffs are also pressing for trebled damages under the Colorado Consumer Protection Act. How the court reconciles those two remedies will set the real value of the verdict.
What happened in the Solen USA hazelnut allergy lawsuit?
The hazelnut allergy lawsuit arose from a reaction on November 30, 2020. According to Allergic Living's account of the trial, Colorado mother Maria Vitale's son, then 10 and allergic to tree nuts, ate a Biscolata Dark Chocolate Rolled Wafer that the family had bought on Amazon. Neither the package nor the Amazon product description listed hazelnut. Allergic Living reports that his mother gave him an antihistamine and his albuterol inhaler; SnackSafely, relying on the plaintiffs' account, reports that he was hospitalized. Reporting on the case also describes a laboratory test that found hazelnut at roughly 5,000 parts per million in the product.
Solen USA is the U.S. distributor of the Biscolata line, not its manufacturer. The suit, filed in 2022 in federal court on diversity grounds, pleaded negligence, misrepresentation and violations of the Colorado Consumer Protection Act (CCPA); punitive damages were also submitted to the jury.
Solen fought the case on two fronts for most of its life. It argued that, as a distributor that neither made the wafer nor wrote its label, it could not be held responsible for what was inside. It also argued that any hazelnut came from unintended cross-contact at the manufacturing plant rather than from a recipe ingredient, and that the manufacturer never meant to put hazelnut in the product.
Then, days before trial, the defense changed course. Allergic Living reports that Solen conceded three things: that the tree nut was in the product, that the Amazon listing's ingredient description and the product label were misleading, and that the wafer caused the boy's allergic reaction. With causation and falsity off the table, the trial narrowed to the distributor's responsibility and damages.
Timeline of the case
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Nov. 30, 2020 | Boy, then 10, reacts after eating a Biscolata Dark Chocolate Rolled Wafer bought on Amazon |
| 2022 | Vitale sues Solen USA in the District of Colorado, No. 1:22-cv-02804 |
| Earlier in the case | Court denies the parties' cross-motions for summary judgment, discussing Colorado's implied warranty of merchantability for food |
| Days before trial (Nov. 2026) | Solen stipulates that hazelnut was present, the label and listing were misleading, and the wafer caused the reaction |
| Shortly before trial | Judge Gallagher grants the plaintiff partial summary judgment on negligence per se |
| Nov. 5, 2026 | Jury finds Solen liable on all claims; awards $350,000 compensatory and $1.2 million punitive damages |
| Nov. 11–13, 2026 | Verdict reported by SnackSafely and Allergic Living |
How much did the jury award in the hazelnut allergy lawsuit verdict?
The jury awarded $1.55 million: $350,000 in compensatory damages and $1.2 million in punitive damages, according to both Allergic Living and SnackSafely. It found Solen liable on every claim submitted, negligence, misrepresentation and the CCPA.
That headline number is not the final judgment. SnackSafely, citing the plaintiffs' legal team of Laurel Francoeur of Francoeur Law Office and Matthew Fenicle of Kontnik Cohen, reports that trebling under the CCPA could push the total to about $2.25 million before judicial adjustments. The arithmetic behind that estimate is straightforward: three times $350,000 is $1.05 million, and adding the $1.2 million punitive figure produces $2.25 million. Whether a court will allow both, and in what amount, is a separate question addressed below.
Can you sue a distributor for an undeclared allergen if it did not make the food?
Yes, and this case shows how. Judge Gallagher rejected Solen's argument that it could not be liable because it neither manufactured the wafer nor created the inaccurate label, reasoning that Colorado law can impose responsibility on those who sell contaminated or misbranded food even when they did not make it.
The distributor argument usually rests on Colorado's innocent seller statute, C.R.S. § 13-21-402. Subsection (1) bars a "product liability action" against a seller unless the seller is also the manufacturer of the product or the part that caused the harm. Subsection (2) carves out an exception: when the court cannot obtain jurisdiction over the actual manufacturer, the principal distributor or seller over whom it does have jurisdiction is treated as the manufacturer. For a wafer made abroad and imported by a domestic distributor, that exception is often the first battleground.
But the statute has a limit that the Colorado Court of Appeals spelled out in Carter v. Brighton Ford: it bars only product liability actions against non-manufacturing sellers, and leaves other kinds of claims available. A negligence per se claim built on the seller's own sale of a misbranded food, a misrepresentation claim about what the seller's listing said, and a statutory claim under the CCPA each attack the seller's own conduct rather than the design or manufacture of the product. That is the gap through which this verdict passed. The jury held Solen to account for what it put into the market and how it was described, not for how the wafer was baked.
The practical lesson for anyone in the chain between a foreign factory and a U.S. kitchen is that distributor status is not a shield in an allergen case. The innocent seller defense is narrower than its name, and it does not reach claims grounded in the distributor's own representations.
What is negligence per se in a food allergy case?
Negligence per se lets a plaintiff use a safety statute or regulation as the standard of care, so that a violation of the rule establishes breach without a jury having to decide what a reasonable company would have done. In this case, the rule was Colorado's food misbranding provision, under which a food is deemed misbranded if its labeling is "false or misleading in any particular," as quoted in the court's order.
Once Solen stipulated that the label and the Amazon listing were misleading and that the wafer caused the reaction, the elements fell into place. The statute was designed to protect consumers from mislabeled food; a child with a tree nut allergy is squarely within the class it protects; an allergic reaction is the kind of harm it aims to prevent; and the misleading label caused that harm. VitalLaw's summary of the ruling describes partial summary judgment granted on negligence per se after the late stipulation on hazelnut contamination. Allergic Living reports that the Colorado misbranding law formed the basis for the judge's summary judgment ruling on the negligence claim before the jury verdict.
The cross-contact defense did not change that analysis. A misbranding standard asks whether the label was accurate, not whether the manufacturer intended the allergen to be there. A product that contains enough hazelnut to trigger a reaction and says nothing about it is misleading on the most important fact for an allergic consumer, whatever the route by which the nut got in.
Earlier in the case, the court had denied cross-motions for summary judgment and discussed Colorado's implied warranty of merchantability for food, a discussion the later order incorporates. That history matters because it shows the court treating food sellers as carrying obligations about what they sell, whether framed in warranty, statute or negligence.
Will the $1.2 million punitive damages award survive Colorado's cap?
Probably not in full. Colorado's exemplary damages statute, C.R.S. § 13-21-102(1)(a), provides that jury-awarded exemplary damages may not exceed the amount of actual damages awarded to the injured party. On a $350,000 compensatory award, a straight application of that limit would cut the $1.2 million punitive figure to $350,000.
Two refinements could move that number:
- The base can be larger than the jury's figure. In Vickery v. Evans (Colo. 2011), the Colorado Supreme Court held that the "actual damages" base for the cap includes prejudgment interest on the compensatory award, reduced to the damages for which the defendant is actually liable. With a reaction in November 2020 and judgment in late 2026, prejudgment interest could add meaningfully to the base.
- The court can enhance up to three times. Section 13-21-102(3) permits the court to increase exemplary damages to as much as three times actual damages, but only on findings that the defendant continued the conduct in a willful and wanton manner during the case, or acted willfully and wantonly during the case in a way that aggravated the plaintiff's damages. Even if those findings were made, three times $350,000 is $1.05 million, still short of the jury's $1.2 million unless the interest-adjusted base is used.
The court also retains power under § 13-21-102(2) to reduce or disallow exemplary damages where the deterrent purpose has already been served, and § 13-21-102(6) bars consideration of a defendant's income or net worth in setting them. Because the case is in federal court on diversity, these Colorado rules govern the amount, and the federal due process ceiling from State Farm v. Campbell, which presumes single-digit ratios, would not be the binding constraint at a 3.4-to-1 ratio.
There is a procedural backdrop as well. Under § 13-21-102(1.5)(a), a Colorado plaintiff may not include an exemplary damages claim in the initial complaint; it can be added by amendment only after initial disclosures and a prima facie showing of a triable issue. That the claim reached a jury at all means the court found a reasonable likelihood that the punitive question deserved a verdict, which tells defendants something about how the court viewed the evidence of Solen's conduct.
Damages scenarios
| Scenario | Compensatory | Punitive / exemplary | CCPA trebling | Illustrative total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jury verdict as returned | $350,000 | $1,200,000 | Not yet applied | $1,550,000 |
| Plaintiffs' reported estimate | $350,000 trebled to $1,050,000 | $1,200,000 | Applied | About $2,250,000 |
| Statutory 1:1 cap, no trebling | $350,000 | $350,000 | None | $700,000 |
| 1:1 cap plus CCPA trebling | $1,050,000 | $350,000 | Applied | $1,400,000 |
| 3x enhancement (if findings made), no trebling | $350,000 | $1,050,000 | None | $1,400,000 |
All figures exclude prejudgment interest, costs and attorney fees. The table is illustrative only: it shows the range the statutes permit, not a prediction of the court's ruling.
Can the Colorado Consumer Protection Act triple the damages?
It can, but only on a heightened showing. Under C.R.S. § 6-1-113(2), a successful private CCPA plaintiff recovers the greater of actual damages, $500, or three times actual damages, and trebling is available only if the plaintiff proves by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant engaged in bad faith conduct, which the statute defines as fraudulent, willful, knowing or intentional conduct that causes injury. The Colorado Court of Appeals reversed a trebled award in Shekarchian v. Maxx Auto, 2019 COA 60, because the trial court used a preponderance standard instead of clear and convincing evidence.
The reported record does not say whether the jury made an express bad-faith finding under that standard, which is the threshold question for trebling. If it did, the plaintiffs will argue that trebling serves a different purpose from exemplary damages and that both may stand. Solen can be expected to argue that the two remedies both punish the same conduct and that awarding both would be a double recovery.
The CCPA also carries fee shifting. A prevailing CCPA plaintiff recovers reasonable attorney fees and costs, which in a case pending since 2022 and tried to verdict could rival the compensatory award. For plaintiffs' counsel weighing a modest-damages allergen case, that fee provision is often what makes the case economic.
The federal allergen labeling backdrop
The verdict was won under Colorado law, but it sits on top of a federal labeling regime that defines what an accurate label requires. The Food Allergen Labeling and Consumer Protection Act (FALCPA), effective January 1, 2006, requires packaged foods regulated by FDA to declare major food allergens by their common names. Tree nuts are among them, and FDA's current guidance lists hazelnut (filbert) among the tree nuts that must be declared. Sesame became the ninth major allergen on January 1, 2023.
FALCPA does not create a private right of action, so consumers cannot sue under it directly. That is why state-law vehicles matter. A state misbranding statute that mirrors federal labeling duties, used as the standard of care for negligence per se, lets an injured consumer borrow the federal standard without needing a federal cause of action. Undeclared allergens are also one of the leading causes of food recalls in the United States, which means evidence of industry knowledge about cross-contact risk is rarely hard to find.
Cross-contact is the one area where federal labeling law leaves room. Precautionary statements such as "may contain" are voluntary, and FDA does not require them. But a voluntary advisory label is different from silence about an allergen that is present in measurable quantities. A product that contains a tree nut at levels high enough to cause anaphylaxis is not saved by the fact that the nut arrived by accident.
Is Amazon or the seller responsible for an undisclosed allergen in a product listing?
The seller that controls the listing is the most exposed party, and Solen's concession that the Amazon ingredient description was misleading was central to the outcome here. Because the concession covered the online description as well as the printed package, the misrepresentation and consumer protection claims did not depend on the physical label alone, and the case illustrates how a marketplace listing can function as part of a product's labeling and advertising for state-law purposes.
Whether Amazon itself can be held liable as a seller of third-party products is a separate question that courts across the country have answered differently, and Amazon was not a defendant in this case. For distributors and brand owners, the takeaway is narrower and more certain: an online listing that omits an allergen is a representation by whoever wrote it, and it can support misrepresentation and consumer protection claims independent of the package.
How the hazelnut allergy lawsuit verdict compares with other food allergy verdicts
Jury verdicts in food allergy cases are uncommon; most cases settle or are dismissed. The reported awards vary widely, depending on whether the defendant prepared the food, labeled it or treated the reaction.
| Case | Defendant type | Allergen / setting | Reported outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| A.C. v. Solen USA (D. Colo., Nov. 5, 2026) | Packaged-food distributor | Undeclared hazelnut in wafer bought on Amazon | $1.55 million ($350,000 compensatory, $1.2 million punitive) |
| Boloco burrito case (Massachusetts, reported May 2024) | Restaurant chain | Peanut in a burrito ordered with an allergy note | More than $200,000 in damages, fees and costs |
| MedicWest Ambulance (Las Vegas, April 2021) | Ambulance service | Treatment of a 2013 peanut reaction | $29.5 million |
| Delta Dough (verdict March 10, 2020) | Bakery supplier to Panera | Pastry labeling | About $27,500 for medical costs and pain and suffering |
| Orla Baxendale v. Stew Leonard's (pending) | Grocer | Undeclared peanut in cookies | Punitive damages claim survived an August 2025 motion to strike; no verdict |
The Solen verdict stands out on two axes. It is one of the few awards against a defendant that only distributed a packaged product, and the punitive component signals that a jury was willing to punish a labeling failure, not just compensate for its consequences.
What happens next in Vitale v. Solen USA?
The immediate stage is post-trial motions. Under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 50(b) and 59, Solen has 28 days after entry of judgment to renew a motion for judgment as a matter of law, seek a new trial or move to alter or amend the judgment, and it can be expected to ask the court to apply the § 13-21-102 cap. The plaintiffs will seek trebling under the CCPA, prejudgment interest and attorney fees.
The issues likely to be contested are:
- Application of the exemplary damages cap, including the Vickery base and any request for a three-times enhancement.
- Trebling under the CCPA, including whether the record supports bad faith by clear and convincing evidence and whether trebling duplicates the punitive award.
- Fees and costs under the CCPA's fee-shifting provision.
- Preservation of the distributor defense for appeal to the Tenth Circuit, including the innocent seller statute and the reach of negligence per se against a non-manufacturer.
An appeal would test whether a Colorado misbranding violation can serve as the basis for negligence per se against a distributor that did not author the label, and how the innocent seller statute interacts with consumer protection and misrepresentation claims. A published Tenth Circuit decision on either point would carry well beyond this case.
What it means for distributors, importers, plaintiffs' counsel and insurers
For distributors and importers. Distributor status is a weaker defense in allergen cases than many in the supply chain assume. The innocent seller statute reaches product liability claims, not negligence per se built on a misbranding rule, misrepresentation or consumer protection claims. Importers of foreign confectionery should expect to answer for label accuracy, including online listings they control, and should treat allergen testing of imported lots and accurate English-language labeling as core legal controls rather than paperwork.
For plaintiffs' counsel. The case is a template for small-damages allergen claims: anchor liability in a state misbranding statute to convert falsity into breach, pair it with a state consumer protection claim for fee shifting and possible trebling, and build the punitive record early enough to satisfy any pleading gate such as Colorado's § 13-21-102(1.5)(a). Product testing showing the allergen's concentration and an admission or proof that the listing was wrong did much of the work here.
For defendants generally. A late concession can narrow a trial, but it can also hand the plaintiff summary judgment on liability. Defense teams should evaluate stipulations with an eye on whether they complete the elements of a per se theory.
For insurers. Product recall and general liability carriers writing food importers and distributors should note that compensatory exposure in a non-fatal allergen case can be modest while punitive, trebled and fee components multiply it. Whether punitive damages are insurable varies by state and by policy wording, and in this case the cap fight may matter more than the jury's figure.
FAQ
What happened in the Solen USA hazelnut allergy lawsuit?
A federal jury in Colorado found distributor Solen USA liable on November 5, 2026, for a severe reaction suffered by a 10-year-old with a tree nut allergy who ate a Biscolata Dark Chocolate Rolled Wafer containing undeclared hazelnut. The jury found liability on negligence, misrepresentation and the Colorado Consumer Protection Act.
How much did the jury award in the hazelnut allergy lawsuit verdict?
The jury awarded $1.55 million: $350,000 in compensatory damages and $1.2 million in punitive damages. The final judgment may differ because Colorado caps exemplary damages and the plaintiffs are seeking trebling under the state consumer protection act.
Can you sue a distributor for an undeclared allergen if it did not make the food?
Yes. The court rejected Solen's argument that a non-manufacturing distributor could not be liable, and Colorado's innocent seller statute bars only product liability actions, leaving negligence per se, misrepresentation and consumer protection claims available against a seller.
Will the $1.2 million punitive damages award survive?
Not likely in full. C.R.S. § 13-21-102(1)(a) limits jury exemplary damages to the amount of actual damages, and the court may enhance them to no more than three times actual damages only on specific findings of willful and wanton conduct during the case.
Can you sue if a food label does not list an allergen?
Generally yes, under state law. Federal law (FALCPA) requires major allergens, including tree nuts such as hazelnut, to be declared, but it does not give consumers a private right to sue, so injured consumers rely on state negligence, misbranding, warranty, misrepresentation and consumer protection claims.
Can the Colorado Consumer Protection Act triple the damages?
Yes, if the plaintiff proves by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant acted in bad faith. The plaintiffs' lawyers have said trebling could bring the total to about $2.25 million before adjustments, but the court will decide whether trebling applies and whether it duplicates the punitive award.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Largest Personal Injury Verdicts of 2026: 12 of the Top 17 Are on Appeal, Reduced or Uncollectable
A November 11 review of the largest personal injury verdicts of 2026 finds 12 of the 17 biggest jury awards are on appeal, cut after trial or entered against a bankrupt or imprisoned defendant. Those 12 make up $4.61 billion of $5.24 billion, and none of the 17 is confirmed paid in full.
Torts Desk · 17 min

$301 Million DUI Verdict in Levy County, Florida: Why No Cap Applies and How Much Can Be Collected
A Levy County, Florida jury returned a $301 million DUI verdict, $301,145,960.72, for a mother hit head-on by a wrong-way drunk driver, including $100 million in punitive damages. Florida's punitive damages cap does not reach impaired defendants, so the fight now turns to remittitur, appeal and collection.
Torts Desk · 12 min

PepsiCo Insurance Coverage Lawsuit: Chubb Units Sued Over San Francisco Ultra-Processed Food Defense
In a PepsiCo insurance coverage lawsuit removed to Manhattan federal court on November 5, 2026, the company says four Chubb-group insurers wrongly refused to defend San Francisco's ultra-processed food suit. The issue: is a city's health-cost claim 'damages because of bodily injury'?
Torts Desk · 15 min