10-3-1117 Statute of Limitations: Colorado Supreme Court Takes Up State Farm v. Weatherill
On Nov. 9, 2026 the Colorado Supreme Court agreed to decide whether claims against auto insurers that withhold policy information under C.R.S. 10-3-1117 must be filed within one year or two, settling a split that decides which $100-a-day claims survive.
Courts Desk··14 min read

Colorado Supreme Court will settle the 10-3-1117 statute of limitations
The Colorado Supreme Court on Monday, Nov. 9, 2026 agreed to hear State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Weatherill, which will decide whether a claimant suing an auto insurer for failing to make the disclosures required by C.R.S. § 10-3-1117 has one year or two years to file. The answer determines whether thousands of dollars in statutory $100-a-day liability, plus fees, survive in cases where the insurer's nondisclosure was not discovered until long after the 30-day response window closed.
The grant, reported by Colorado Politics on Nov. 11, resolves nothing yet, but it puts the 10-3-1117 statute of limitations squarely before the state's highest court for the first time. Two published divisions of the Colorado Court of Appeals have reached opposite answers. In 2023, Reynolds v. Great Northern Insurance Co. treated the statute as a penalty subject to a one-year limitations period that starts running on the 31st day after the insurer receives the request. In March 2026, Weatherill v. State Farm rejected that reading, held the statute is not a penalty, and applied Colorado's two-year catchall period.
State Farm, which lost in the Court of Appeals, asked the justices to step in. Its lawyers told the court that the competing opinions are "in hopeless conflict regarding the type of liability imposed onto insurers, what statute of limitations should apply, when that claim would accrue," according to Colorado Politics. The Weatherills answered that, if review were granted, the court should affirm their panel and disapprove Reynolds.
For Colorado's personal injury bar, the case matters because § 10-3-1117 is the routine pre-suit tool for learning how much liability coverage an at-fault driver carries. Its enforcement remedy, $100 for every day an insurer is late, is often the only leverage a claimant has when an adjuster drags its feet or leaves an umbrella policy off the list. The limitations ruling will decide how long that leverage lasts.
What did the Colorado Supreme Court agree to decide in State Farm v. Weatherill?
The court agreed to decide how much time plaintiffs have to sue auto insurers for failing to disclose relevant policy information after an accident. Embedded in that question are three linked issues, each of which State Farm flagged in its petition: what kind of liability § 10-3-1117 creates (a penalty or compensatory damages), which statute of limitations follows from that characterization, and when the claim accrues.
Those issues are not academic. If the statute imposes a penalty, § 13-80-103(1)(d) supplies a one-year period, and Reynolds holds that it begins on the fixed date when the penalty first starts to run. If the statute is not a penalty, the claim falls under § 13-80-102(1)(i), the two-year catchall, and the Weatherill division tied accrual to when the claimant knew or should have known of the violation, in line with Colorado's general Discovery Rule.
The court has not announced a briefing or argument schedule. No decision is expected for months.
The facts of Weatherill v. State Farm
The dispute began with a December 2020 collision between Joshua and Wendy Weatherill and a driver insured by State Farm. Through counsel, the Weatherills sent § 10-3-1117 requests to State Farm in January and February 2021, asking for the at-fault driver's coverage information.
According to the Court of Appeals opinion, State Farm's response disclosed a $250,000 liability policy but did not disclose a $1,000,000 umbrella policy. Colorado Politics reported that State Farm answered the first request eight days after receiving it and that a follow-up inquiry went unanswered. The Weatherills say they did not learn of the umbrella policy until Oct. 31, 2022. They sued State Farm in November 2022, seeking the statutory remedy.
State Farm moved to dismiss, arguing that the claim was for a penalty and was barred by the one-year period in § 13-80-103(1)(d), measured from the 31st day after it received the request. The district court, Judge Jill D. Dorancy presiding, agreed and dismissed the complaint, relying on Reynolds.
On March 12, 2026, a division of the Court of Appeals reversed in an opinion by Judge Elizabeth L. Harris, reported at 2026 COA 11 (No. 23CA1172) and later modified as 2026 COA 11M. The division held that "section 10-3-1117 is not a penalty statute and, therefore, is not subject to a 1-year statute of limitations," and that the claim is instead governed by § 13-80-102(1)(i). It remanded with directions to reinstate the complaint. The division expressly declined to follow Reynolds, creating the published split the Supreme Court has now agreed to resolve.
What is the 10-3-1117 statute of limitations right now?
Until the Supreme Court rules, the honest answer is that the 10-3-1117 statute of limitations is unsettled: one published Court of Appeals decision applies one year, another applies two years, and trial courts may follow either. Because one division of the Court of Appeals does not bind another, district judges have been left to choose between the two opinions, so the outcome in a given courtroom can turn on which one the judge finds more persuasive.
The two rules produce sharply different results.
| Question | Reynolds v. Great Northern (2023 COA 77) | Weatherill v. State Farm (2026 COA 11) |
|---|---|---|
| Decided | Sept. 7, 2023 | Mar. 12, 2026 |
| Character of § 10-3-1117 remedy | Penalty | Not a penalty |
| Limitations period | One year, § 13-80-103(1)(d) | Two years, § 13-80-102(1)(i) |
| Accrual | Fixed: the 31st day after the insurer receives the written request | Tied to when the claimant discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, the violation |
| Continuing violation doctrine | Rejected; each day is not a new claim | Not needed to save the claim |
| Result | Claim filed May 4, 2022 dismissed as untimely | Claim filed November 2022 reinstated |
In Reynolds, Great Northern's registered agent received the claimant's written request on Nov. 17, 2020. The insurer did not comply until April 22, 2022. The penalty began to run on Dec. 18, 2020, the 31st day after receipt, so the division held the one-year period expired on Dec. 18, 2021. Because Reynolds sued on May 4, 2022, the claim was time-barred even though the insurer was still out of compliance for months after the limitations period supposedly ran. The division also rejected the argument that each day of noncompliance was a separate violation carrying its own accrual date.
The arithmetic shows what was at stake. By this publication's calculation, Great Northern was late for roughly 490 days, which at $100 a day is about $49,000 before fees. Under Reynolds, none of it was recoverable.
Is C.R.S. 10-3-1117 a penalty statute?
Under current Court of Appeals law, that depends on which division a court follows: Reynolds says yes, and Weatherill says no. The Weatherill division concluded that the $100-a-day consequence for nondisclosure lacks the hallmarks of a penalty, as Colorado Politics summarized Judge Harris's reasoning in March. The district court in the case had itself observed that the damages "are not a fine imposed by the state," a point that cuts against the penalty label even though that court ultimately felt bound to apply the one-year period.
The Weatherill division also pointed to a practical problem with the Reynolds rule: a one-year period running from a fixed date could expire before a claimant knew, or could reasonably have discovered, that the insurer had violated the statute. That is exactly the Weatherills' situation. State Farm answered their request with a policy, so there was no obvious silence to trigger suspicion; the problem was what the answer left out.
State Farm's position is that the statute does exactly what a penalty statute does. It sets a fixed daily sum unconnected to any proof of actual loss and makes it payable to the requesting claimant. If that framing prevails, the one-year period applies and the Reynolds accrual rule likely comes with it.
The label has consequences beyond the clock. Penalty characterization can affect how courts read the statute's scope, since penal statutes are traditionally construed narrowly, and how the remedy is described in pleadings, settlements and releases. The Supreme Court's reasoning on the penalty question may therefore reach the other § 10-3-1117 disputes now working through the courts.
What does Colorado's insurance disclosure law require auto insurers to disclose?
Section 10-3-1117 was added by House Bill 19-1283, signed May 22, 2019, and took effect Jan. 1, 2020. It imposes two related duties on insurers that write personal or commercial auto policies in Colorado.
First, within 30 calendar days after a written request from an insured, the insurer must provide a copy of the complete policy, including endorsements.
Second, within 30 days after a written request from a claimant or the claimant's attorney, sent to the insurer's registered agent, the insurer must provide a written statement covering each known policy of the named insured that may be relevant to the claim, expressly including excess and umbrella coverage. The statement must identify the insurer, each insured party as listed on the declarations page, and the limits of liability coverage.
The statute restricts what a claimant may do with the information: under subsection (4), the claimant and counsel generally may not disclose it to others, except to discuss it with the claimant's own insurer.
How much is the penalty for failing to disclose policy information in Colorado?
An insurer that fails to make the required disclosure is liable to the requesting claimant for $100 per day, beginning on and including the 31st day after it receives the written request and continuing until it provides the information. The insurer is also responsible for the attorney fees and costs the claimant incurs in enforcing the remedy, a Fee Shifting provision that makes even modest daily totals worth litigating.
The Tenth Circuit narrowed the arithmetic in Fogel v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Co. (Nos. 24-1422 and 24-1440, May 21, 2026), an unpublished order and judgment applying Colorado law. The claimant sought $300 a day, one $100 penalty for each of three undisclosed policies. The court held that § 10-3-1117(3) authorizes one penalty per claim, not one per unanswered request or per policy, and affirmed an award of $35,600: $100 a day for the 356 days from March 4, 2022 through Feb. 23, 2023. It also held the claimant was entitled to appellate fees and costs for defending the award. Fogel is not binding on Colorado state courts, but it is the most detailed federal treatment of how the daily amount is calculated.
The other 10-3-1117 case already at the Colorado Supreme Court
Weatherill is the second § 10-3-1117 case the Supreme Court has taken this year. On Aug. 17, 2026, it granted review in Esurance Property & Casualty Insurance Co. v. Bohanan, No. 26SC158, arising from Bohanan v. Esurance, 2026 COA 6, decided Feb. 5, 2026 by a divided 2-1 division.
The question in Bohanan is whether the Court of Appeals erred in holding, as a matter of first impression, that § 10-3-1117(2)(a) required Esurance to disclose a copy of a policy that was not in effect at the time of the accident. The district court had capped the claimant's recovery at $600, representing the six days between the statutory deadline and the date Esurance told the claimant the policy was not in force. The Court of Appeals majority read the "may be relevant" language more broadly. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Colorado Chamber filed an amicus brief, dated Oct. 26, 2026, urging reversal and arguing that a policy "may be relevant" only when it could actually apply to the loss.
| Case | Court and date | Issue | Holding or status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reynolds v. Great Northern, 2023 COA 77 | Colo. Ct. App., Sept. 7, 2023 | Limitations period and accrual | Penalty; one year from day 31; claim barred |
| Bohanan v. Esurance, 2026 COA 6 | Colo. Ct. App., Feb. 5, 2026 (2-1) | Must a policy not in force at the accident be disclosed? | Yes, as "may be relevant"; certiorari granted Aug. 17, 2026 (No. 26SC158) |
| Weatherill v. State Farm, 2026 COA 11 | Colo. Ct. App., Mar. 12, 2026 | Limitations period and accrual | Not a penalty; two-year catchall; claim reinstated; certiorari granted Nov. 9, 2026 |
| Fogel v. Shelter Mutual | 10th Cir., May 21, 2026 (unpublished) | One penalty per claim or per request/policy? | One per claim; $35,600 for 356 days affirmed |
Taken together, the two Supreme Court cases will define both the scope of the disclosure duty (Bohanan) and the time available to enforce it (Weatherill). It is possible the court will consider them in tandem or let the first decision shape the second, though it has said nothing about coordinating them.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| May 22, 2019 | HB 19-1283 signed, adding § 10-3-1117 |
| Jan. 1, 2020 | § 10-3-1117 takes effect |
| December 2020 | Weatherills' collision with State Farm-insured driver |
| Jan.-Feb. 2021 | Weatherills' § 10-3-1117 requests to State Farm |
| Oct. 31, 2022 | Weatherills learn of $1,000,000 umbrella policy |
| November 2022 | Weatherills sue State Farm |
| Sept. 7, 2023 | Reynolds adopts one-year penalty rule |
| Feb. 5, 2026 | Bohanan decided by Court of Appeals |
| Mar. 12, 2026 | Weatherill rejects Reynolds, applies two-year period |
| May 21, 2026 | Tenth Circuit decides Fogel |
| Aug. 17, 2026 | Supreme Court grants review in Bohanan |
| Nov. 9, 2026 | Supreme Court grants review in Weatherill |
What it means for personal injury lawyers, insurers and defense counsel
Claimants' counsel. Until the Supreme Court rules, the conservative course is to treat the one-year Reynolds period as live. That means calendaring the 31st day after the insurer's registered agent receives each § 10-3-1117 request and counting one year from that date for any nondisclosure claim, rather than relying on the two-year Weatherill rule or on later discovery. Proof of the registered agent's receipt date becomes important evidence. Where a response looks incomplete, for example a primary policy with no mention of excess or umbrella coverage for a commercial or high-net-worth insured, a prompt, specific follow-up request creates a cleaner record.
Claims already filed between one and two years after day 31 are the ones most exposed. Lawyers holding such claims should expect defendants to move to stay pending the Supreme Court's decision, or to preserve the Reynolds defense for appeal.
Insurers and claims departments. The daily remedy has no cap, the fee-shifting provision raises the cost of losing, and Fogel shows a single late claim can produce a five-figure award. If Weatherill is affirmed, nondisclosures discovered late, especially omitted umbrella or excess policies, remain actionable for two years from discovery. Compliance audits that confirm every known policy of the named insured is captured in the 30-day statement are cheaper than litigating the limitations defense.
Defense counsel. A win for State Farm would revive Reynolds as the controlling rule and may make it easier to argue for narrow construction of the statute in other disputes, including the scope question in Bohanan. A loss would close off the limitations defense in most late-discovery cases and leave the per-claim cap from Fogel as the main limit on exposure in federal court.
The wider PI bar. Colorado is one of a number of states with pre-suit policy-limits disclosure laws. How its high court characterizes a fixed daily remedy for nondisclosure may be cited in other jurisdictions that have adopted, or are considering, similar statutes. It also bears on the Statute of Limitations analysis for other Colorado statutory remedies that award fixed sums.
What happens next
State Farm, as the petitioner, will file an opening brief, followed by the Weatherills' answer brief and any amicus filings. Given that business groups weighed in on Bohanan, amicus participation in Weatherill would not be surprising. The court will then set oral argument. No dates have been published. Until a decision issues, both Reynolds and Weatherill remain published Court of Appeals precedent, and the March 2026 judgment reinstating the Weatherills' complaint is under review.
FAQ
What is the statute of limitations for a 10-3-1117 claim in Colorado?
It is currently disputed. Reynolds v. Great Northern (2023) applies a one-year period starting on the 31st day after the insurer receives the request, while Weatherill v. State Farm (2026) applies a two-year period tied to discovery; the Colorado Supreme Court agreed on Nov. 9, 2026 to decide which is right.
When does a 10-3-1117 claim accrue?
Under Reynolds, the claim accrues on the 31st day after the insurer's registered agent receives the written request, and later days of noncompliance do not restart the clock. Under Weatherill, the claim accrues when the claimant discovers, or reasonably should have discovered, the nondisclosure.
Does 10-3-1117 require disclosure of umbrella policies?
Yes. The claimant statement must cover each known policy of the named insured that may be relevant to the claim, including excess or umbrella coverage, and the omission of a $1,000,000 umbrella policy is the alleged violation in Weatherill.
How much can a claimant recover if an insurer does not respond?
The insurer owes $100 per day from the 31st day after receiving the request until it complies, plus the claimant's attorney fees and costs of enforcement. The Tenth Circuit held in Fogel v. Shelter Mutual that the $100 is owed once per claim, not once per policy or request.
Is Reynolds v. Great Northern still good law?
It remains a published Court of Appeals opinion, but a later division declined to follow it in Weatherill, and the Colorado Supreme Court's review of Weatherill will decide which approach survives.
What should Colorado personal injury lawyers do while the Weatherill appeal is pending?
Practitioners commonly treat the shorter one-year Reynolds period as the operative deadline, document the registered agent's receipt date for every request, and follow up promptly on incomplete responses. This summary is analysis, not legal advice for any particular claim.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Nationwide Bad Faith Verdict Cut by $87 Million as Washington Court Voids Ohio-Law Punitive Damages
On November 10, 2026 Washington's Court of Appeals reversed about $87 million of a $103.2 million judgment against Nationwide, striking a $47 million punitive award and the IFCA claim but affirming bad faith, negligence and Consumer Protection Act liability.
Courts Desk · 11 min

Hazelnut Allergy Lawsuit Verdict: Colorado Jury Hits Wafer Distributor Solen USA With $1.55 Million
A federal jury in Colorado found Solen USA liable for an undeclared hazelnut in a Biscolata wafer that sent a 10-year-old into a severe reaction, awarding $350,000 in compensatory and $1.2 million in punitive damages. Colorado's punitive cap and the state consumer act's trebling rule now decide the final number.
Torts Desk · 16 min

A $65 Million Colorado Trucking Verdict Runs Into a $598,350 Cap
A Larimer County jury returned a unanimous $65 million wrongful death verdict on 21 September 2026 over the 2022 I-25 bridge strike that killed Megan Arneson. Colorado caps noneconomic damages but not economic loss, and the driver's vehicular homicide plea does not lift the cap.
Torts Desk · 12 min