Becton Dickinson Ethylene Oxide Verdict: Georgia Appeals Court Limits Retrial to Intent
On November 3, 2026 the Georgia Court of Appeals refused to give Becton Dickinson and C.R. Bard a full new trial over Gary Walker's $20 million ethylene oxide verdict. A new jury will decide only whether the companies intended harm, the finding that sets punitive damages at $50 million or $250,000.
Torts Desk··15 min read

The Becton Dickinson ethylene oxide verdict survived appeal on November 3, 2026. The Court of Appeals of Georgia rejected the bid by Becton, Dickinson and Company (BD) and its predecessor C.R. Bard to retry the whole case and affirmed a narrower retrial limited to one question: whether the companies acted with specific intent to cause harm. The answer decides whether retired truck driver Gary Walker, who won $20 million in compensatory damages for non-Hodgkin lymphoma he blamed on decades of emissions from the Covington, Georgia sterilization plant, ends up with a judgment of about $70 million or about $20.25 million under Georgia's punitive damages cap.
The ruling in Becton, Dickinson and Company v. Walker, No. A26A1118, is the first appellate word on the first ethylene oxide case tried to verdict in Georgia. Roughly 430 more Covington suits are waiting behind it, and the decision affects how Georgia trial courts handle a punitive phase that collapses after the compensatory award is in. Local reporting picked up the decision between November 7 and November 11, 2026, and it is now the central fact in valuing the Georgia ethylene oxide docket.
What did the Georgia Court of Appeals decide in Becton Dickinson v. Walker?
The Court of Appeals affirmed a Gwinnett County State Court order that granted a partial retrial on "the sole issue of specific intent to cause harm," rather than the full retrial on liability and punitive damages that BD and Bard had asked for. The court held that confining the retrial to that question did not violate the defendants' right to a fair trial. The trial court had treated the amount of punitive damages and the specific-intent finding as separate questions that could be tried apart, and the appellate court found no error in that approach.
In practical terms, three things now stand. First, the $20 million compensatory verdict is intact. Second, the companies' liability for negligence and public nuisance, found by the jury in May 2025, will not be retried. Third, a new jury will hear evidence on intent alone, and its answer will either unlock the $50 million punitive figure the first jury put on the verdict form or drop punitive damages to the statutory ceiling of $250,000.
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution described the decision as upholding a $70 million verdict while preserving the companies' ability to cut it by roughly two-thirds at the new trial. Yahoo News framed it from the other direction: a new jury could reduce Walker's recovery to $20.25 million. Both descriptions are accurate. The case is now a binary contest over a single factual finding.
The case came to the Court of Appeals on interlocutory review. On October 23, 2025, under application No. A26I0048, the court granted the defendants' application for interlocutory appeal, which let them challenge the retrial order before any second trial took place. The opinion issued just over a year later.
How the $70 million Becton Dickinson ethylene oxide verdict was built
The Becton Dickinson ethylene oxide verdict came out of a trial that ran from mid-April to May 6, 2025 before State Court Judge Emily Brantley in Gwinnett County, under case No. 21-C-08201. Walker, a longtime Covington resident diagnosed with cancer in 2017, alleged that he was exposed over 47 years to ethylene oxide, a gas the plant has used to sterilize medical devices since 1967. He sued BD and Bard for negligence and public nuisance. The defense position, as reported by Courtroom View Network and Expert Institute, was that his lymphoma was a randomly occurring cancer and that his exposure was too low to cause it.
The trial was split into phases. In the first, the jury decided liability and compensatory damages. In the second, it decided punitive damages and, critically, whether the companies acted with specific intent to cause harm.
| Date | Event | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1967 | Covington plant begins sterilizing medical devices with ethylene oxide | Exposure period at issue begins |
| 2017 | Walker diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma | Later suit filed in State Court of Gwinnett County (No. 21-C-08201) |
| Apr. 2025 | Trial opens before Judge Emily Brantley | First Georgia ethylene oxide trial to reach a jury |
| May 2, 2025 | Phase one verdict after just over three hours of deliberation | Liability for negligence and public nuisance; $20 million compensatory damages |
| Phase two | Jury returns $50 million punitive award with a unanimous form | Juror disavows the specific-intent finding when polled |
| May 6, 2025 | Trial court order | Mistrial on punitive phase only; $20 million verdict stands |
| Later in 2025 | Trial court limits retrial to specific intent | Defendants seek interlocutory review |
| Oct. 23, 2025 | Court of Appeals grants interlocutory application (A26I0048) | Appeal docketed as A26A1118 |
| Nov. 3, 2026 | Court of Appeals decision | Partial retrial on specific intent affirmed |
| Nov. 7–11, 2026 | AJC, CDLLife and Yahoo report the ruling | Companies say they will seek further review |
The trial team for Walker included Michael Geoffroy and Amer Ahmad of MG Law, Stephen "Buck" Daniel of Rueb Stoller Daniel, and Lindsay Forlines of Chance Forlines Carter & King. Penn Law Group, which earlier reported handling a majority of the Georgia ethylene oxide cases against BD, has also publicized the verdict and mistrial.
Is ethylene oxide linked to non-Hodgkin lymphoma?
At the population level, regulators treat the link as established for some cancers. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies ethylene oxide as a Group 1 human carcinogen. The EPA's 2016 Integrated Risk Information System assessment characterized it as carcinogenic to humans by inhalation, pointing to lymphoid cancers and, in women, breast cancer. That regulatory science is the foundation of General Causation arguments in every ethylene oxide suit.
A courtroom asks a narrower question. Plaintiffs must also prove Specific Causation, meaning that this plaintiff's exposure, at the concentrations near this plant over this period, more likely than not caused this plaintiff's cancer. That is where the Walker defense focused, arguing that the lymphoma was a background cancer unrelated to the plant. The jury rejected that argument, and the Court of Appeals left the compensatory verdict untouched. Each later plaintiff will still have to prove causation separately, under the reliability standards the Court of Appeals set out in Mutz.
Why did the judge declare a mistrial on punitive damages?
The mistrial came from jury polling. When the second-phase verdict was read, the form reflected a unanimous award of $50 million in punitive damages. Polling then exposed a problem with the intent finding. According to reports of the post-verdict polling, one juror said that she had gone along with the rest of the panel on whether the plant's operator intended to cause harm only because the judge had instructed that the verdict had to be unanimous. Courtroom View Network reported that the dissenting juror cited uncertainty about whether BD actually meant to cause harm by releasing ethylene oxide into the air. Another juror reportedly said they had "deferred to the group."
A unanimous verdict that a juror disavows on polling is not a unanimous verdict. BD's lawyers asked for a mistrial of the entire case. Judge Brantley refused that request and declared a mistrial only as to the punitive phase, leaving the compensatory verdict from the prior week in place. That split ruling set up the question the Court of Appeals has now answered: when only the intent finding is tainted, must everything after liability be retried, or can the court send back just the defective finding?
What happens next in the Walker ethylene oxide case?
A new Gwinnett County jury will be empaneled to decide one factual question: whether BD and Bard acted, or failed to act, with the specific intent to cause harm. No retrial date had been publicly reported as of November 13, 2026.
Before any retrial, the companies have signaled that they will keep litigating on appeal. The AJC and CDLLife both report that BD and Bard plan to pursue further review, potentially by petitioning the Supreme Court of Georgia. Georgia's high court hears Court of Appeals cases on certiorari at its discretion. If it takes the case, the retrial would likely wait for that decision. If it declines, the case returns to Gwinnett County for the intent-only trial.
The outcomes of that retrial are easy to map:
| Retrial finding | Punitive damages | Compensatory damages | Approximate total judgment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specific intent to cause harm found | $50 million (no statutory cap) | $20 million | About $70 million, before interest |
| Specific intent not found | $250,000 (statutory cap) | $20 million | About $20.25 million, before interest |
The figures in the table reflect how the AJC and Yahoo describe the stakes. They assume the $50 million figure carries forward if intent is found, which is the premise of the partial-retrial order. Post-judgment interest and costs would be added to either total.
Does Georgia cap punitive damages in ethylene oxide cases?
Yes. The cap applies unless the jury makes a specific finding of intent. Georgia's punitive damages statute, O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1, limits awards in most tort actions to $250,000 under subsection (g). Subsection (f) removes the cap when the trier of fact finds that the defendant "acted, or failed to act, with the specific intent to cause harm," and separately when the defendant was under the influence of alcohol or drugs. A third track, subsection (e), governs product liability actions. It removes the cap but sends most of the award to the state treasury. Walker's claims were pleaded in negligence and nuisance against a plant operator, not as product liability claims, and the reported stakes make clear that subsection (e) is not in play.
The specific-intent exception is demanding. Georgia courts have long required the jury to make a separate finding of specific intent before an award can exceed $250,000; McDaniel v. Elliott, 269 Ga. 262 (1998), is the case usually cited for that rule. The finding is distinct from the "willful misconduct, malice, fraud, wantonness, oppression, or that entire want of care which would raise the presumption of conscious indifference to consequences" that a plaintiff must prove by clear and convincing evidence to get punitive damages at all. A jury can find conscious indifference, award punitive damages, and still leave the plaintiff at $250,000 if it does not find specific intent.
That is why one juror's doubt mattered so much. On the reported polling, the jury's problem was not whether BD and Bard deserved punishment but whether they meant to cause harm. The difference between those two findings is $49.75 million.
Why the Court of Appeals let the intent question be retried alone
The defense argument for a full retrial was that liability, punitive conduct and intent are intertwined. A new jury asked only about intent would hear an abbreviated version of the case, the argument ran, without having weighed the full liability record. On that view, a fair trial required the new jury to decide the whole case.
The trial court, and now the Court of Appeals, rejected that framing. The available text of the opinion shows the court treating damages and specific intent as separate questions and holding that the trial court did not err in limiting retrial to the sole issue of specific intent. The reasoning fits a familiar principle in American procedure: a partial new trial is permissible when the issue to be retried is distinct enough from the rest of the verdict that it can be tried alone without injustice. Here the first jury's liability and compensatory findings were not challenged as tainted by the polling problem. Only the intent finding was.
The ruling also fits Georgia's structure for punitive damages. The statute already treats the specific-intent finding as a separate determination that changes the legal consequence of an award. Separating that finding for retrial applies the same line the statute draws. Georgia's 2025 tort reform package, Senate Bill 68, now lets any party demand a phased trial under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-15, with punitive damages tried last. Phased trials will be more common, and so will collapses in a later phase. The Walker opinion gives trial judges authority to repair the defective phase without discarding the earlier ones.
What the court did not do is equally important. Nothing in the coverage indicates that the Court of Appeals passed on whether the evidence would support a specific-intent finding, or whether the $50 million figure is constitutionally excessive. Those questions remain open for the retrial and any later appeal.
What it means for the Covington ethylene oxide lawsuits
The Walker case is a bellwether in all but name. It is the first of hundreds of Covington suits to reach a verdict, and every number in it will drive settlement valuation for the rest of the docket.
Scale of the docket. BD's quarterly report for the period ended March 31, 2026 disclosed approximately 430 suits involving about 440 plaintiffs asserting individual personal injury claims tied to the Covington facility. About 50 of those cases also allege injury from a chemical attributed to an unrelated defendant. Earlier AJC reporting put the Georgia ethylene oxide caseload against BD at 402, with Penn Law Group involved in 272.
A $20 million anchor. With the compensatory award affirmed past the retrial stage, plaintiffs' counsel now hold an appellate-tested $20 million figure for a single non-Hodgkin lymphoma claimant. Because the defense theory that the cancer was random did not persuade the jury, the specific causation evidence in Walker becomes a template for later trials.
A punitive damages question that is now binary. The cap structure means punitive exposure in Georgia ethylene oxide cases will turn on whether juries find specific intent to cause harm, not on the size of the number they write down. Defense counsel will try to keep the intent question narrow, and plaintiffs' counsel will build their record around what the companies knew and when.
Causation remains the main battleground. The Walker appeal arrived in the shadow of Sterigenics US LLC v. Mutz, No. A25A1377, decided October 31, 2025. In Mutz, the Court of Appeals addressed for the first time how Georgia's Rule 702, O.C.G.A. § 24-7-702, applies to general causation experts in toxic tort cases. It held that the Cobb County trial court misapplied the federal McClain framework by letting an "any exposure" theory pass without a rigorous reliability analysis. It also held that an expert need not always identify a specific dose-response threshold for a substance like ethylene oxide. According to Sterigenics' own investor materials, on remand the trial court excluded the plaintiffs' general causation experts and granted summary judgment in five pool cases against the Smyrna-area operator. The Covington cases against BD are a separate docket, but every expert in them will now be tested against Mutz.
Industry pressure on the science. AdvaMed, the medical device trade association, filed an amicus brief in the Walker appeal, through counsel of record Phil Goldberg of Shook, Hardy & Bacon. The brief urged the Court of Appeals to reverse what it called a trial court ruling admitting unreliable expert testimony about ethylene oxide exposure, and argued that ethylene oxide sterilization is essential to the medical device supply. The affirmance is a setback for that position in this case. The industry's argument is still likely to recur in every Daubert Challenge, or Georgia Rule 702 motion, in the remaining Covington suits.
What it means for defendants, plaintiffs' firms and funders
For defense counsel. The decision limits a familiar post-trial option. When a punitive phase fails because of a juror problem, a Georgia defendant can no longer assume the whole case is retried. Defense teams in phased trials should expect trial courts to isolate the defective finding. That raises the stakes of verdict-form drafting and polling objections in the first trial.
For plaintiffs' firms. The ruling protects a compensatory award won after a multi-week trial from being reopened because of a dispute confined to the punitive phase. In a Mass Tort docket with hundreds of similar claims, that protection matters. It also shows how much the specific-intent question decides. Firms trying Covington cases will need evidence of corporate knowledge and decision-making directed at that statutory standard, not only at conscious indifference.
For litigation funders and settlement planners. The $70 million versus $20.25 million split is a large range for a single claim, and the Supreme Court of Georgia may still weigh in. Anyone pricing Third-Party Litigation Funding exposure or modeling a Global Settlement for the Covington docket now has a concrete compensatory benchmark. The punitive variable will remain unresolved until a jury answers the intent question.
For other ethylene oxide jurisdictions. The best-known comparison remains Illinois. In September 2022 a Cook County jury awarded Sue Kamuda $363 million, including $325 million in punitive damages, against Sterigenics over emissions from its Willowbrook plant. In January 2023 Sterigenics and parent Sotera Health agreed to pay $408 million to resolve roughly 870 remaining claims. Illinois has no equivalent of Georgia's $250,000 cap for these claims, which is why the specific-intent finding is so much more important in Georgia than the size of the punitive award.
The regulatory backdrop: the 2024 EPA rule and the exemptions
The litigation is running alongside a federal fight over ethylene oxide emissions limits. In April 2024 the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency finalized tighter emissions standards for commercial sterilizers. On July 17, 2025, President Trump granted two-year exemptions from that rule to 40 commercial sterilizer facilities, including BD's Covington plant, formerly known as Bard Manufacturing. In January 2026, Sustainable Newton joined the Southern Environmental Law Center, the Natural Resources Defense Council and other groups in a federal suit challenging the exemptions; BD is not a named defendant. BD's SEC filing notes that the EPA published a proposed reconsideration of the 2024 sterilizer standards on March 17, 2026.
None of those regulatory moves controls the tort cases. Compliance with emissions permits is not a defense to a negligence or nuisance claim in itself. But the regulatory record matters to the punitive phase, because evidence of what regulators required and what the plant emitted is the kind of evidence a jury will weigh when it decides whether a defendant intended harm.
Frequently asked questions
How much was the Becton Dickinson ethylene oxide verdict?
A Gwinnett County jury awarded Gary Walker $20 million in compensatory damages on May 2, 2025, and later returned a $50 million punitive damages award. The punitive award was undone by a mistrial on May 6, 2025, and its fate now depends on a retrial limited to specific intent.
Did Becton Dickinson win its appeal?
No. On November 3, 2026, the Court of Appeals of Georgia affirmed the trial court's order and rejected BD and Bard's request to retry the entire case. The $20 million compensatory award stands. The companies kept the chance to cut the punitive award to $250,000 if a new jury does not find specific intent to cause harm.
Why could the award drop to $20.25 million?
Georgia caps punitive damages at $250,000 in most tort cases under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1(g), unless the jury finds specific intent to cause harm. If the retrial jury does not make that finding, Walker's recovery would be $20 million in compensatory damages plus $250,000 in punitive damages.
Who is Gary Walker and what cancer did he have?
Walker is a retired truck driver and longtime Covington, Georgia resident who was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma in 2017. He alleged 47 years of exposure to ethylene oxide emitted by the medical device sterilization plant now owned by BD.
How many ethylene oxide lawsuits are pending against Becton Dickinson?
BD reported about 430 personal injury suits involving about 440 plaintiffs over its Covington facility as of March 31, 2026, according to its quarterly SEC filing.
Can Becton Dickinson still appeal?
Yes. The companies have said they plan to seek further review, potentially in the Supreme Court of Georgia, which takes cases from the Court of Appeals on discretionary certiorari. The retrial on intent could wait until that request is resolved.
This article is analysis of public court records and reporting and is not legal advice.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Georgia Anchoring Law: Walmart Wins New Trial as Appeals Court Voids $975,000 Slip-and-Fall Verdict
On October 29, 2026 the Georgia Court of Appeals backed Walmart's bid for a new trial after a $975,000 slip-and-fall verdict, holding that the plaintiff's closing-argument dollar comparisons for pain and suffering broke the 2025 SB 68 amendment to OCGA § 9-10-184.
Torts Desk · 15 min

Bernavage Punitive Damages Ruling: En Banc Pa. Superior Court Backs Midtrial Recklessness Amendment
Sitting en banc on reargument, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania has sided with a Lackawanna County trial judge who let a nursing home plaintiff add recklessness mid-trial, reversing the 2025 panel that wiped out a $2.7 million punitive damages award as unfair surprise.
Courts Desk · 12 min

Amherst PFOA Verdict: NH Jury Awards Homeowner Class $4.36 Million Against Textiles Coated
In the Amherst PFOA verdict, a Hillsborough County jury on November 6, 2026 found Textiles Coated International liable to a class of New Hampshire homeowners with contaminated wells and awarded $4.36 million for lost property value, with non-economic damages still to come.
Torts Desk · 11 min