Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions: Split California Court Refuses to Enforce 'Lifetime' Arbitration Clause
In Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, published November 13, 2026, a 2-1 California Court of Appeal refused to enforce a call-center employer's arbitration clause covering almost any claim for life, holding it too unconscionable to save by severance. The dissent says the FAA forbids that method.
Courts Desk··16 min read

In Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, a published opinion filed November 13, 2026, a divided California Court of Appeal refused to enforce a call-center employer's arbitration agreement that would have required a six-week employee to arbitrate nearly any claim against the company, job-related or not, for the rest of her life. The 2-1 panel held the agreement, read alongside a confidentiality agreement from the same hiring packet, so permeated with unconscionability that severance could not save it, so Tracie Bennett's wage-and-hour class action stays in Los Angeles Superior Court.
The decision, Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, No. B346763, comes from the Second Appellate District, Division Eight, the same division that a day earlier certified Salazar v. CN Motor for publication and severed a different employer's overbroad terms instead of voiding the agreement. The two cases now sit side by side as the clearest current map of where California courts draw the line between a fixable arbitration agreement and an unfixable one. Justice Wiley's dissent adds a third element: a direct argument that California's application of unconscionability doctrine to arbitration agreements is preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), backed by a statistical survey of five years of California appellate decisions. That framing makes Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions a plausible candidate for California Supreme Court review.
What did the court decide in Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions?
The Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court's order denying VXI Global Solutions, LLC's motion to compel arbitration and awarded Bennett her costs on appeal. The opinion refers to the employer as "Global." Its core holdings are four.
First, the arbitration agreement and a separate confidentiality agreement that Bennett signed in the same onboarding packet must be read together when deciding whether the arbitration terms are unconscionable.
Second, the arbitration agreement contains "a high degree of substantive unconscionability." The court agreed with the trial court that its scope and its duration were each unconscionable, and it identified further defects. According to HCAMag's report on the ruling, the majority counted at least five unconscionable provisions across the two documents.
Third, two provisions of the confidentiality agreement were also unconscionable: an injunctive relief clause that relieved Global of proving the ordinary elements for an injunction, including irreparable harm, and a nonsolicitation clause the court found unlawful under California law.
Fourth, and decisive for the remedy, the confidentiality agreement's bad terms could be severed "without fundamentally altering the arbitration agreement," but "the same cannot be said for the unconscionable provisions contained in the arbitration agreement itself." The agreement, the court concluded, was permeated with unconscionability that severance could not cure, so the trial court did not abuse its discretion by refusing to enforce it at all.
The opinion is certified for publication, which means it is binding on California trial courts and citable under California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115, unless the California Supreme Court grants review or orders it depublished.
Background: a six-week job and a 100-page hiring packet
Global, a Los Angeles-based customer-service outsourcing company, hired Bennett as an account associate in February 2023. The opinion notes that she has a high school education. She worked for the company until April 2023, roughly six weeks.
When she started, Global gave her a new hire packet of approximately 100 pages containing various policies and forms. An arbitration agreement and a confidentiality agreement appeared in the middle of the packet.
In October 2023, Bennett filed a putative class action against Global in Los Angeles County Superior Court. Reports describe ten causes of action, including unpaid minimum wages, unpaid overtime, and missed meal and rest breaks: the standard California wage-and-hour package, typically paired with Unfair Competition Law and waiting-time claims.
Global moved to compel individual arbitration. The trial court held that the FAA governed the agreement but denied the motion. It found the agreement was a contract of adhesion with a low degree of procedural unconscionability: a standard, take-it-or-leave-it form. On the substantive side it identified two defects: the agreement's scope was unreasonably overbroad because it expressly applied to claims unrelated to Bennett's employment, and its duration was unreasonably long. Because the court concluded the defects could not be severed without rewriting the contract, it refused enforcement. Global appealed, as Code of Civil Procedure section 1294, subdivision (a) permits for an order denying a petition to compel arbitration.
Why did the court call it a "lifetime" arbitration clause?
The phrase comes from the combination of two features the majority found unconscionable, scope and duration, which together meant Bennett would have to arbitrate nearly any claim she could ever have against the company for the rest of her life, until she and Global agreed to terminate the agreement.
Scope: any claim against anyone connected to Global
The agreement required Bennett to arbitrate any claim she had against Global "and all of its past or present employees, officers, administrators, and agents," even if her claims were "wholly unrelated to her employment." The court treated that as the central substantive defect. A clause of that breadth would, on its terms, force a former call-center worker to arbitrate a car accident with a Global manager, a consumer dispute with an affiliate, or a tort claim against a former coworker, years after she left.
Global did not dispute that forcing arbitration of claims wholly unrelated to employment would be unconscionable. Its position was that the clause should be read narrowly, to reach only employment-related claims. The majority rejected that reading because the agreement expressly covered claims "whether or not" they arose from employment, and construing it narrowly would render that language meaningless.
Duration: survival with no end point
The agreement survived the end of Bennett's employment and could be modified or terminated only by a signed writing. The majority acknowledged that no general rule of contract law holds an indefinite duration unfair in itself. It nonetheless followed Cook v. University of Southern California (2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 312, another Second District decision, in which an employment arbitration agreement that survived unless both parties terminated it in a signed writing expressly mentioning the agreement was held to reveal fatal unconscionability when combined with an unlimited scope.
The logic is cumulative rather than freestanding. An open-ended duration attached to a clause limited to employment disputes would do little harm, because the universe of employment disputes closes once the job ends. Attached to a clause covering every claim against every person connected to the company, an indefinite duration converts a hiring form into a permanent waiver of the courthouse.
Why was the confidentiality agreement relevant to the arbitration agreement?
The court read the two documents together because Bennett signed them at the same time, in the same packet, as part of the same transaction. That approach follows the general contract principle that several contracts relating to the same matters, between the same parties, and made as parts of substantially one transaction are to be taken together. California courts applied the same reasoning in August 2026 in Cluck v. GEO Secure Services, where a confidentiality agreement signed the same day as an arbitration agreement rendered the arbitration arrangement one-sided.
Two confidentiality terms drew the court's criticism.
The injunctive relief provision allowed Global to obtain injunctions without establishing the usual elements, including irreparable harm. The court held the provision substantively unconscionable because "Global identifies no legitimate commercial reason for a contractual provision that relieves it of the need to establish essential elements for the issuance of an injunction." The asymmetry matters in an arbitration analysis: the employer kept a fast lane to court for the claims it was most likely to bring, trade-secret and confidentiality claims, while the employee was routed to arbitration for nearly everything.
The nonsolicitation provision barred Bennett from soliciting Global employees for a competing business during her employment and for one year afterward. The court held it unlawful under California law, which has long been hostile to post-employment restraints on workers. Notably, the majority pointed out that the dissent applied the same analysis and agreed the nonsolicitation clause is unenforceable.
How does Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions treat severance?
Severance was where the case was won and lost. Under Civil Code section 1670.5 and the California Supreme Court's 2024 decision in Ramirez v. Charter Communications, a court that finds unconscionable terms must decide whether the central purpose of the contract is so tainted that the whole agreement should fall, or whether the bad terms can be removed by striking language without augmenting or reforming the contract. Ramirez rejected any bright-line rule that multiple unconscionable terms automatically defeat enforcement, but it also directed courts to consider whether severing would create an incentive for the drafter to load agreements with unfair terms, confident that a court will simply trim them.
The Bennett majority split its severance analysis by document:
| Provision | Document | Unconscionable? | Severable? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope covering claims "whether or not" related to employment, against Global and all past or present employees, officers, administrators and agents | Arbitration agreement | Yes, high degree | No: removing it would require rewriting the clause |
| Indefinite duration, surviving employment until terminated by signed writing | Arbitration agreement | Yes, in combination with scope (following Cook) | No |
| Injunctive relief without proof of irreparable harm or other ordinary elements | Confidentiality agreement | Yes | Yes, without fundamentally altering the arbitration agreement |
| One-year employee nonsolicitation | Confidentiality agreement | Unlawful under California law (dissent agreed) | Yes |
| Procedural setting: adhesive form in a 100-page packet | Both | Low procedural unconscionability | Not applicable |
Global proposed a targeted fix: strike two phrases from the scope language. The majority rejected it because the remaining text would still cover all claims involving Global, and adding limiting language to confine the clause to employment disputes would be reformation, which Ramirez and section 1670.5 do not allow. Commentary on the opinion has highlighted the majority's point that the more unconscionable provisions a contract contains, the less likely it is that severance will be the appropriate remedy.
Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions vs. Salazar v. CN Motor: same division, opposite outcomes
Both opinions come from Division Eight of the Second District, both involve California wage-and-hour class actions, both involve overbroad scope language, and both apply Ramirez. Yet Salazar ordered arbitration and Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions refused it. The differences explain a great deal about how employment arbitration agreements now succeed or fail in California.
| Issue | Salazar v. CN Motor (certified Nov. 12, 2026) | Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions (filed Nov. 13, 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Procedural unconscionability | Minimal; trial court's oppression and surprise findings unsupported | Low; adhesive form in a 100-page packet |
| Scope defect | "Of any nature" language and affiliates reach | Claims "whether or not" employment-related, against all past or present personnel |
| Duration defect | Not a basis of decision | Indefinite survival, following Cook |
| Collateral document | None in issue | Confidentiality agreement read together, with injunction and nonsolicitation defects |
| Number of defects | Several, each removable by striking phrases, a sentence and a paragraph | At least five reported across both documents |
| Severance | Required; refusal was an abuse of discretion | Refusal affirmed; scope defect could not be fixed without rewriting |
| Result | Individual arbitration compelled; class waiver remanded | Denial of motion to compel arbitration affirmed |
| Dissent | None reported | Justice Wiley, on FAA preemption grounds |
Two lessons follow. First, the standard of review matters: in Salazar the appellate court found the trial court's refusal to sever an abuse of discretion, while in Bennett it found no abuse of discretion in the same kind of refusal, because the offending language there could not be excised cleanly. Second, the collateral confidentiality agreement changed the arithmetic in Bennett. It added defects, added a visible asymmetry favoring the employer, and supported the inference Ramirez warns about, that the drafter had loaded the paperwork with one-sided terms.
What did the dissent argue about the Federal Arbitration Act?
Justice Wiley's dissent argued that "the majority opinion uses a prohibited state law method to invalidate federally protected arbitration." His theory rests on the equal-treatment principle the US Supreme Court has drawn from section 2 of the FAA in cases such as AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011): states may invalidate arbitration agreements through generally applicable contract defenses like unconscionability, but not through rules that apply only to arbitration or that are applied in a way that disfavors it.
The dissent made two moves. It observed that the unconscionability precedents Bennett and the majority relied on, including those used to evaluate the non-arbitration provisions of the confidentiality agreement, are themselves arbitration cases. And it conducted a statistical analysis of California decisions over the past five years to argue that California courts invalidate arbitration agreements through unconscionability at a higher rate than other contracts. HCAMag reports that the survey covered 713 California unconscionability decisions from 2021 through 2025 and found that between 79 and 90 percent involved arbitration, a pattern the dissent described as "antipathy to arbitration."
The majority responded that its "unconscionability analysis is not preempted by the FAA" and that it applied "well-settled and generally applicable rules of unconscionability." It added that the dissent points to no decision of the California Supreme Court or the US Supreme Court undermining Sonic-Calabasas A, Inc. v. Moreno, the California Supreme Court's post-Concepcion holding that unconscionability remains a valid defense to arbitration agreements, and it called the dissent's statistics not definitive. The majority's point about the nonsolicitation clause served as a rejoinder: the dissent itself applied ordinary California law to find that non-arbitration term unenforceable.
The empirical argument is the novel element. Defense counsel have long argued that California applies unconscionability more aggressively to arbitration than to other contracts; Bennett puts a dataset in a published appellate opinion. Whether that is legally relevant is contested. A high share of unconscionability decisions involving arbitration may simply reflect that arbitration clauses are the adhesive term most often litigated, not that courts apply a harsher standard. But a published dissent with numbers attached is the kind of record a petitioner cites when asking the California Supreme Court, and ultimately the US Supreme Court, to take up FAA preemption.
How does Bennett fit with Cook, Ayala-Ventura and other "infinite" clause cases?
The term "infinite arbitration clause," popularized by Professor David Horton's 2020 law review article of that name, describes agreements with no sunset date and no limit to the dispute that gave rise to them. Courts have split on how to treat them.
- Cook v. University of Southern California (2d Dist. 2024) held an employment arbitration agreement covering all claims, including those unrelated to the job, for an unlimited period unconscionable and wholly unenforceable. USC's vast institutional footprint made it realistic that a former employee could have unrelated disputes with it decades later.
- Ayala-Ventura v. Superior Court (5th Dist., published March 2026, No. F089695) upheld an order compelling a janitor to arbitrate under an agreement that also covered claims "whether or not arising out of employment" and survived termination. The Fifth District distinguished Cook because the employer solely provided commercial janitorial services, so a vast range of unrelated claims was unlikely, and stressed mutuality and the employer's assumption of arbitration costs. Commentators read it as confirming Cook created no per se rule.
- Revitch v. DirecTV (9th Cir. 2020) refused to compel arbitration of a consumer's claim against DirecTV under a wireless contract he had signed with AT&T years earlier, rejecting a literal reading of a clause that would have bound him in disputes with any AT&T affiliate forever.
- Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions (2d Dist., Nov. 13, 2026) lands closer to Cook than to Ayala-Ventura. Global is a large outsourcing company, its clause reached every past or present employee, officer, administrator and agent, and the confidentiality agreement removed any claim of mutuality.
The practical reading is that California courts examine scope and duration in context: the size and reach of the employer, the realistic set of disputes, whether the terms are mutual, and whether collateral documents tilt the bargain. A large-employer agreement that reaches non-employment claims indefinitely is now on the wrong side of two published Second District opinions.
Does the Bennett ruling affect other California arbitration agreements?
Yes, as precedent, though not automatically. Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions binds every California trial court while it stands, so any employee facing a motion to compel arbitration under an agreement that covers claims unrelated to employment, survives indefinitely, or sits beside a one-sided confidentiality, injunction, or nonsolicitation agreement can cite it. It does not invalidate any other company's agreement; each one is still judged on its own terms and record, and Salazar shows that a defective agreement with cleanly removable terms can still be enforced.
Federal courts sitting in California apply California unconscionability law to these agreements and treat published Court of Appeal decisions as strong evidence of state law, so the ruling is likely to be cited in federal motion practice as well.
What happens next in Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions?
Under California Rules of Court, a Court of Appeal decision generally becomes final 30 days after filing, which for an opinion filed November 13 points to mid-December 2026, and a petition for review in the California Supreme Court is due within 10 days after that. A party may also seek rehearing in the Court of Appeal before finality. Given the dissent's preemption argument and the tension with Ayala-Ventura, a petition for review is likely; the Supreme Court could grant review, deny it, or deny it and order the opinion depublished.
Meanwhile, absent a stay, the putative class action returns to the Los Angeles Superior Court to proceed in court. Because the arbitration agreement is unenforceable in its entirety, any class action waiver it contained falls with it, and the case can proceed toward class certification.
What it means for drafters, employers and claimants' counsel
For drafters of employment and consumer arbitration agreements. Scope language reaching claims "whether or not" related to employment, or reaching every affiliate, officer and agent, is the single most dangerous phrase in a California agreement after Cook and Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions. Tie the clause to the employment relationship or the transaction, add a sunset or a limit tied to the dispute's subject matter, and keep collateral confidentiality, injunction and restrictive-covenant terms out of the arbitration document's orbit, or make them mutual. A severability clause will not rescue an agreement whose central term must be rewritten to survive.
For employers with existing programs. Audit onboarding packets as a whole, not clause by clause. Bennett shows a court will read every document signed in the same transaction together. A confidentiality agreement drafted by a different team can turn a defensible arbitration agreement into an unenforceable one.
For claimants' and plaintiffs' counsel. Bennett supplies a published, quotable framework for opposing motions to compel: read the documents together, count the defects, and show why the offending language cannot be excised without reformation. Salazar supplies the defense's counter-framework, so briefs now need to engage both.
For mass arbitration practitioners. The same scope and duration drafting appears in consumer terms of service used to trigger mass arbitration programs. Where respondents seek to enforce such clauses, or claimants seek to escape them, Bennett and Cook give California claimants an argument against enforcement; where claimants want arbitration, respondents may invoke the same doctrine. The dissent's empirical attack signals that defense-side efforts to federalize the unconscionability question are intensifying.
FAQ
What is Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions?
It is a published California Court of Appeal decision, No. B346763, filed November 13, 2026 by the Second District, Division Eight. The 2-1 court affirmed an order refusing to compel arbitration of former call-center employee Tracie Bennett's wage-and-hour class action against VXI Global Solutions, LLC.
Why was the VXI arbitration agreement unenforceable?
The court held it substantively unconscionable because it required arbitration of nearly any claim against the company and its personnel, even claims unrelated to employment, for an indefinite period. Read with a confidentiality agreement containing a one-sided injunction clause and an unlawful nonsolicitation clause, the agreement was too permeated with unconscionability to sever.
Can a California court sever unconscionable terms instead of voiding an arbitration agreement?
Yes. Under Civil Code section 1670.5 and Ramirez v. Charter Communications, courts may strike bad terms if doing so does not require rewriting the agreement. Salazar v. CN Motor severed; Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions refused because the core scope defect could not be removed without reformation.
Is a lifetime or infinite arbitration clause always unenforceable in California?
No. Cook and Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions struck such clauses, but Ayala-Ventura v. Superior Court enforced a survival clause for a janitorial employer where unrelated disputes were unlikely and the terms were mutual. Context, including employer size and collateral documents, decides the outcome.
Does the FAA preempt California's unconscionability rule?
The majority held it does not, relying on Sonic-Calabasas A, Inc. v. Moreno and generally applicable contract law. Justice Wiley's dissent argued the majority used a method that disfavors arbitration and is therefore preempted, citing a survey of California decisions from 2021 to 2025.
Will VXI appeal to the California Supreme Court?
No petition has been reported. A petition for review would be due within 10 days after the decision becomes final, roughly 30 days after the November 13 filing, and the published dissent makes a petition likely.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Salazar v. CN Motor: California Appeals Court Severs One-Sided Terms, Sends Wage Claims to Arbitration
In Salazar v. CN Motor, published November 12, 2026, California's Second District struck an employer's overbroad and one-sided arbitration terms instead of voiding the whole agreement, and ordered individual arbitration of a worker's Labor Code claims. The class action waiver fight goes back to the trial court.
Courts Desk · 13 min

Cluck v. GEO: When a Confidentiality Agreement Makes an Arbitration Agreement Unconscionable
A California appellate panel refused to enforce GEO's arbitration agreement because a confidentiality agreement signed in the same onboarding packet sent the employer's own likely claims to a Florida court. The clause was never read alone.
Drafting Desk · 15 min

Tesla Arbitration Clause: Chronicle Finds 920-Plus Owner Cases Routed to AAA, Class Suits Blocked
A San Francisco Chronicle investigation published November 16, 2026 found Tesla's arbitration clause has sent at least 920 owner disputes to the AAA, more than twice the nine next-largest US automakers combined, and has scuttled or delayed at least a dozen class actions.
Courts Desk · 21 min