Domino's Arbitration Ruling: Seattle Judge Finds Warehouse Yard Driver Exempt From the FAA
In a Domino's arbitration ruling on November 16, 2026, a Seattle federal judge refused to compel a former warehouse yard driver's proposed wage class action into arbitration, holding him an exempt transportation worker under FAA Section 1. The fight now shifts to Washington law, where class waivers have fared badly.
Courts Desk··17 min read

A Seattle federal judge on Monday, November 16, 2026, denied Domino's Pizza LLC's motion to compel arbitration of a former warehouse yard driver's proposed wage class action, holding that the driver belongs to a "class of workers engaged in foreign or interstate commerce" exempt from the Federal Arbitration Act under Section 1. The Domino's arbitration ruling in McClusky v. Domino's Pizza LLC, No. 2:26-cv-03189 (W.D. Wash.), keeps the case in court for now and pushes the fight onto Washington state law, where Domino's has already lost a class action waiver battle once.
The decision is short on public detail. The order was reported by Law360 the same day, and the written ruling was not available through public sources at the time of writing, so the presiding judge, the plaintiff's counsel and the precise wage claims pleaded are not stated here. What is clear is the holding and the fact pattern, and both matter. A yard driver typically moves trailers around a distribution center lot rather than delivering on public roads. If that job falls inside Section 1, the transportation worker exemption reaches further into the warehouse than many employer arbitration programs assume.
What did the judge decide in the Domino's arbitration case?
The court refused to send the case to arbitration because the plaintiff, a former warehouse yard driver, is a transportation worker whose employment contract Section 1 removes from the FAA. Without the FAA, Domino's cannot use Section 3 (stay) or Section 4 (order to compel) of the statute to force individual arbitration, and its arbitration agreement must stand or fall under some other body of law.
According to Law360's report, the judge made the Section 1 finding on Monday, November 16. The case was filed on September 4, 2026, and is docketed in the Western District of Washington under the Fair Labor Standards Act nature-of-suit code; Law360 described it as a proposed wage theft class action seeking overtime. The motion to compel was therefore decided roughly ten weeks after filing, which is quick and suggests the Section 1 question was presented on a limited factual record rather than after extended arbitration-related discovery.
Three features make this Domino's arbitration ruling worth tracking:
- The job is on-premises. Most Section 1 litigation since 2020 has involved drivers on public roads: Amazon Flex couriers, bakery distributors, and Domino's own tractor-trailer drivers. A yard driver works in the gap between the inbound interstate truck and the outbound local truck.
- The employer has lost this argument before. Domino's litigated the exemption to the Supreme Court and back in Carmona, and lost on remand in 2023.
- The forum is unforgiving. Washington courts have twice refused to enforce Domino's or comparable class action waivers in wage cases under state law, so losing the FAA likely means losing the waiver too.
Behind the Domino's arbitration ruling: the case and a parallel Washington suit
McClusky is not Domino's only live yard-driver arbitration fight in Washington. On August 31, 2026, Domino's asked a Washington state court to compel individual arbitration of a different former yard driver's proposed class claims alleging that the company's conflict-of-interest policy unlawfully restricted employees from holding second jobs, Law360 reported. Domino's relied on an arbitration agreement with a class action waiver that the worker allegedly signed at hire.
That suit sits within a wave of Washington class actions under RCW 49.62.070, the provision of the state's noncompetition statute that bars employers from restricting employees who earn less than twice the state minimum wage from taking an additional job, supplementing income with another employer, or working as an independent contractor, subject to narrow exceptions. The statute provides a private right of action for actual damages or a statutory penalty of $5,000, whichever is greater, plus attorney fees. The Washington Supreme Court's decision in David v. Freedom Vans LLC narrowed the duty-of-loyalty exception and helped trigger a run of handbook-policy class suits.
The two cases raise the same threshold question. If Domino's yard drivers are an exempt class of workers, the state-court motion faces the same Section 1 problem that sank the federal motion, and both cases then turn on Washington arbitration and unconscionability law. A yard-driver ruling in one courthouse is therefore persuasive, if not binding, in the other.
What is the FAA transportation worker exemption?
Section 1 of the Federal Arbitration Act, enacted in 1925, provides that "nothing herein contained shall apply to contracts of employment of seamen, railroad employees, or any other class of workers engaged in foreign or interstate commerce." In Circuit City Stores, Inc. v. Adams (2001), the Supreme Court read the residual phrase "any other class of workers" narrowly, limiting it to transportation workers rather than every employee whose work touches commerce.
Since 2019 the Court has repeatedly refused to narrow the exemption further:
- New Prime Inc. v. Oliveira, 586 U.S. 105 (2019): "contracts of employment" includes independent contractor agreements, and a court must decide whether Section 1 applies before it can compel arbitration, even when the agreement contains a delegation clause.
- Southwest Airlines Co. v. Saxon, 596 U.S. 450 (2022): set the two-step test. First, define the relevant "class of workers" by the work they actually perform; second, ask whether that class is engaged in foreign or interstate commerce. A ramp supervisor who frequently loaded and unloaded cargo on airplanes traveling interstate qualified, even though she never left the airport.
- Bissonnette v. LePage Bakeries Park St., LLC, 601 U.S. 246 (2024): a worker need not be employed by a company in the transportation industry; the inquiry looks at the worker's duties, not the employer's business.
- Flowers Foods, Inc. v. Brock (May 28, 2026): a unanimous Court, in an opinion by Justice Neil Gorsuch, held that a driver whose deliveries stay inside one state can qualify when those deliveries are the final leg of an interstate journey, and rejected the employer's bright-line rule requiring that the worker cross state lines or directly load vehicles that do.
The practical result is that the exemption is a question of job function and of where goods are in their journey. It is not a question of whether the worker's truck, or the worker, ever leaves the state.
Why is a Domino's yard driver exempt from the Federal Arbitration Act?
A yard driver is exempt when the class of workers he belongs to moves goods that are still in interstate transit, so that their work is a necessary link in the interstate journey rather than a step after the journey has ended. Under Saxon, the court first identifies what yard drivers at the facility actually do; under Flowers Foods and Ninth Circuit precedent, it then asks whether the goods they move have come to rest in the state or are still moving through the supply chain.
Domino's supply chain centers are the hub of that chain. As the Ninth Circuit described the California operation in Carmona, Domino's buys ingredients and supplies from out-of-state vendors, receives them at a supply chain center, and then sends them by truck to franchisee stores inside the state. The court held in 2023 that the drivers carrying goods on that last intrastate leg were engaged in interstate commerce because the goods were on a continuous journey from out-of-state suppliers to stores, and the supply center was a waypoint, not a destination.
A yard driver works one step upstream of those delivery drivers. In a typical distribution yard, the yard driver (often called a yard hostler or yard jockey) uses a specialized tractor to move loaded trailers from the gate or the staging lot to the dock doors, and to pull outbound trailers into position for the road drivers. If the road driver hauling ingredients from the center to a store is part of an interstate journey, the employee who positioned that same trailer at the dock is, on Saxon's logic, doing transportation work on the same journey, just as Latrice Saxon did by loading cargo onto a plane she never flew.
Two strands of authority support that reading:
- Ninth Circuit warehouse precedent. In Ortiz v. Randstad Inhouse Services, LLC, 95 F.4th 1152 (9th Cir. 2024), the court held that a warehouse worker who moved goods within a California facility qualified because his work sat "near the very heart of [the] supply chain." The court applied Saxon's two steps and found that unloading and moving goods inside a warehouse, as goods passed from interstate carriers toward their final destinations, was sufficiently connected to interstate transportation.
- The California yard-hostler decision. In Doss v. Tesla, No. A173210 (Cal. Ct. App. June 11, 2026), the First District Court of Appeal held that yard hostlers who moved 53-foot trailers of auto parts around Tesla's Fremont factory grounds were exempt transportation workers even though they never left the property. The court declined to adopt a bright-line "come to rest" rule and treated the end point of interstate commerce as a fact-specific inquiry.
McClusky applies the same reasoning in federal court in Washington, within the circuit that decided Rittmann v. Amazon.com, Inc., 971 F.3d 904 (9th Cir. 2020), the last-mile driver case that itself began in the Western District of Washington.
Do warehouse workers who never leave the facility qualify for the Section 1 exemption?
Some do. Workers who physically load, unload or move goods that are still in interstate transit have repeatedly qualified, while workers whose duties are clerical, supervisory without hands-on cargo handling, or performed after goods have come to rest generally have not. The decisive questions are what the class of workers typically does and whether the goods they handle are still on an interstate journey.
The scorecard below sets out the rulings most relevant to Domino's position and to on-site transportation work.
| Case | Court and date | Workers | Moved beyond facility? | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rittmann v. Amazon.com | 9th Cir., 2020 | Amazon Flex last-mile drivers | Yes, local roads only | Exempt |
| Lopez v. Cintas Corp. | 5th Cir., 2022 | Local delivery driver after goods reached warehouse | Yes, local roads only | Not exempt (contrary view the Ninth Circuit noted) |
| Southwest Airlines v. Saxon | U.S. Supreme Court, 2022 | Ramp supervisor loading cargo | No | Exempt |
| Oakley v. Domino's Pizza | Wash. Ct. App., 2022 | Domino's supply chain drivers, Kent center | Yes | FAA did not apply; class waiver unconscionable under state law |
| Carmona v. Domino's Pizza (remand) | 9th Cir., July 21, 2023 | Domino's supply chain drivers to franchisees | Yes, intrastate | Exempt |
| Ortiz v. Randstad | 9th Cir., Mar. 12, 2024 | Warehouse associate moving goods | No | Exempt |
| Flowers Foods v. Brock | U.S. Supreme Court, May 28, 2026 | Bakery distributor, intrastate routes | Yes, intrastate | Exempt; bright-line rule rejected |
| Doss v. Tesla | Cal. Ct. App., June 11, 2026 | Factory yard hostlers | No | Exempt |
| Joyner v. Frontier Airlines | 10th Cir., Sept. 1, 2026 | Airport customer service agents | No | Reversed; remanded to define the class by typical duties |
| McClusky v. Domino's Pizza | W.D. Wash., Nov. 16, 2026 | Warehouse yard driver | Reported as on-site yard work | Exempt; motion to compel denied |
Two cautions run through this table. First, the Tenth Circuit's decision in Joyner v. Frontier Airlines warned that courts must define the class by what workers in the role typically do, not by what the named plaintiffs happened to do. An employer arguing that its yard drivers mostly shuffle empty trailers, or move goods that have already been broken down and repackaged, can use that framing. Second, the Fifth Circuit's view in Lopez v. Cintas, under which interstate commerce can end when goods arrive at a local warehouse, has not been adopted in the Ninth Circuit, but it shows that the "come to rest" question is still contested nationally.
How does Flowers Foods v. Brock affect Domino's drivers?
Flowers Foods makes Domino's position harder everywhere, not just in the Ninth Circuit. By holding unanimously that an intrastate leg of an interstate journey can bring a worker inside Section 1, the Supreme Court effectively endorsed the core of the Ninth Circuit's Carmona reasoning and removed the most plausible basis for Domino's to seek further review of that line of cases.
The decision was also deliberately narrow, and that is where the remaining arguments lie. The Court did not adopt a rule sweeping all local drivers into the exemption, did not decide whether Brock was an employee or an independent contractor, and left room for arguments based on features of modern supply chains such as title passage, resale, and the point at which goods are transformed. For a company like Domino's, which runs supply chain centers that make dough and assemble orders, the strongest remaining defense argument is that some goods leaving the center are new products rather than continuing interstate shipments. That argument fits delivery drivers awkwardly and yard drivers even less well, because a yard driver typically moves the inbound trailer before anything has been unloaded or processed.
The Flowers Foods opinion also reinforces the federal reach of the trend. Before May 2026, an employer facing a Ninth Circuit loss could point to the Fifth Circuit and argue for a split. After Flowers Foods, the room for that argument is limited to facts the Court expressly left open.
Can Domino's still force arbitration under Washington state law?
Possibly in theory, but the odds are poor. A Section 1 exemption removes the FAA, not the contract: an employer can still try to enforce the arbitration agreement under a state arbitration statute such as Washington's Uniform Arbitration Act, RCW chapter 7.04A, if the agreement allows it. The obstacle is that Washington courts apply their own unconscionability law, and they have refused to enforce class action waivers in wage cases.
Domino's has already experienced this in Washington. In Oakley v. Domino's Pizza LLC, No. 82659-0-I (Wash. Ct. App. 2022), a former driver who worked at Domino's supply chain center in Kent sued over minimum wage and wage rebate violations. The Court of Appeals agreed that the driver was exempt from the FAA, held that the agreement's FAA choice-of-law clause was therefore ineffective, and found the class action waiver unconscionable under Washington law as an independent ground to deny arbitration. The Washington Supreme Court declined review.
Washington's appellate courts have since reaffirmed the approach. In a September 2025 unpublished decision involving warehouse workers at a logistics company, the Court of Appeals again refused to compel arbitration, treating class action waivers in employment wage disputes as unconscionable where individual claims are too small to pursue alone and treating the state wage statutes as conferring non-waivable rights. Earlier, in Burnett v. Pagliacci Pizza, Inc., 196 Wash. 2d 38 (2020), the Washington Supreme Court affirmed the denial of a pizza chain's motion to compel arbitration of a delivery driver's wage claims, finding no mutual assent to an arbitration policy buried in a handbook and holding the policy procedurally and substantively unconscionable.
The significance is structural. Under the FAA, Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis (2018) requires courts to enforce class and collective action waivers in employment arbitration agreements, and AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011) preempts state rules that disfavor them. Once Section 1 applies, those preemption shields disappear. A Washington court, or a federal court applying Washington law, may then treat the waiver the way Oakley did. For Domino's, the realistic best case under state law is individual arbitration of some claims; the realistic worst case is a certified class in court.
Can Domino's appeal the ruling denying arbitration?
Yes. FAA Section 16(a) allows an immediate interlocutory appeal from an order refusing to stay an action or denying a petition to compel arbitration, and both Rittmann and Carmona reached the Ninth Circuit that way. Under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 4(a)(1)(A), a notice of appeal in a civil case is generally due within 30 days of the order, which puts the deadline in mid-December 2026.
An appeal would also freeze the case. In Coinbase, Inc. v. Bielski, decided June 23, 2023, the Supreme Court held 5-4 that a non-frivolous appeal from the denial of a motion to compel arbitration automatically stays district court proceedings while the appeal is pending. That means no class discovery and no class certification briefing in McClusky until the Ninth Circuit rules, which in that court commonly takes a year or more.
The table below summarizes the likely next steps.
| Step | Mechanism | Timing | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notice of appeal | FAA § 16(a); FRAP 4(a)(1)(A) | About 30 days from Nov. 16, 2026 | Whether Domino's appeals or pivots to state law |
| Automatic stay | Coinbase v. Bielski (2023) | On filing a non-frivolous appeal | Whether plaintiff argues frivolousness given Carmona and Ortiz |
| State-law motion | RCW 7.04A, if the agreement permits | Alternative or after appeal | Unconscionability of the class action waiver under Oakley |
| Class certification | Rule 23 / FLSA collective procedure | After any stay lifts | Size of the yard-driver class and covered facilities |
| Parallel state case | Domino's Aug. 31, 2026 motion to compel | Pending in Washington state court | Whether the state court follows the federal Section 1 analysis |
The appeal calculus is unattractive. The Ninth Circuit has already ruled against Domino's on delivery drivers in Carmona, against a warehouse employer in Ortiz, and against Amazon in Rittmann, and Flowers Foods endorsed the reasoning that drove those cases. An appeal buys time through the Coinbase stay, but the merits path runs through precedent that has grown less favorable with each decision.
The Domino's arbitration ruling in context: what it means for employers, workers' counsel and drafters
What it means for employers with distribution operations
The Domino's arbitration ruling is a reminder that the transportation worker exemption follows the goods, not the job title or the paved road. Any company that runs a distribution center receiving out-of-state goods should assume that yard drivers, dock workers and loaders who handle inbound or outbound interstate freight may be exempt, and that an FAA-only arbitration program will not reach them. Retailers, restaurant chains with commissaries, grocery distributors and third-party logistics providers are all exposed. The question to ask is whether the company's arbitration program has a lawful fallback for exempt workers in each state where it operates, and whether that fallback survives state unconscionability law.
What it means for plaintiffs' employment counsel
For workers' counsel, the decision supplies a district court data point for on-premises yard work inside the Ninth Circuit, to sit beside Ortiz and the California decision in Doss. In Washington, the combination of Section 1 and Oakley offers a route to class treatment of wage claims that would otherwise be confined to individual arbitration. Counsel should expect employers to contest the class definition under Joyner's "typical duties" framing, so evidence about what yard drivers at the facility routinely do, and which loads they move, is likely to matter more than the named plaintiff's own shifts.
What it means for arbitration clause drafters
Drafters face a familiar choice. An agreement governed solely by the FAA falls apart entirely for exempt workers, as Oakley showed when Domino's FAA choice-of-law clause was held ineffective. An agreement that names a state arbitration statute as a fallback, includes a severability clause, and states expressly what happens to the class action waiver if a court will not enforce it gives the employer more options, though it cannot override a state's unconscionability law. Where class waivers are unenforceable under governing state law, some employers prefer a clear blow-up provision sending any class claim to court, rather than leaving the result to litigation.
What it means for mass arbitration strategy
Section 1 cuts both ways in the mass arbitration context. Employers that require individual arbitration of wage claims face the risk of coordinated mass filings by hundreds of workers, each triggering fees under the provider's employment rules. When a class of workers is exempt and state law voids the waiver, that pressure moves back to court as a conventional class action. For plaintiffs' firms deciding whether to organize mass arbitration campaigns against logistics and retail employers, the threshold Section 1 analysis now determines which tool is available: individual demands under the FAA for non-exempt workers, or a Rule 23 class and FLSA collective in court for exempt ones.
FAQ
What did the court decide in McClusky v. Domino's Pizza?
On November 16, 2026, a judge in the Western District of Washington denied Domino's motion to compel arbitration, holding that the plaintiff, a former warehouse yard driver, is an exempt transportation worker under FAA Section 1, so his proposed wage class action stays in federal court for now.
Why is a Domino's yard driver exempt from the Federal Arbitration Act?
Because Section 1 excludes the employment contracts of any class of workers engaged in interstate commerce, and moving trailers of goods that are still on an interstate journey through a supply chain center is transportation work under Southwest Airlines v. Saxon, Flowers Foods v. Brock and Ninth Circuit precedent such as Ortiz v. Randstad, even if the worker never leaves the facility.
Does the ruling mean Domino's can never arbitrate the claims?
No. It means the FAA cannot be used to compel arbitration. Domino's can appeal to the Ninth Circuit or try to enforce the agreement under Washington law, but Washington courts, including in Oakley v. Domino's Pizza (2022), have refused to enforce class action waivers in wage cases as unconscionable.
Can Domino's appeal the arbitration ruling?
Yes. FAA Section 16(a) permits an immediate appeal from an order denying a motion to compel arbitration, generally within 30 days, and under Coinbase v. Bielski (2023) a non-frivolous appeal automatically pauses the district court case.
How does Flowers Foods v. Brock affect the Domino's case?
The Supreme Court's unanimous May 28, 2026 decision held that drivers on an intrastate leg of an interstate journey can be exempt, which endorses the Ninth Circuit's reasoning in Carmona v. Domino's Pizza and narrows the arguments available to Domino's on appeal.
Do other warehouse workers qualify for the FAA transportation worker exemption?
Many can. Courts have held warehouse workers moving goods in transit (Ortiz v. Randstad, 2024), airline cargo loaders (Saxon, 2022) and factory yard hostlers (Doss v. Tesla, 2026) exempt, while the Tenth Circuit in Joyner v. Frontier Airlines (2026) stressed that the class must be defined by what such workers typically do.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Tenth Circuit Transportation Worker Exemption Turns on the Class, Not the Claimant
In Joyner v. Frontier Airlines, decided 1 September 2026 and now the subject of a wave of practitioner analysis, the Tenth Circuit held that a district court defined the FAA Section 1 class of workers too narrowly by asking what three named plaintiffs actually did rather than what their class typically does.
Courts Desk · 12 min

T-Mobile Price Lock Arbitration Ruling: Judge Sends Rate-Hike Class Claims to Individual Arbitration
In a T-Mobile price lock arbitration win, a Seattle federal judge ruled September 29 that customers suing over broken rate promises must arbitrate one by one, having accepted updated terms by continuing to pay after notice. The fight moves to the AAA, where a 25-claimant batching clause awaits.
Courts Desk · 17 min

SpaceX Arbitration Ruling: Ninth Circuit Rejects a Plausibility Test for the EFAA
In a 2-1 SpaceX arbitration ruling on November 10, 2026, the Ninth Circuit held that eight fired engineers can litigate in court because the EFAA asks only whether a complaint asserts sexual harassment, not whether it would survive a motion to dismiss.
Courts Desk · 12 min