East Palestine Settlement Appeal: Sixth Circuit Refuses to Undo Residents' Personal Injury Releases
On November 10, 2026 the Sixth Circuit affirmed Judge Benita Pearson's refusal to let 196 East Palestine residents out of the personal injury releases they signed under the $600 million Norfolk Southern settlement, rejecting every Rule 60 fraud theory.
Torts Desk··16 min read

The East Palestine settlement appeal is over: on November 10, 2026 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the refusal of U.S. District Judge Benita Pearson to release 196 residents from the personal injury releases they signed under the $600 million Norfolk Southern class settlement, holding that none of their fraud theories under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60 justified reopening a final judgment. The decision, In re East Palestine Train Derailment, No. 26-3499, means residents who took the personal injury payment remain bound by a release that covers future illness from the February 3, 2023 derailment, and it pushes the dispute over what class counsel told them into state-court malpractice litigation against the lawyers rather than the railroad.
The ruling matters well beyond eastern Ohio. It is the fourth time since 2025 that a federal appellate court has turned away a challenge to the deal, and it is an appellate answer to what the plaintiffs' bar calls the "Petty data" problem: testing results from class counsel's own expert that became public only after the settlement was approved and the releases were signed. For anyone who negotiates, objects to, or advises clients on a mass tort class settlement with a personal injury release, the opinion is a clear statement of how hard it is to unwind that release after the fact.
What did the Sixth Circuit decide in the East Palestine settlement appeal?
The Sixth Circuit affirmed Judge Pearson's May 1, 2026 opinion and order denying the residents' motions for relief from judgment, reviewing that denial only for abuse of discretion. The panel concluded that the movants failed under each of the three provisions they invoked: Rule 60(b)(3) (fraud, misrepresentation or misconduct by an opposing party), Rule 60(d)(3) (the court's inherent power to set aside a judgment for fraud on the court), and Rule 60(b)(6) (the catch-all for extraordinary circumstances).
Put in one sentence for anyone searching the East Palestine settlement appeal: the court held that what Norfolk Southern said came too late to have induced the releases, that what class counsel said and did not say was not fraud on the court, and that the residents' disappointment with how the settlement turned out is not the kind of extraordinary circumstance that reopens a class judgment.
According to Law360's account of the decision, the practical effect is that Ohio residents who waived their personal injury claims in exchange for extra settlement payments cannot reclaim the right to sue the railroad. Mealey's reported the same outcome on November 12, 2026, describing it as an affirmance of the denial of relief from the personal injury payment releases.
Who were the judges on the Sixth Circuit panel?
Judge Amul Thapar wrote the opinion for a panel that also included Judges Chad Readler and Whitney Hermandorfer. The same court has now handled every major appellate fight over this settlement. Judge Thapar also wrote the November 2025 opinion that dismissed the original objectors' appeals, and Judge Readler wrote the November 25, 2025 opinion on attorneys' fees. The appeal came from the Northern District of Ohio, Eastern Division, where Judge Pearson has presided over the consolidated litigation, docketed as No. 4:23-cv-00242, since 2023.
How the East Palestine settlement reached a fourth appeal
The litigation arises from the February 3, 2023 derailment of a Norfolk Southern freight train carrying hazardous materials, including vinyl chloride, on the Ohio–Pennsylvania border, and the controlled vent-and-burn that followed. Residents filed a consolidated class action in the Northern District of Ohio. The parties reached a $600 million class settlement covering residents, households and businesses in the surrounding area, with a separate personal injury component available to people who lived within 10 miles and who agreed to release injury claims.
Judge Pearson held the final approval hearing on September 25, 2024 and entered final approval on September 27, 2024, according to the court-approved settlement website. More than 55,000 claims were filed. Class counsel sought, and the court approved, attorneys' fees of 27% of the fund, or $162 million, plus up to $18 million in expenses.
Since then, the settlement has been challenged on every available track:
| Date | Forum | Challenge | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sept. 27, 2024 | N.D. Ohio (Pearson, J.) | Final approval; objections that the deal was rushed and collusive | Settlement approved; fee award of $162M (27%) plus expenses |
| Nov. 2025 | Sixth Circuit (Thapar, J.) | Objectors' appeals of final approval | Dismissed for failure to post an $850,000 appeal bond |
| Nov. 25, 2025 | Sixth Circuit (Readler, J.) | Morgan & Morgan's fee and quick-pay appeal | Largely affirmed; firm lacked standing on quick-pay; narrow remand on its $7.7M share |
| Mar. 2, 2026 | U.S. Supreme Court | Certiorari petition from objectors | Denied |
| May 1, 2026 | N.D. Ohio (Pearson, J.) | Rule 60 motions by 196 residents to rescind personal injury releases | Denied |
| Sept.–Oct. 2026 | Columbiana County C.P. (Ohio) | About ten malpractice, fiduciary duty and fraud suits against class counsel, Dr. Arch Carson and Rebuttal PR | Pending |
| Nov. 10, 2026 | Sixth Circuit (Thapar, J.) | Appeal of Rule 60 denial, No. 26-3499 | Affirmed |
The November 2025 objector ruling noted that fewer than 0.01% of class members had objected and that the unpaid bond was holding up distributions to tens of thousands of claimants. That background mattered in this round too. The Sixth Circuit observed that the district court acted within its discretion by declining to revisit a settlement that "largely satisfied" the class.
Why did the court reject the fraud claims against class counsel and Norfolk Southern?
The residents' motions rested on two sets of actors and three procedural vehicles. The panel addressed each in turn.
Rule 60(b)(3): Norfolk Southern's statements came too late
Rule 60(b)(3) lets a court relieve a party from a final judgment for "fraud (whether previously called intrinsic or extrinsic), misrepresentation, or misconduct by an opposing party." The movants argued that Norfolk Southern misled them. The statements they targeted, however, appeared in briefing filed after the settlement. The panel reasoned that because that briefing occurred after the settlement, it could not have induced the movants to enter the settlement a year earlier, so Norfolk Southern's statements could not satisfy Rule 60(b)(3).
The movants also pressed a concealment version of the argument: that Norfolk Southern hid evidence despite a duty to disclose, specifically by persuading the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to remove five entries from a list of chemicals the agency had asked the railroad to measure in East Palestine. The court did not find that theory sufficient to disturb the judgment. Notably, the movants did not appeal the district court's denial of Rule 60(b)(3) relief as to class counsel, so on appeal the (b)(3) analysis was confined to the railroad.
Rule 60(d)(3): no fraud on the court by class counsel
Fraud on the court is a narrow doctrine. In the Sixth Circuit it generally requires conduct by an officer of the court that is directed at the judicial machinery itself, that is intentionally false or in reckless disregard of the truth, and that actually deceives the court. It is reserved for corruption of the adjudicative process, not ordinary disputes between litigants.
The movants' theory was that class counsel misled the court at the fairness stage by presenting the settlement as fair while counsel's own environmental expert held views adverse to it, and by presenting Dr. Arch Carson as an independent voice in a video that a public relations firm had helped produce. The panel found that none of these theories held up:
- Statements at the fairness hearing. The court concluded that what class counsel told Judge Pearson at the fairness hearing was not fraud.
- The Carson video. The description of Dr. Carson as "completely independent" was made in a video shown to the class, not in a representation to the court, so it was not directed at the judicial machinery.
- Post-approval evidence. The residents' new evidence, which emerged after the court approved the settlement, cannot by itself ground a fraud-on-the-court theory. Standing alone, it does not suggest that counsel lied to the court before approval.
- No evidentiary showing. The movants made no evidentiary showing of fraud by class counsel or by Norfolk Southern.
Rule 60(b)(6): no extraordinary circumstances
The catch-all provision allows relief for "any other reason that justifies relief," but courts apply it only in extraordinary circumstances and not as a substitute for the more specific grounds in Rule 60(b)(1) through (5). The panel held that extraordinary relief was not warranted. The district court had applied the same standard and found it unmet.
| Theory | Target | What the movants argued | Why it failed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rule 60(b)(3) | Norfolk Southern | Railroad misrepresented risks and concealed data, including by narrowing the EPA chemical list | Statements came in post-settlement briefing and could not have induced releases signed a year earlier |
| Rule 60(b)(3) | Class counsel | Counsel's misconduct induced releases | Not appealed; district court's ruling stands |
| Rule 60(d)(3) | Class counsel | Fairness-hearing statements and undisclosed RebuttalPR role misled the court | Statements were not fraud; Carson "independent" label was made to the class, not the court; post-approval evidence cannot ground the theory; no evidentiary showing |
| Rule 60(b)(6) | All | Extraordinary circumstances justify reopening | Standard not met; no abuse of discretion |
Does the Petty testing data change the East Palestine settlement?
No, at least not in federal court. The Sixth Circuit held that evidence surfacing after approval could not establish fraud on the court, which was the residents' route for using it.
The "Petty data" refers to environmental testing by Stephen Petty, an industrial hygienist whom class counsel retained as their testing expert. In reporting first published by NewsNation and republished by The Hill in late summer 2026, Petty said that somewhere between 50% and 70% of his data points for dioxins or polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons exceeded screening levels for cancer. Exceeding a screening level is not a finding of harm; it signals that further study is warranted. Residents say they never saw those results before deciding whether to sign the personal injury release, and the movants' Sixth Circuit brief argued that class counsel's own expert held opinions materially adverse to the settlement that were not disclosed before class members opted in.
Judge Pearson had already rejected a version of this argument in the district court. She wrote that "simply asserting that there may be conflicting opinions among professionals about the severity of the health risks does not result in fraud," and found that concerns about dioxins and long-term health effects had been discussed in public filings and news reports for months before residents signed. The Sixth Circuit's reasoning closes the loop: even if the Petty results are as significant as residents believe, the question for Rule 60(d)(3) is whether counsel deceived the court, and evidence that came to light later does not prove that on its own.
The RebuttalPR video and the duty to disclose
The most practitioner-relevant passage concerns the PR firm. RebuttalPR, a litigation communications firm, supplied an edited version of a video featuring Dr. Arch Carson, a physician and environmental toxicologist, which class counsel played for residents at a town hall about the settlement. In the video, Carson told residents the exposure level was low enough that no cancers or other adverse health effects were expected, while acknowledging the risk was not zero. Emails in the record show RebuttalPR transmitting the edited video to class counsel.
The movants argued that counsel should have told the court about RebuttalPR's role. The Sixth Circuit held that class counsel had no duty to disclose it. The court added that a class member who watched counsel introduce Dr. Carson and play the video would have understood that counsel had arranged the presentation. Judge Pearson, for her part, had noted that Carson was not paid and that his assessment was consistent with other studies.
That holding draws a line between two different questions. Whether class counsel's communications with class members were accurate, complete and in their clients' interest is a question of professional duty, which can be tested in a malpractice or fiduciary duty suit. Whether counsel defrauded the court is a question about the integrity of the judgment, and the Sixth Circuit held the record did not show that.
How much are East Palestine personal injury settlement payments?
The personal injury fund within the $600 million settlement was fixed at $120 million. In July 2024, before the opt-in deadline, lead counsel raised the projected payment for people who lived within two miles of the derailment to $25,000, up from an original estimate of $10,000. Because the fund did not grow as sign-ups increased, actual payments fell well short of those projections.
The settlement administrator, Epiq, began issuing partial personal injury payments in December 2025 and said it could not yet determine the full value of individual claims. By April 2026, Spectrum News and CBS Pittsburgh reported that Epiq put the average personal injury claim at roughly $12,400, less than half the $25,000 headline figure. Distribution was also slowed by a dispute between class counsel and the original administrator, Kroll Settlement Administration.
| Settlement figure | Amount |
|---|---|
| Total class settlement fund | $600 million |
| Attorneys' fees (27%) | $162 million |
| Litigation expenses (up to 3%) | up to $18 million |
| Personal injury fund (fixed) | $120 million |
| Projected payment within 2 miles (July 2024) | up to $25,000 |
| Average personal injury claim reported by Epiq (2026) | about $12,400 |
| Claims filed | more than 55,000 |
| Residents seeking to rescind releases | 196 |
That gap between projection and payment drives much of the anger behind the litigation. It is also why the residents argued their releases were induced by misleading information. The Sixth Circuit's decision does not address whether the projections were reasonable; it holds only that the residents did not show the kind of fraud that would let a court reopen the judgment.
Can East Palestine residents undo their personal injury releases?
Not through the federal settlement court, on the current record. The East Palestine settlement appeal leaves the May 1, 2026 denial in place, and the Supreme Court has already declined to review the underlying approval. The movants could seek rehearing en banc in the Sixth Circuit or petition for certiorari, but en banc review is rarely granted in fact-bound Rule 60 appeals reviewed for abuse of discretion, and nothing in the reported opinion suggests a circuit split.
The release itself is broad. Residents who opted in to the personal injury payment released Norfolk Southern and a long list of related entities from further liability arising from the derailment, including health effects that may develop in the future. A resident who later develops an illness and who signed the release is therefore unlikely to have a claim against the railroad, regardless of the diagnosis.
What options are left for East Palestine residents who signed releases?
The remaining route runs against the lawyers, not the railroad. In September 2026, East Palestine resident Austin Druckenbrod sued Mikal Watts, Russell Abney and the Watts Guerra firm, along with Dr. Arch Carson (doing business as Environmental Medicine Consultants), Stephanie Wolf and Rebuttal PR, Inc., in the Columbiana County Court of Common Pleas. That case is assigned to Judge Scott Washam and seeks damages above $25,000 plus punitive damages. About ten similar complaints, reported by Law.com on October 13, 2026, name class counsel including lawyers at Grant & Eisenhofer, Morgan & Morgan and Motley Rice and plead legal malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty and fraud.
Those plaintiffs do not ask the court to unwind the settlement. They seek damages from the people whose conduct, they allege, induced them to release valuable claims. Watts has previously said that residents who believed they had a personal injury claim worth pursuing were advised they could opt out and continue litigating.
Does the ruling affect the East Palestine malpractice lawsuits against the lawyers?
The Sixth Circuit did not decide the malpractice suits, and its holdings are framed around Rule 60, so they do not resolve state-law duties owed by lawyers to their clients. Defendants in those cases will nevertheless cite the opinion and Judge Pearson's findings. Expect arguments that the federal courts already found no fraud, that the health-risk debate was public before residents signed, and that class members could have opted out. Plaintiffs will answer that a fraud-on-the-court standard, which requires deception of the judge, is different from the duty of candor a lawyer owes a client, and that the Sixth Circuit expressly confined itself to whether the court was deceived. How an Ohio state court weighs the federal findings on issue preclusion, and on causation and damages, will be the next significant development.
What it means for practitioners
For class counsel in mass tort settlements. The opinion protects the finality of an approved settlement, but it is not an endorsement of every communication counsel had with the class. The court's statement that class members watching the town-hall presentation would understand counsel had arranged it suggests that transparency about who produced settlement messaging can matter later. Firms using litigation PR vendors, or presenting experts as independent, should assume that emails with those vendors will become discoverable in later malpractice or fiduciary duty litigation even when the federal judgment holds.
For defendants seeking global peace. The case shows the value of a fixed-fund personal injury release with a clear opt-out path, an appeal-bond request against objectors, and a thorough fairness record. Each of those features gave the Sixth Circuit grounds to hold the line. Defense counsel drafting releases in toxic exposure or environmental settlements will read the decision as confirmation that later-emerging science, without proof of fraud on the court, does not reopen a class judgment.
For personal injury firms advising individual residents. The decision underscores that the opt-in decision is effectively final. A firm advising a client on a settlement offering a modest personal injury payment in exchange for releasing future illness claims needs to address the latency risk directly, document that advice, and consider whether its own testing or expert work is consistent with what the client is being told. The fixed $120 million pool, which produced average payments around half the projected figure, is also a caution about communicating estimates before the claimant count is known.
For objectors and their counsel. Rule 60 is not a second fairness hearing. Arguments that could have been raised as objections to the settlement, or that depend on evidence emerging after approval, face long odds. The time to test expert data, communications strategy and allocation is before final approval, and the bond ruling in 2025 shows the Sixth Circuit will enforce the procedural cost of appealing.
For litigation funders and secondary-market buyers. Investors evaluating claims against class counsel in the Ohio malpractice suits should price in the federal findings: two levels of federal courts found no evidentiary showing of fraud, and Judge Pearson found the health-risk debate was public before residents signed.
FAQ
What did the Sixth Circuit decide in the East Palestine settlement appeal?
On November 10, 2026, in No. 26-3499, the Sixth Circuit affirmed the denial of Rule 60 relief to 196 residents who sought to cancel their personal injury releases under the $600 million Norfolk Southern settlement. The court found no fraud by Norfolk Southern that could have induced the releases, no fraud on the court by class counsel, and no extraordinary circumstances.
Can East Palestine residents still sue Norfolk Southern for health problems?
Residents who opted in to the personal injury payment released Norfolk Southern and related entities from claims arising from the derailment, including future health effects, and the Sixth Circuit's decision leaves those releases intact. Residents who opted out of the personal injury release were not affected by the ruling.
Why did the court reject the Petty testing data argument?
The court held that evidence surfacing after the settlement was approved cannot by itself establish fraud on the court, because it does not show that class counsel lied to the court before approval. Judge Pearson had separately found that concerns about dioxins and long-term health risks were already public before residents signed.
How much did East Palestine residents receive for personal injury claims?
The personal injury fund was fixed at $120 million, and while counsel projected up to $25,000 for people within two miles, the administrator Epiq put the average claim at about $12,400 in 2026. Initial payments in December 2025 were partial.
What happens next after the East Palestine settlement appeal?
The movants may seek rehearing en banc or file a certiorari petition, but the main remaining fight is in the Columbiana County Court of Common Pleas, where about ten malpractice, fiduciary duty and fraud suits against class counsel, Dr. Arch Carson and Rebuttal PR are pending. The narrow remand on Morgan & Morgan's share of the $162 million fee award is a separate, intra-counsel dispute.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

East Palestine Settlement Malpractice Lawsuits: 10 Suits Target Class Counsel Behind $600M Norfolk Deal
Ten legal malpractice lawsuits filed in Columbiana County, Ohio accuse the plaintiffs' firms behind the $600 million East Palestine derailment settlement of steering residents into personal injury releases while withholding their own expert's toxic-exposure data.
Torts Desk · 13 min

Maui Wildfire Attorney Fees Reach Hawaii's High Court — and $4 Billion in Payouts Waits
Hawaii's high court heard argument on 15 September over Maui wildfire attorney fees: Judge Cahill capped them at 3% to 10% and carved $222 million from the $4.037 billion settlement into a common benefit fund. Until the court rules, not one of 21,750 claimants gets paid.
Economics Desk · 13 min

Settlement Administrator Kickback Lawsuit: Epiq, Banks and Fintechs Move to Dismiss MDL 3162
In the settlement administrator kickback lawsuit before Judge John Bates in Washington, D.C., administrators, banks and prepaid-card fintechs say they owed class members no fiduciary duty and that plaintiffs lack standing. No ruling yet, but the case already reshapes how settlements are paid.
Courts Desk · 13 min