Maui Wildfire Settlement Payments: Only 6 to 8 of 20,000+ Claimants Opted Out of the $4 Billion Deal
Attorneys told a Nov. 20 status conference that only six to eight of more than 20,000 claimants opted out of the $4.037 billion Maui wildfire settlement. Maui wildfire settlement payments now hinge on administrators, not courts, and will be paid in installments over four years.
Torts Desk··14 min read

Only six to eight of the more than 20,000 claimants in the $4.037 billion Maui wildfire settlement have opted out, attorneys told a status conference on Friday, Nov. 20, 2026, which makes the deal one of the most complete participation results in any US mass tort. With the Hawaii Supreme Court's Sept. 30 fee ruling final and Hawaiian Electric already paying its installments, Maui wildfire settlement payments now depend on claims administrators moving money out of trust rather than on any court, and they will be spread over four annual installments.
The participation figure, reported by Hawaii News Now on Nov. 21, settles a question that has hung over the Lahaina litigation since the global settlement was announced in August 2024: whether enough survivors would accept it to make the deal hold. Attorney Jesse Creed, who represents fire victims, called the settlement "wildly successful in terms of participation." The handful who walked away now face mediation that attorneys said could delay their awards by more than a year.
What has not been announced is a date. Maui attorney Cynthia Wong said in early October that she expected claims administrators to begin issuing payments within two months of the Supreme Court's ruling. That window closes around the end of November, and no public source has yet confirmed that the first distribution from the roughly $1.1 billion in trust has gone out. This article sets out what the Nov. 20 status report means, what the money looks like after fees and insurer liens, and why the timing has slipped so many times.
How many Maui wildfire claimants opted out of the $4 billion settlement?
Six to eight, out of more than 20,000, according to attorneys at the Nov. 20 status conference. Against the 21,750 claimants counted in the fee proceedings earlier this year, that is an opt-out rate of roughly 0.04%, or about one claimant in every 2,700 to 3,600.
That figure is consistent with what was visible in June. When award notices first began reaching survivors, the Honolulu Star-Advertiser reported that every property insurer had elected to participate before a May deadline and that very few individual plaintiffs had opted out. The Nov. 20 tally confirms that the trickle never grew.
Two points about the number deserve care. First, it comes from attorneys speaking at a status conference, as reported by one outlet; no court filing quantifying the opt-outs has been made public. Second, the settlement has two distinct exits, and the reporting does not specify which one each opt-out used:
- The class opt-out. The $135 million Class Settlement Fund covers people who did not hire their own lawyers. Its court-authorized website listed an opt-out deadline of Oct. 7, 2025. Anyone who excluded themselves kept their own claims but gave up a share of the class fund.
- Rejecting an individual award. The Individual Settlement Fund, which holds the remainder of the $4.037 billion, pays represented claimants through award determinations. Notices began going out on June 17, 2026, and each one is an offer: a claimant has 30 days to accept or contest it. A Maui attorney told Hawaii News Now in June that the notice "is not an actual payment."
Either way, the practical outcome is the same. Virtually the entire claimant population has accepted the global settlement as the vehicle for compensation, which means the defendants' bargain for total peace has very nearly been delivered.
What happens to Maui fire claimants who opted out of the settlement?
They go to mediation, and attorneys said the process could delay their awards by more than a year. That is the only detail the Nov. 20 report provides about the path for opt-outs, and it should be read as a description of timing rather than of outcome.
The broader legal landscape for anyone outside the deal is narrower than it would be in most disasters. The settling defendants (Hawaiian Electric and its affiliates, Kamehameha Schools, West Maui Land Co., Hawaiian Telcom, Spectrum/Charter, Maui County and the State of Hawaii) bargained for a global resolution. Two Hawaii Supreme Court decisions then removed the biggest threats to that structure:
- On Feb. 10, 2025, the court held that insurers could not bring their own subrogation lawsuits against the parties blamed for the fire.
- On Feb. 10, 2026, in an opinion by Justice Todd Eddins, the court held that insurers could not intervene in the class settlement and that their exclusive remedy was a lien on settlement funds. Maui Now reported that the ruling left subrogation claims available only against a small group of policyholders who had opted out of the settlement agreements and the class action.
That second point matters for anyone weighing an opt-out in a future disaster deal. In Maui, opting out did not just mean forgoing a share of the fund; it potentially meant facing an insurer's subrogation claim without the protection that participants received under the insurer agreement.
When will Maui wildfire settlement payments be made?
No firm date has been announced. The best public estimate is Wong's: payments within two months of the Sept. 30 Supreme Court ruling, which points to late November or early December 2026. A Star-Advertiser editorial on Oct. 9 said payments could go out "within the next month or two." Settlement Insight, which tracks payout dates, reported as recently as Nov. 9 that no payout date had been set.
When the money does move, it will not arrive as a lump sum. Attorneys at the Nov. 20 conference said claimants with clear-cut damages will be paid in installments over the next four years. That matches the structure of the deal itself: the defendants fund the settlement in four equal annual payments, and the class FAQ warns that payments "may be paid in installments over the next 4 years or more."
Are Maui wildfire settlement payments made in installments?
Yes. Hawaiian Electric's share alone is paid in four equal annual installments of $479 million. The first was authorized on April 10, 2026, when the final condition to payment under the settlement agreements, dated Nov. 1, 2024, was satisfied after the subrogation insurers stipulated to dismiss their appeals with prejudice, according to the company's Form 8-K. More than $1.1 billion from the first round of defendant payments has sat in a Bank of America trust account since then.
The second installment is due in April 2027, and Hawaiian Electric is paying it early. On its third-quarter 2026 earnings call, the company said it had already prepaid $80 million toward that second payment and expected to prepay at least another $100 million before the due date, using proceeds from a potential sale of its remaining American Savings Bank shares and expected insurance recoveries. Management said the balance would be financed with straight or convertible debt. For claimants, the signal is that the second-year money is on track; for the market, it is a utility actively reducing a fixed liability.
Why have Maui wildfire settlement payments been delayed?
Every year since the fire, a different legal fight has stood between the trust account and survivors. The table below sets out the sequence.
| Date | Event | Effect on payments |
|---|---|---|
| Aug. 8, 2023 | Lahaina fire; 102 people killed | Hundreds of lawsuits filed in state court |
| Aug. 2, 2024 | $4.037 billion global settlement announced after months of mediation | Deal in principle; terms still being papered |
| Nov. 1, 2024 | Settlement agreements signed | Payment conditioned on resolving insurer claims |
| Feb. 10, 2025 | Hawaii Supreme Court bars insurer subrogation suits against defendants | Removes threat that defendants pay twice |
| Oct. 7, 2025 | Class settlement opt-out deadline | Class membership fixed |
| Feb. 10, 2026 | Hawaii Supreme Court bars insurers from intervening; lien is exclusive remedy | Clears class settlement path |
| April 2026 | Mediated insurer agreement approved | Insurers' recovery fixed at a percentage |
| Apr. 10, 2026 | Final condition met; Hawaiian Electric authorizes first $479 million installment | Funds move into trust |
| June 5, 2026 | Judge Peter Cahill caps attorney fees and creates $222 million common benefit fund | Fee appeal filed July 2, freezing payouts |
| June 17, 2026 | First award notices reach claimants; 30 days to accept or contest | Individual determinations begin |
| Sept. 30, 2026 | Hawaii Supreme Court upholds fee caps, strikes anti-appeal clauses | Last appellate obstacle removed |
| Nov. 20, 2026 | Status conference: six to eight opt-outs reported | Distribution awaits administrators |
Two of those obstacles were about insurers and one was about lawyers. None of them involved a challenge to whether the defendants owed the money, which is why the Nov. 20 participation figure reads less like a turning point than like confirmation that the remaining work is administrative.
Did the Hawaii Supreme Court uphold the Maui wildfire attorney fee caps?
Yes, in substance. In a unanimous opinion filed Sept. 30, 2026 in SCAP-26-0000484 and written by Justice Eddins, the court rejected an appeal brought by three attorneys and one fire victim. "Appellants are wrong on the power," the opinion said, holding that Maui Circuit Judge Peter Cahill had authority to set the fee schedule. Courthouse News reported that the court found the special proceeding coordinating the Maui fire cases had never formally closed, so Cahill retained jurisdiction to supervise fees.
Cahill's June 5 order replaced individually negotiated contingency fees, which under Hawaii law could otherwise run to 25%, with a sliding scale: up to 3% for most attorneys retained after the global deal was reached, up to 8.33% for most retained before it, up to 10% for cases that had been set for trial, and up to 12.5% only on motion in extraordinary circumstances. On top of that, he carved a $222 million Common Benefit Fund out of the settlement for lawyers whose work advanced every claimant's case. Lawyers had been positioned to collect close to $1 billion in aggregate fees; the order cut that to a fraction.
The court did not affirm everything. Mealey's described the result as a partial affirmance: the justices vacated three provisions that restricted review of fee awards. Cahill's order had declared that decisions of the Common Fee Review Board could not be challenged and that a lawyer who tried to appeal would forfeit any award from the fund. Those clauses are gone. Lawyers dissatisfied with their allocation retain a right to seek review, and Courthouse News reported that the court ordered withheld payments released.
Why the fee ruling matters for the payment math
Fees are not deducted from the first installment in full. Common benefit fees are scheduled to be paid in the second, third and fourth years of distributions, after determinations by a review board that includes two retired judges. That sequencing pushes more of the first-year money to claimants and leaves the lawyers' fight over the $222 million to play out over later years without holding up survivors.
How much is the Maui wildfire settlement and who is paying it?
The gross figure is $4.037 billion, the number filed by liaison counsel when the deal was announced. Hawaiian Electric's share is $1.99 billion, a little under half, including $75 million it had earlier contributed to the One 'Ohana Initiative. The other six defendants' individual shares have not been publicly itemized, and the State of Hawaii's contribution required legislative approval. The table below shows how the money is spoken for, using only reported figures.
| Component | Amount | Source and timing |
|---|---|---|
| Gross global settlement | $4.037 billion | All seven defendant groups, paid over four years |
| Hawaiian Electric share | $1.99 billion | Four equal installments of $479 million plus earlier $75 million One 'Ohana contribution |
| First installment in trust | More than $1.1 billion | Bank of America trust account since spring 2026 |
| Class Settlement Fund | $135 million | Unrepresented class members; also covers class counsel fees, service awards and administration |
| Individual Settlement Fund | Remainder of $4.037 billion | Represented claimants via award determinations |
| Common benefit fund | $222 million | Paid from installments two through four |
| Individual attorney fees | 3% to 10% of each award (12.5% ceiling on motion) | Per Cahill's June 5 order, upheld Sept. 30 |
| Insurer liens | About $249 million projected on nearly $2.2 billion in paid claims | 10% of ordinary claim payouts, 15% on certain exceptions; installments two through four only |
How much will insurers take from the Maui wildfire settlement?
About $249 million, on the insurers' own projection. The mediated agreement approved in April 2026 lets property insurers recover 10% of what they paid policyholders on ordinary claims and 15% on certain coverage exceptions, according to the Star-Advertiser's June reporting, which put the projected total at roughly $249 million on nearly $2.2 billion in paid claims. Honolulu Civil Beat had reported in April that insurers had paid $3.03 billion in fire claims by the end of 2025, $2.16 billion of it to people participating in the settlement. The insurer share comes only from the second, third and fourth installments, not from the first distribution.
What survivors actually net
The University of Hawaii Economic Research Organization projected in May that about $550 million in cash would reach households in 2026, with payments continuing through 2029 for a cumulative $2.8 billion. That estimate assumed roughly $1 billion in attorney fees and about $200 million in insurer liens. Because Cahill's schedule, now upheld, cuts fees well below the $1 billion assumption, the fee component of UHERO's deduction looks conservative on its own terms; the 2026 figure, however, depended on money moving in 2026, which has not yet been confirmed. UHERO economist Carl Bonham's caution still applies: the payouts cover losses that have already occurred, and for many survivors they will not cover all of them, particularly as rebuilding costs rise.
How the Maui opt-out rate compares with other mass tort deals
Participation thresholds are the hinge of nearly every global mass tort settlement, because defendants pay for peace and walk-away rights protect them if too many claimants stay out. Maui's result is unusually lopsided.
| Settlement | Reported participation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Maui wildfire global settlement (Hawaii) | 6 to 8 opt-outs of 20,000+ (about 0.04%) | Reported Nov. 20, 2026; awaiting distribution |
| J&J ovarian talc proposal (MDL 2738, D.N.J.) | About 87.5% signed as of October 2026 | Against a 95% condition |
| Eaton Fire compensation program (Southern California Edison) | More than 80% of offers accepted | Voluntary program; Nov. 30, 2026 claim deadline |
The comparison is imperfect. The Eaton Fire program is a voluntary, pre-litigation compensation scheme rather than a settlement of filed claims, and the talc figure measures sign-ups against a contractual threshold that triggers funding. But the contrast explains why the Maui result matters beyond Hawaii. Three features probably drove it: a single state-court special proceeding under one judge; two state Supreme Court rulings that cut off insurer subrogation suits and channeled insurers into liens; and a fee order that capped what lawyers could take, removing an incentive some counsel might otherwise have had to hold clients out for larger individual recoveries. Whether those features can be replicated depends on the forum, but each one is a lever that defendants and plaintiffs' leadership in the next utility-caused wildfire will look at closely.
What it means for PI firms, defendants, insurers and funders
Plaintiffs' personal injury firms. The Maui fee order is now an affirmed state supreme court precedent for a trial judge overriding signed Retainer Agreement terms across an entire aggregate settlement. Firms signing disaster clients in Hawaii should assume a Contingency Fee may be reset by the supervising court, and that the reset can turn on when the client was retained relative to a global deal. Firms elsewhere should expect defendants and objectors to cite the opinion when asking state judges to supervise fees in coordinated proceedings. The one concession to the bar, the restored right to seek review of fee board awards, preserves due process but not the fee percentages.
Utility and corporate defendants. Near-total participation means the defendants obtained what a Global Settlement is meant to buy. Hawaiian Electric's decision to prepay its 2027 installment shows a defendant treating the settlement as a fixed, financeable liability rather than a contingent one. For other utilities facing wildfire exposure, the Maui sequence (settle early, fund in installments, litigate insurer rights to an exclusive lien remedy) is now a tested template.
Property insurers. The insurers' recovery was reduced from full subrogation to a percentage lien paid late. The two Hawaii Supreme Court rulings mean that in future Hawaii disasters, insurers should expect their leverage to be a negotiated lien inside a settlement rather than an independent lawsuit against the tortfeasor.
Litigation funders and lenders to claimants. Payment over four years, with fees and liens loaded into the back three installments, changes the cash-flow profile of every claim. Funders that advanced money to survivors or to firms on the assumption of a lump-sum 2026 payout face a longer duration. The $222 million common benefit pool will also be allocated over years two through four, so firm-level financing secured against common benefit awards carries the same timing risk.
Claims administrators and courts. With the appellate fights over, administrators now own the timeline. The pace of first-installment distributions, the handling of Medical Lien resolution for injury claimants, and how quickly the handful of opt-out mediations proceed will be the next measurable signals.
FAQ
How many people opted out of the Maui wildfire settlement?
Attorneys told a Nov. 20, 2026 status conference that six to eight of more than 20,000 claimants opted out, roughly 0.04%.
When will Maui fire survivors get paid?
No date has been announced. Attorneys expected administrators to begin issuing payments within about two months of the Sept. 30, 2026 Supreme Court ruling, and payments will be made in installments over four years.
What happens if a Maui fire claimant opted out?
Opt-outs face mediation that attorneys said could delay their awards by more than a year, and they may be exposed to insurer subrogation claims that settlement participants avoid.
How much of the Maui wildfire settlement goes to lawyers?
Individual fees are capped at 3% to 10% of each award (12.5% only on motion), plus a separate $222 million common benefit fund, under Judge Cahill's order that the Hawaii Supreme Court upheld on Sept. 30, 2026.
Who is paying the $4.037 billion Maui wildfire settlement?
Hawaiian Electric pays $1.99 billion in four $479 million installments plus an earlier $75 million contribution; the remainder comes from Kamehameha Schools, West Maui Land Co., Hawaiian Telcom, Spectrum/Charter, Maui County and the State of Hawaii.
Do insurers get money from the Maui settlement?
Yes. Under an April 2026 agreement, insurers recover 10% of ordinary claim payouts and 15% on certain exceptions, projected at about $249 million, paid from the second through fourth installments.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Maui Wildfire Attorney Fees Reach Hawaii's High Court — and $4 Billion in Payouts Waits
Hawaii's high court heard argument on 15 September over Maui wildfire attorney fees: Judge Cahill capped them at 3% to 10% and carved $222 million from the $4.037 billion settlement into a common benefit fund. Until the court rules, not one of 21,750 claimants gets paid.
Economics Desk · 13 min

Eaton Fire Settlement Deadline: Edison's Nov. 30 Cutoff, $1.1 Billion Offered and a March Trial
The Eaton Fire settlement deadline is Nov. 30, 2026: survivors must submit claims to Southern California Edison's program by then. More than 18,200 people have used it and SCE has offered over $1.1 billion. The first bellwether trial is now set for March 8, 2027.
Torts Desk · 16 min

J&J Talc Settlement Participation Hits 87.5%: 313 Firms In, About 5,700 Claims Short of 95%
Lead plaintiffs' counsel told the MDL 2738 court that 313 firms holding about 66,500 ovarian talc claims have signed J&J's $5.5 billion deal, 87.5% against a 95% condition. Meanwhile a Boston jury is hearing a mesothelioma case the deal never covered.
Torts Desk · 19 min