Trooper Stroke Verdict Appeal: New Jersey Asks Court to Void $11.3M Award Over Good-Faith Immunity
On November 16, 2026, New Jersey asked an Appellate Division panel to vacate the $11.3 million trooper stroke verdict won by Cheryl Rhines, arguing the trooper deserved Tort Claims Act immunity. The appeal tests how far good-faith immunity protects officers who mistake a medical emergency for intoxication.
Torts Desk··11 min read

New Jersey asked a state appeals court on Monday, November 16, 2026, to throw out the roughly $11.3 million trooper stroke verdict won by Cheryl Rhines, a Jersey City woman who was arrested on suspicion of drunk driving while she was having a stroke. The state argues that Trooper Jennifer Albuja reasonably believed Rhines was intoxicated and should have been granted good-faith immunity under the New Jersey Tort Claims Act; Rhines' lawyer counters that the trooper's failure to follow her training defeats immunity and that a retrial could produce an even larger award.
The trooper stroke verdict appeal is now before a three-judge panel of the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. No date has been set for a decision. What follows sets out the facts, the arithmetic behind the competing dollar figures that have circulated since 2025, the immunity statute at the center of the case, and what the outcome would mean for personal injury firms and public-entity defendants.
What happened to Cheryl Rhines?
On October 17, 2017, Rhines, then 48 and a marketing executive, was driving to work when she began to feel ill and pulled onto the shoulder of a highway in Newark, reported as Route 78 westbound. According to her complaint, she was having early symptoms of a stroke. Dashcam footage described in the appellate briefs shows her asking repeatedly for help and telling the responding officer, "I think I'm having a heart attack."
The officer, Trooper Jennifer Albuja, was in her second year with the New Jersey State Police. She concluded that Rhines' disorientation, slurred speech and inability to stand were signs of impairment. The complaint alleges there was no odor of alcohol or other indicator of substance use. Instead of calling for medical help or taking Rhines to a hospital reported to be about five minutes away, Albuja arrested her and drove her to the state police barracks in Somerville, where Rhines was shackled to a bench in a holding cell.
Her lawyers say the detour delayed stroke treatment by about two and a half hours. Rhines was left with global aphasia, a severe impairment of the ability to speak and understand language. She has not returned to work and, according to her counsel, needs lifelong care and supervision. The lawsuit was filed in 2019 in Essex County through her mother, Mary Lou Rhines, acting as guardian ad litem, against the State of New Jersey, the New Jersey State Police and Albuja.
How much was the New Jersey trooper stroke verdict?
The short answer is that the jury found $19.1 million in total damages but held the trooper responsible for 60% of them, producing an award of roughly $11.5 million; after post-trial adjustments the judgment has been reported at about $10.9 million to $11.3 million. The range of figures in news coverage, from $10.8 million to nearly $13 million, comes from reporting different stages of the same judgment.
After a trial that lasted nearly a month, the Essex County jury returned its verdict on January 29, 2025. The gross award broke down into four components. The jury then found that 60% of Rhines' disabilities flowed from the delayed treatment and 40% from the stroke itself, which the trooper did not cause, and the award was reduced accordingly.
| Damages component | Gross verdict | At 60% | After post-trial adjustment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pain and suffering, disability, impairment, loss of enjoyment of life | $5,000,000 | $3,000,000 | $3,000,000 |
| Emotional distress | $6,000,000 | $3,600,000 | $3,600,000 |
| Future medical care | $6,500,000 | $3,900,000 | $3,900,000 |
| Lost income | $1,600,000 | $960,000 | $382,432 |
| Total | $19,100,000 | $11,460,000 | $10,882,432.20 |
The gross figures come from the plaintiff-side trial report; the 60% column is simple arithmetic and matches the $3 million pain-and-suffering and $3.6 million emotional-distress figures the New Jersey Monitor reported on November 16, 2026. The post-trial total and the reduced lost-income figure were reported after Judge Thomas Vena's April 2025 ruling, which adjusted the award for disability benefits Rhines had already received. The components in the final column add up to the reported $10,882,432.20.
The larger headline numbers have other sources. A February 5, 2025 order of judgment entered against the State, the State Police and Albuja produced the "$12 million" and "$12.9 million" headlines. Other outlets reported $11.2 million after adjustments for medical expenses and insurance benefits, and the New Jersey Monitor's appeal coverage uses $11.3 million. The order itself governs; the differences are a reminder that a verdict, an order of judgment and a judgment after post-trial motions are three different numbers.
Why was the $19.1 million verdict reduced?
The cut from $19.1 million came from causation, not from a cap. Because Rhines' stroke was not caused by the trooper, the jury had to separate the harm the stroke would have done anyway from the additional harm caused by the delay in treatment. It put the split at 60% delay and 40% stroke.
That approach tracks the apportionment New Jersey courts use when a defendant's conduct worsens an existing condition, the framework most associated with delayed-diagnosis medical cases since Scafidi v. Seiler (1990). In those cases damages are limited to the harm the delay added, and the jury assigns a percentage. Here the defense won a meaningful reduction on that issue at trial, and the 60% figure itself does not appear to be the main target on appeal.
The second reduction, to lost income, is consistent with the Tort Claims Act's collateral source provision, N.J.S.A. 59:9-2(e), which requires a court to reduce an award against a public entity by benefits the claimant receives from other sources, such as disability insurance. Unlike the collateral source rule in many private-defendant cases, that offset is built into the statute for claims against public entities, which explains why the lost-income line fell to $382,432 while the noneconomic lines did not move.
Why is New Jersey appealing the trooper stroke verdict?
The state's core argument is that Albuja is immune. Arguing for the state on November 16, Michael T.G. Long told the panel that the trooper reasonably and sincerely suspected Rhines was impaired, pointing to her disorientation, slurred speech and inability to stand, and that the trial judge was wrong to refuse immunity. He asked the panel to vacate the January 2025 verdict and grant immunity outright.
The state also sought narrower relief in the alternative. If the panel orders a new trial, Long argued, the jury should receive fuller instructions on immunity and on the difference between pain and suffering and emotional distress, two categories the state says overlapped and inflated the award. If the verdict stands, the state asked the panel either to reduce damages or to order a new trial limited to damages.
Rhines' trial lawyer, Dennis M. Donnelly, urged the panel to affirm. He argued that Albuja's deliberate indifference, negligence and failure to follow police training defeat any claim of immunity, and warned that a new trial would risk a higher award for the state.
Does the New Jersey Tort Claims Act give police immunity for a good-faith arrest?
Yes, but with an important limit. N.J.S.A. 59:3-3 provides that a public employee "is not liable if he acts in good faith in the execution or enforcement of any law." The same section then states that nothing in it "exonerates a public employee from liability for false arrest or false imprisonment."
The New Jersey Supreme Court has read the good-faith defense to have two routes. In Alston v. City of Camden (2001), it held that an employee can establish good faith by showing either objective reasonableness or subjective good faith. That is why the state's argument stresses both that Albuja's belief was reasonable given the symptoms she saw and that it was sincerely held.
The court has also limited the provision's reach. In Fielder v. Stonack (1995) it held that section 59:3-3 does not cover a police officer's negligent operation of a patrol car, and later Appellate Division decisions describe the defense as one a plaintiff can overcome only with proof of more than ordinary negligence where it does apply.
For the Rhines appeal, the statute frames three questions. First, was the conduct that caused the injury "enforcement of law" (the arrest) or something else, such as a failure to summon medical aid for a person in obvious distress, which is closer to the ordinary negligence that 59:3-3 does not reach? Second, if it was enforcement, does the false-arrest carve-out apply to an arrest made without probable cause of intoxication? Third, was immunity a question for the judge or for the jury, and were the jurors properly instructed on it? The state's fallback request for fuller immunity instructions puts that third question squarely before the panel.
How strong is the state's damages argument?
Overturning a jury's damages finding in New Jersey is difficult. Under Rule 4:49-1(a), a trial judge may grant a new trial only if it "clearly and convincingly" appears there was a miscarriage of justice under the law, and Judge Vena applied that standard in April 2025, writing that it "does not clearly and convincingly appear to the Court that there was a miscarriage of justice under the law." He also found sufficient evidence to support the verdict and rejected the state's challenge to testimony about the shackling, explaining that it gave the jury an accurate account of what happened.
On appeal, remittitur is reviewed against the standard set in He v. Miller (2011) and Cuevas v. Wentworth Group (2016): an award stands unless it is so wide of the mark that it shocks the judicial conscience. Total noneconomic damages of $6.6 million for permanent global aphasia in a woman who was 48 at the time of the injury are unlikely to meet that test on their own, so the state's better route is the duplication argument, that pain and suffering and emotional distress were compensated twice.
The Tort Claims Act already limits what Rhines can collect in ways that do not depend on the appeal. Pain-and-suffering damages against a public entity are allowed only where the plaintiff proves a permanent loss of a bodily function, permanent disfigurement or dismemberment above a medical-expense floor (N.J.S.A. 59:9-2(d)); punitive damages are barred against public entities; and no interest accrues against a public entity before judgment. The verdict was therefore already shaped by the statute before the appeal began.
Could a new trial increase the damages?
It could. Donnelly's warning reflects a real risk for the state. If the panel orders a new trial, a second jury is not bound by the first jury's numbers, and it could set damages higher, reapportion the 60/40 split, or both. Future medical expenses in particular tend to grow as a plaintiff's care needs are documented over a longer period, and roughly two more years of care costs will have accrued by the time any retrial is held. A full retrial on liability would also give the state the chance of a defense verdict, which is why it asked for that relief first.
Timeline of Rhines v. State of New Jersey
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| October 17, 2017 | Rhines has a stroke on a Newark highway; Trooper Albuja arrests her and takes her to the Somerville barracks |
| 2019 | Suit filed in Essex County through Mary Lou Rhines as guardian ad litem |
| January 29, 2025 | Jury returns $19.1 million gross verdict; 60% of disability attributed to delayed treatment |
| February 5, 2025 | Order of judgment entered against the State, the State Police and Albuja |
| April 2025 | Judge Thomas Vena denies new trial and adjusts the award to $10,882,432.20 |
| November 16, 2026 | Appellate Division hears the state's appeal |
| Pending | Appellate Division decision; no timetable announced |
When will the Appellate Division rule?
There is no deadline. The New Jersey Monitor reported that it is unclear how soon the panel will decide. Appellate Division opinions after oral argument commonly take several months. Whichever side loses can seek review in the New Jersey Supreme Court by petition for certification, so a final resolution could extend well into 2027 or beyond.
Can you sue the police for mistaking a stroke for drunk driving?
Yes, in New Jersey such a claim can proceed against the state and the officer under the Tort Claims Act, subject to its notice requirements, immunities and damages limits. The Rhines case shows the path: a negligence theory focused on the failure to recognize a medical emergency and get the person to care, proof that the delay worsened the outcome, and expert evidence to apportion the harm. Officers can raise good-faith immunity under N.J.S.A. 59:3-3, and the pending appeal will clarify how that defense applies when the arrest itself is the mistake.
What it means for personal injury firms and public-entity defendants
- For plaintiffs' counsel: The case is a model for medical-emergency-in-custody claims. The verdict rested on dashcam footage, a clear time gap (about two and a half hours) and expert apportionment of the added harm. Firms should expect the collateral-source offset in N.J.S.A. 59:9-2(e) to reduce economic damages and should build the noneconomic case accordingly.
- For public-entity defense counsel: The fallback arguments matter as much as immunity. Requests for separate, clearly defined instructions on pain and suffering and on emotional distress, and on which facts the jury must find for immunity, preserve the strongest appellate issues.
- For police agencies and insurers: Training on recognizing stroke symptoms that resemble impairment, such as slurred speech, confusion and loss of balance, is now part of the liability record, since Rhines' counsel argued that the trooper's failure to follow training defeated immunity.
- For claimants: Damages against a New Jersey public entity are shaped by statute: no punitive damages, no prejudgment interest, and a permanency threshold for pain and suffering. The headline verdict will rarely equal the amount paid.
This is analysis, not legal advice.
FAQ
What is the trooper stroke verdict appeal about?
New Jersey is asking the Appellate Division to vacate the roughly $11.3 million verdict for Cheryl Rhines and declare Trooper Jennifer Albuja immune under N.J.S.A. 59:3-3, or alternatively to order a new trial or reduce damages.
Who is Jennifer Albuja?
Albuja is the New Jersey State Police trooper, then in her second year on the force, who arrested Rhines on October 17, 2017, believing she was intoxicated when she was having a stroke.
Who represents the parties?
Michael T.G. Long argued for the state on November 16, 2026, and Dennis M. Donnelly represents Rhines.
Why do news reports give different verdict amounts?
The $19.1 million figure is the gross verdict, about $11.5 million is the 60% award, $10,882,432.20 reflects April 2025 post-trial adjustments, and the $12 million to $13 million headlines and the $11.3 million appeal figure reflect the order of judgment and later reporting.
Did the trooper cause the stroke?
No. The jury found the stroke itself responsible for 40% of Rhines' disabilities and the delayed treatment responsible for 60%, and only that 60% was charged to the defendants.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

McKinley Park Tree Limb Verdict: Sacramento Jury Awards Jogger $33.3 Million
A Sacramento jury found the city 100% responsible after a dead limb fell on Ph.D. student Michael Flynn in McKinley Park in 2020, awarding $33.3 million. The verdict turns on constructive notice and the absence of routine tree inspections.
Torts Desk · 10 min

Washington Prison Tuberculosis Verdict: King County Jury Awards $52.39M Against State DOC
A King County jury awarded $52,390,000 to 23 plaintiffs over the 2021 tuberculosis outbreak at Clallam Bay and Stafford Creek. Liability was settled before trial, so jurors decided only damages, and Washington's uncapped noneconomic damages left the state fully exposed.
Torts Desk · 15 min

Aldi's $2M Slip-and-Fall Verdict Puts Georgia's New Collateral Source Rule to Its First Test
Aldi used SB 68's collateral-source provision to put a Georgia slip-and-fall plaintiff's health insurance before the jury even though she had dropped her medical expense claim. A roughly $2 million verdict followed, and the trial bar now has its first look at how O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1.1 works in a courtroom.
Torts Desk · 17 min