Meta Privilege Sanctions Motion: MDL Plaintiffs Say 93% of Withheld Documents Should Have Been Produced
Plaintiffs in social media addiction MDL 3047 asked Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on Nov. 13, 2026 to sanction Meta, saying its own re-review found about 93% of withheld documents were improperly held back. They want the February 2027 jury told.
Torts Desk··13 min read

Plaintiffs in the federal social media addiction litigation asked Chief Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on Friday, November 13, 2026, to sanction Meta Platforms, saying Meta's own court-ordered re-review found that about 93% of the documents it re-examined had been improperly withheld or redacted as privileged. The Meta privilege sanctions motion asks the court to tell jurors at the February 2027 school district bellwether trial about Meta's conduct and to limit Meta's ability to fight plaintiffs' use of the late-produced documents; Meta says it acted in good faith.
The filing, first reported on November 16, lands in In re Social Media Adolescent Addiction/Personal Injury Products Liability Litigation, MDL No. 3047, the Northern District of California proceeding that holds more than 3,800 actions against Meta, Google's YouTube, TikTok and Snap. It is the culmination of a privilege fight that has run through most of 2026: a 73,841-document downgrade in March, a 300-document test re-review in September, the "privilege hats" hearing and the refusal of an AI review tool in October, and a special master protocol that has Meta re-examining roughly 170,000 documents at a minimum pace of 20,000 a week. This article sets out what was filed, what the 93% figure does and does not show, what relief a federal court can actually grant, and what the motion means for the February trial and for counsel on both sides of the Multidistrict Litigation (MDL).
Why are plaintiffs asking the court to sanction Meta?
The core allegation is that Meta used the attorney-client privilege to keep relevant business documents out of discovery. According to the motion as described by Reuters, Law360 and Bloomberg Law, lawyers for thousands of individual claimants and school districts say Meta withheld tens of thousands of documents on privilege grounds and produced them only after the court forced a re-review. They also allege that Meta's lawyers were involved in shaping the evidentiary record, a theme the plaintiffs have pressed since at least the spring.
Timing is the second pillar. The plaintiffs say the documents were due more than 18 months ago and arrived roughly three months before the next trial. That gap matters because fact discovery has long closed, expert reports have been served, and trial exhibit lists are being built. Documents that surface this late cannot easily be put to Meta witnesses at deposition, tested by experts, or folded into motions in limine without reopening parts of the schedule.
The third pillar is pattern. The motion arrives after the court itself criticized Meta's privilege practices in open court, after earlier sanctions threats in March, and after a separate D.C. court found probable cause that Meta sought legal advice to obscure potential liability for teen harms. The plaintiffs' argument is that the late production is not an isolated logging error but a litigation-wide practice that warrants a remedy visible to the jury.
What does the 93% figure in the Meta sanctions motion mean?
The 93% figure is the plaintiffs' characterization of Meta's own re-review results: of the documents Meta has re-examined so far under the court-ordered protocol, about 93% were, by the plaintiffs' account, found to have been improperly withheld or redacted. It is not a court finding, and Meta disputes the framing.
Three cautions apply. First, the re-review is still running, so the percentage describes documents processed to date, not the full population of roughly 170,000. Second, press accounts describe the denominator slightly differently, some as documents re-reviewed and others as documents previously withheld, and the motion itself is the controlling text. Third, a downgrade from "privileged" to "produced" can include partial redactions lifted, documents reclassified as not privileged, and documents released for reasons other than a finding that the original call was wrong. Even so, the plaintiffs also cite the special master's weekly sampling, which reportedly found that some documents Meta still treats as privileged should be disclosed. A figure in the 90s, generated by the producing party's own reviewers, is unusually strong evidence for a sanctions movant, which is why it leads every report of the filing.
What sanctions are plaintiffs asking for against Meta?
The plaintiffs ask for two remedies. First, an instruction or statement telling jurors at the February 2027 trial about Meta's handling of the documents. Second, an order limiting Meta's ability to challenge the plaintiffs' use of the newly produced materials, which in practice could mean restricting authentication, foundation, hearsay or late-disclosure objections to those exhibits.
Neither request is a terminating sanction. The plaintiffs are not asking the court to strike Meta's answer or enter default, and they are not seeking an order deeming facts established. The requested relief sits in the middle of the menu federal courts use when a party misuses discovery.
| Remedy | Typical source of authority | Requested here? |
|---|---|---|
| Fees and costs caused by the misconduct | Rule 37(b)(2)(C); inherent authority (limited by Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. Haeger, 2017, to fees caused by the misconduct) | Not reported as the lead request |
| Jury told about the conduct | Inherent authority; Rule 37(b)(2)(A) "just orders" | Yes |
| Bar or limit challenges to the evidence | Rule 37(b)(2)(A)(ii) (prohibiting supporting or opposing designated claims or defenses, or introducing designated matters) | Yes |
| Designated facts taken as established | Rule 37(b)(2)(A)(i) | Not reported |
| Striking pleadings or default | Rule 37(b)(2)(A)(iii), (vi) | No |
Reports of the filing do not specify which rule the motion invokes, so the table describes the general framework rather than the plaintiffs' brief. The framework still frames the fight. Rule 37(b) sanctions require violation of a discovery order, and an MDL of this age has many: case management orders setting production deadlines, privilege-log protocols, and the October re-review stipulation. Rule 26(b)(5)(A) separately requires a withholding party to describe withheld documents in a way that lets the other side assess the claim. Sanctions under the court's inherent authority, by contrast, generally require a finding of bad faith or conduct tantamount to bad faith in the Ninth Circuit, which is why Meta's good-faith defense is not merely a press line but the center of its legal response.
How has Meta responded to the sanctions motion?
Meta's lawyers told the court the company acted in good faith when it withheld or redacted documents, and a Meta spokesperson called the motion a litigation tactic by plaintiffs' lawyers designed to turn a routine discovery dispute into an advantage at trial. Meta has not been reported as conceding the 93% figure.
The good-faith framing tracks the doctrine. If Meta can persuade the court that its reviewers applied a defensible, if aggressive, view of privilege over in-house counsel communications, the inherent-authority path narrows and any Rule 37 remedy is more likely to be calibrated: extra time, fees, or targeted evidentiary rulings rather than anything the jury hears. Meta can also point to the fact that it agreed to the special master protocol, agreed to pay the special master's costs, and is meeting the court-ordered pace. Its formal opposition will be the place to watch for a competing account of what the re-review numbers show.
How the Meta privilege fight got here: a timeline
The privilege dispute has escalated in steps, each documented in the docket and in contemporaneous reporting.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Oct. 2022 | The Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation (JPML) centralizes the social media addiction cases as MDL No. 3047 before Judge Gonzalez Rogers |
| Mar. 12, 2026 | School district plaintiffs and state attorneys general say they will seek sanctions over Meta's "extremely belated production" of 73,841 documents downgraded off privilege logs after fact discovery closed |
| Mar. 25, 2026 | In the parallel California JCCP 5255 proceeding, a Los Angeles jury returns the $6 million K.G.M. verdict, 70% against Meta |
| May 18, 2026 | Magistrate Judge Peter Kang orders Meta to produce the original version of a disputed slide deck |
| May 2026 | Meta and co-defendants settle the first federal school district bellwether, Breathitt County (Kentucky), for a reported total of about $27 million |
| July 16, 2026 | The D.C. Court of Appeals denies Meta's mandamus petition, leaving in place a D.C. Superior Court crime-fraud ruling in the District's separate case |
| Sept. 2026 | Court orders Meta to re-review privilege calls on 300 documents selected by plaintiffs, who allege a "culture of privilege abuse"; plaintiffs ask for a special master |
| Oct. 9, 2026 | Hearing: Judge Gonzalez Rogers mocks Meta's "attorney-client privilege" caps and refuses Meta's request to use an AI tool for the re-review |
| Mid-Oct. 2026 | Retired Judge Suzanne Segal appointed special master; protocol approved for re-review of about 170,000 documents at a minimum average of 20,000 per week, Meta paying costs |
| Nov. 13, 2026 | Plaintiffs file the sanctions motion citing the 93% figure |
| Dec. 2026 | Meta's re-review must be complete by year-end |
| Feb. 2027 | School district bellwether trial against Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap |
Who is the special master reviewing Meta's privilege claims?
The special master is retired Judge Suzanne Segal, appointed in October 2026 to oversee Meta's re-review of roughly 170,000 documents it had withheld or redacted. Under the stipulated protocol, Meta re-reviews at a minimum average pace of 20,000 documents a week, and the special master each week examines a random sample of 200 documents that Meta still says should stay privileged or redacted. Meta and the plaintiffs agreed to abide by her findings, and Meta pays her fees and costs.
The Special Master structure is what produced the numbers now driving the sanctions motion. Because the protocol forces Meta to report reclassifications and lets a neutral test the residue, it generates a running, quasi-official record of how often Meta's original calls were wrong. That record is far harder to dismiss than a plaintiff-selected sample, and it is the feature of this MDL that other defendants will study most closely.
Why did the judge reject Meta's request to use AI for privilege review?
Judge Gonzalez Rogers refused to let Meta use an AI tool to speed the re-review because the tool's accuracy had not been tested and she was not prepared to rely on it without more information. Reports quote her telling Meta's counsel, "I don't trust AI obviously as much as you do," and Law360 reported that she noted it would take time to validate the tool. She suggested that such an argument might carry weight only with a model trained and tested with full disclosure.
The same October 9 hearing produced the litigation's most quoted exchange. Addressing caps Instagram had made for staff around its 2024 Teen Accounts launch, the judge said she had "never seen a company whose employees are so taken with the attorney-client privilege that they'd have caps made." Meta attorney Ashley Simonsen responded that the hats had nothing to do with whether outside counsel properly applied the privilege. The exchange is not evidence of anything, but it signals the court's skepticism heading into the sanctions briefing.
Does the D.C. crime-fraud ruling affect the federal MDL?
Not directly. The D.C. ruling arose in the District of Columbia attorney general's own consumer protection case against Meta in D.C. Superior Court, where Judge Yvonne Williams found probable cause that Meta sought and followed legal advice to obscure potential liability for teen harm research, triggering the crime-fraud exception for certain documents. On July 16, 2026, the D.C. Court of Appeals denied Meta's petition for mandamus, holding only that the trial court's ruling was not a clear and indisputable error; it expressly did not decide whether the ruling was correct.
That decision does not bind Judge Gonzalez Rogers, who applies federal common law of privilege in a federal-question MDL and state privilege law where state claims control. Its practical effect is persuasive and atmospheric: plaintiffs cited the Superior Court ruling in an earlier sanctions push, and documents released in D.C. can find their way into the federal record through ordinary discovery. It also strengthens the plaintiffs' narrative that Meta's privilege practices reflect a strategy rather than isolated mistakes.
What the Meta privilege sanctions motion means for the February trial
The next federal trial is a school district bellwether set for February 2027 against Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap. Tucson Unified and Charleston County are the districts slated for the 2027 bellwether slots. A Bellwether Trial in this posture is about public-nuisance and negligence theories that turn heavily on what the companies knew about youth harms and when, which is exactly what internal research and counsel-reviewed business documents tend to show.
If the court grants even part of the requested relief, the jury could hear that Meta withheld documents later found not to be privileged. That is a credibility instruction aimed at the company's knowledge defense, and it could affect any Punitive Damages phase. A narrower ruling that only limits Meta's objections to the new exhibits would still let plaintiffs use documents they had no chance to test in discovery with fewer foundation fights. A denial would leave the plaintiffs with the documents but without the sanction narrative. Each outcome shifts settlement value, and the first federal school district case, Breathitt County, settled on the eve of trial.
What it means for claimants' counsel, defendants and insurers
For claimants' counsel in any Mass Tort, the template is the sequence rather than the motion: build a record of downgrades, ask for a test sample, use the sample to obtain a neutral, and let the neutral's numbers carry the sanctions request. Counsel should expect courts to ask what prejudice flows from late production and to tailor relief to it.
For defendants, the lesson is that aggressive privilege calls over in-house lawyers' involvement in product research carry compounding risk. A high downgrade rate under a special master protocol can convert a logging dispute into a jury-facing issue. Defendants weighing AI-assisted privilege review should expect courts to demand validation data before allowing it in a contested re-review.
For insurers and coverage counsel, a sanctions instruction raises verdict risk and can complicate coverage for fee awards, which some policies exclude as sanctions. The coverage fights already running over the social media cases, including Google's California suit against AIG units, will absorb any change in exposure.
For state attorneys general and the JCCP plaintiffs, documents released through the federal re-review can be used in parallel proceedings subject to protective orders, which magnifies the stakes of each reclassification.
What happens next
Meta will file a formal opposition, the plaintiffs will reply, and the court may hold a hearing or refer factual questions to the special master. The re-review must be complete by the end of December, which means the final reclassification numbers will be known before the court rules. Judge Gonzalez Rogers could grant the motion, deny it, or defer relief until pretrial proceedings for the February trial, when the scope of any instruction can be fitted to the exhibits actually offered. A sanctions order against a party is generally reviewable only after final judgment, not by immediate appeal.
FAQ
Why are plaintiffs asking the court to sanction Meta in the social media addiction MDL?
They say Meta improperly withheld tens of thousands of documents as privileged, produced them only after a court-ordered re-review, and did so about three months before trial even though the documents were due more than 18 months earlier.
What does the 93% figure in the Meta sanctions motion mean?
It is the plaintiffs' account of Meta's own re-review results: about 93% of documents re-examined so far were improperly withheld or redacted. It is not a court finding and Meta disputes the characterization.
What sanctions are plaintiffs asking for against Meta?
They want jurors at the February 2027 trial told about Meta's conduct and want Meta's ability to challenge plaintiffs' use of the newly produced documents limited. They have not been reported as seeking default or terminating sanctions.
When is the next social media addiction MDL trial?
The next federal trial in MDL No. 3047 is a school district bellwether set for February 2027 against Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap. The next California JCCP 5255 trials are set for March and August 2027.
Can a court tell a jury about a party's discovery misconduct?
Yes. Federal courts can issue jury instructions about discovery misconduct under Rule 37(b) for violations of discovery orders or under their inherent authority, which in the Ninth Circuit generally requires bad faith or conduct tantamount to it. The remedy must be proportionate to the prejudice caused.
Has the judge ruled on the Meta privilege sanctions motion?
No. As of November 17, 2026, the motion was pending, Meta's opposition had not been reported, and Meta's re-review was still running toward its year-end deadline.
Published for legal professionals. Analysis and summaries only — not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by use of this site.
Read next

Meta Snap Social Media Addiction Trial Opens Oct. 28 as Both Seek Illinois and Mississippi Injury Rules
The second Los Angeles bellwether in JCCP 5255 puts two teens' claims before one jury on October 28, with Meta and Snap the last defendants after TikTok and YouTube settled. Their late push for out-of-state law could reshape causation proof and damages.
Torts Desk · 13 min

Snap Social Media Addiction Settlement Ends Second Los Angeles Bellwether Before Openings
Snap settled with teen plaintiffs S.J. and K.D.B. on Nov. 2, 2026, two days before openings in the second JCCP 5255 bellwether. Terms are confidential, Evan Spiegel will not testify, and the next California trials are set for March 2027.
Torts Desk · 11 min

Google AIG Insurance Coverage Lawsuit: Delaware Stays Insurers' Case, Sends Social Media Fight to California
A Delaware Superior Court opinion dated 21 September 2026 paused AIG's suit seeking a ruling that it owes Google nothing for the social media addiction cases, deferring to Google's action filed 16 days earlier in Santa Clara. Who pays for YouTube's defense will now be decided in California.
Torts Desk · 15 min